Released in 1977, Love Songs is another themed Beatles compilation around the obvious: the Beatles’ many love songs, with a particular focus on ballads. In this regard it’s kind of the slower, softer counterpart to Rock ’n’ Roll Music from 1976, aimed at an older audience – the simple cover art consisted of a faux-leather background, and the Beatles’ image was faux gold foil.
Sonically, the songs were presented with the left and right channels reversed, with the four Rubber Soul tracks – “Girl”, “In My Life”, “Michelle”, and “Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)” – appearing in slightly narrowed stereo. Three further tracks—”Yes It Is”, “This Boy”, and “P.S. I Love You”—used the fake stereo mixes prepared by Dave Dexter Jr. in the early 1960s.
To write this post, I once again assembled a custom mix of the album: the same running order as in 1978, but with a combination of the 2009 remastered stereo mixes and various Giles Martin mixes – the only mono song is “P.S. I Love You,” for which no genuine stereo mix exists… yet. (Give him time, he’ll do it eventually.)
On to the music:
Disc 1
Yesterday: Starting us off, slightly bewilderingly, is the penultimate track from the British version of Help!, the legendary “Yesterday.” I adore this song, and goodness knows I’ve had cause to think of it quite a bit over the years, when applying it to my own relationships. (Also, may I recommend a version from 2006 Grammy Awards? It really shouldn’t work, and yet…)
I’ll Follow the Sun: Another great Beatles ballad, but even here, it presents a somewhat more negative view of love than we’ve come to expect from the boys so far. In other words, this is the gentlest break-up song you could hope to have, though I’ll always associate it with footage of the band in Miami during their first American tour.
I Need You: George’s second song ever, it’s another uneasy song about love gone sour, as our protagonist (George himself) tries to get his girlfriend (Pattie Boyd) to cone back after a separation, explaining that he can’t make it through life without her. This is one of the last pure rock songs we’ll get from George before he starts getting really into Indian music – funnily enough, while the Help! film was being made.
Girl: I’ve never been overly fond of this song, mainly because of the hissing noises that come between repetitions of the title – they’re really loud on the stereo mix, so Young Lena would always get freaked out by them. Thankfully, the mono mix (which I’m listening to as I write this) has them much much quieter, almost to the point of inaudibility.
In My Life: One of John’s prettiest ballads, my personal favorite aspect of this song is the piano solo – it sounds like a harpsichord, but it isn’t! It’s a regular piano played at half speed, then sped up, a technique called varispeed. I used the exact technique once in an AUDI 2000 assignment in college, and my professor was really impressed! Thanks, George Martin!
Words of Love: A touching Buddy Holly cover, this song will now forever be connected to the day my fiancee sent me this song, completely out of the blue, when we first got together. I love you to the moon and back, Lykos. ❤
Here, There, and Everywhere: As well as being a Beach Boys pastiche, this is one of my favorite of Paul’s many love songs. It gets pretty heavy rotation in the Mactíre house, I can tell you that much! Apparently, Paul re-recorded this song for the movie Give My Regards to Broad Street, along with several other Revolver songs, and I can’t imagine why. You can’t improve on perfection, Paul.
Something: If there was ever any doubt that George Harrison had grown by leaps and bounds during his Beatles days, this should put those doubts to rest. Abbey Road was his happiest album, perhaps because he suspected that this part of his life was over. “Something,” as a love song, is one of the best ballads anyone ever did, and I appreciate it even more now that I’m engaged to Lykos.
And I Love Her: One of the prettiest love songs the Beatles ever wrote, this. The opening riff was apparently George’s creation, right on the spot – an earlier version on Anthology 1 lets us hear it on electric instruments, minus the riff, and I have to say, something really is lost without it. This song belongs on acoustic guitars.
If I Fell: One of my favorite John ballads, this song gets played early in the movie to cheer up Ringo, but nowadays I associate it with all the times I’ve listened to it with my girlfriend, since it’s part of one of our couples mixes. Sonically, it’s a wonderful display of John and Paul’s talent for harmonizing. That’s a sound you’ll never forget, even sixty years later.
I’ll Be Back: A more subdued album closer this time, as John and Paul share lead vocal duties on this acoustic-guitar driven track. It’s a surprisingly downbeat ending to what has otherwise been their most energetic record yet, something that speaks to their rapidly increasing maturity as musicians.
Tell Me What You See: I really like this one. After spending most of the album listening to songs where relationships are crumbling, it’s nice to have a song that’s about a relationship beginning instead. In this one, our narrator attempts to convince his would-be partner to start dating him. One imagines, given the running order, that the woman accepted, and the song immediately after this is the narrator’s exuberant joy at being in a relationship.
‘Yes It Is’: George breaks out his volume pedal for this song, the mournful B-side of “Ticket to Ride.” According to John, this was him trying to rewrite “This Boy” (down to the 3-part harmonies and a solo John section) but if you ask me, I think it’s more like the dismal sequel: the guy trying to warn the object of his affections away from That Boy has found a new love, but he’s failing to move on, to the point that he doesn’t want his new beau to wear red because it reminds him of his ex. Poor guy.
Disc 2
Michelle: When I first came out as trans around nine years ago (holy fuck nine years?!) I chose Michelle for my replacement middle name, entirely because of this song. I had hoped Paul might perform it when I saw him live in 2016, but he didn’t – maybe I’d’ve stuck with it if he had. (As it is, Fenrira Dukane fits me better anyway, middle name wise.)
It’s Only Love: One of about four traditional “love” songs on this album, even here the feelings are more complex than pure puppy love. Our narrator sings about a turbulent relationship, even as he admits that he’s still head-over-heels for her. It’s far from John’s best love song, but it’s got a good melody to it.
You’re Going To Lose That Girl: I’ve always really liked this song, mainly because of how it’s used in the movie: we join the Beatles pretending to record this song in a studio, in a haze of blue and purple light and cigarette smoke. (Because it’s the ‘60s.) It’s one of my favorite scenes in the whole movie, and the song is pretty great as well.
Every Little Thing: Another Beatles song that hits very differently in the throes of a relationship, when I think of the things my girlfriend does for me, my heart gets full. She writes me love poetry, she comforts me when I need comforting, she makes me laugh, she makes amazing quesadillas, she’s always happy to see me… we’ve hit a few rough patches in the past few days, but I know our relationship is strong enough to withstand them.
For No One: Paul again with a song about love, except this time it’s a story about the aftermath of a nasty break-up. I love the melody, the horn solo, the lyrics… they were all really skilled at writing break-up songs, Paul especially. John really liked it too, so I’d say I have good taste.
She’s Leaving Home: Another one of Paul’s classical music songs, and like “Eleanor Rigby” before it, tells the sad story of a woman… except the woman is real. Melanie Coe ran away from home in February 1967, and being well-to-do, her story attracted Paul’s attention. (John’s lines in the choruses, meanwhile, were things his aunt Mimi used to say – this is the same woman who thought John would never make a living from guitar.) I had this song in my head when I moved to Ithaca last fall – it’s intensely relatable. As good as it is though, I don’t have the faintest idea what the hell it’s doing here, it’s not really a love song except for the last verse.
The Long and Winding Road: An elegiac number from Paul reflecting on the disintegration of the band, it’s also the most contentious: in April 1970, after the song had been recorded, Phil Spector added orchestral overdubs and sent it to Paul prior to release. Paul was furious, and sent an angry letter in reply demanding that the changes be removed. He was ignored, and the single came out anyway, bringing an ignominious end to the band’s recording career. Fortunately, “Now and Then” exists, so it’s not the end of the story after all.
This Boy: “This Boy” has always been a favorite of mine, showcasing the gorgeous three-part harmonies of John, Paul, and George. You don’t get to hear it often, so when you do, it’s a real privilege. Only two other songs have them: “Yes It Is,” on Past Masters, and “Because,” on Abbey Road.
Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown): John’s acoustic ballad about an affair he was having, it’s still a lovely song, with lots of acoustic guitar and some great vocal parts from John and Paul. But of course, what ties it all together is George’s sitar part, the first recorded instance of his growing interest in Indian music. Just try and imagine it without it. You can’t, can you?
You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away: John doing another Dylan pastiche, only this time with flute rather than harmonica. No one is entirely sure what inspired the writing – John never spoke about it before he died, though some have claimed it may be about Brian Epstein, given that Brian was gay and that was illegal in 1965.
I Will: At the completely different end of Paul’s register is this touching love song, featuring my favorite melody of his. We don’t often get straight love songs like this on Beatles records anymore, so it’s nice to hear them go back to basics again.
P.S. I Love You: One of Paul’s first epistolatory songs, (he seems to really like this format) P.S. I Love You is the other Andy White song on the album. A tender ballad song that shows off how well he can sing those, I still really like the brief flash of his rock ’n’ roll voice on the phrase “You KNOW I want you to remember,” just before George’s delightful “Yeeeaaah” a second later. As an aside, this is one of four Beatles songs for which no true stereo mix exists: the album version of “Love Me Do” and the singles “She Loves You” and “I’ll Get You” are the others. But if Giles Martin has his way, that won’t be the case for long…
I do like the concept behind this album, and I think it strikes a good balance of actual love songs and break-up songs. Love, after all, is a multi-faceted thing, and everyone who listens to this album will be able to find something (ha) that resonates with them.
Having said that, there are a couple of songs that I don’t think really fit the vibe: “Long and Winding Road” and “She’s Leaving Home” mainly. Similarly, “You’re Going to Lose That Girl,” while a great song, probably belongs over on Rock ’n’ Roll Music instead. Solid effort though, all things considered.
Leave a Reply