Years ago, I wrote the following in the first chapter of Back to the Eleventh Hour: “I can remember exactly when I first watched The Eleventh Hour: Easter Saturday on YouTube, in about ten minute increments. Why YouTube? Because I lived in the United States, and BBC America wouldn’t be airing the episode until April 17th, a full two weeks behind the UK, and I didn’t want to be spoiled.”
“In subsequent weeks I’d follow the season by watching them on Sunday mornings, courtesy of a very illegal streaming site set up explicitly for the purpose of uploading full Who episodes online, because fuck you, cable.”
Four seasons later, time to update everyone on the means by which I watch this wonderfully frustrating series. The illegal streaming site upon which Series 5 was viewed got shut down between The Big Bang and A Christmas Carol, forcing me to actually watch the show on BBC America.
But that was okay because, starting with that Christmas special, BBCA started airing the episodes on the same day as the UK, meaning that for series 6 and 7, I could just buy the iTunes season passes for the new seasons, and keep up my little tradition of watching on Sunday mornings.
This approach carried me through series 8, though Last Christmas, as I had done with A Christmas Carol, The Time of the Doctor, and The Day of the Doctor, was watched live on BBC America in my mom’s basement.
And then came series 9.
To date, Peter Capaldi’s second season as the Doctor is unique, in that it was the only one that I watched in the United Kingdom. I was in Britain for a study abroad program, and so I stayed at the host school my alma mater partnered with at the time, since Webster didn’t have a British campus of their own.
I went to Regent’s University London, situated right in the middle of Regent’s Park. The campus was surprisingly small from what I remember, and unlike American schools where everything is spread out into different buildings that were separate from each other, all of Regent’s buildings were connected by hallways, meaning that I could go from my dorm to breakfast, class, and back again and never actually set paw outside unless I wanted to. (But I always wanted to, because even back then, I was pagan as fuck. I just didn’t know it yet!)
I was there from August to December of 2015, which meant I got to see all of the ninth season of Doctor Who on BBC iPlayer. (Except for one week in particular, when I watched it live on BBC 1… but we’ll get to that in a couple weeks.) Prior to the start of the season, I visited Abbey Road, though not on the same day as Peter Capaldi and Jenna Coleman. (I was in class, if I remember right.)
Of somewhat more relevance to this week’s two-parter was my viewing of one story in particular: 1975’s Genesis of the Daleks. Regent’s had a copy of the episode on DVD in the library, so after reconfiguring my Mac’s disc drive to play region 2 DVDs, I watched Genesis for the first time, in glorious 480p resolution.
Why Genesis? I knew there would be Daleks, and I was reasonably certain (or maybe I knew already) that the action of the story would be taking place on Skaro, and I wanted to be prepared for what lay ahead. If I recall correctly, I watched Genesis on September 18th 2015, the day before The Magician’s Apprentice, and I was absolutely spellbound. I think I binged the whole thing, and when it was over, I simply sat back in awe. It really is as good as everyone says!
Needless to say, that was perfect prep work for Magician’s Apprentice, which opens on a foggy Skarosian battlefield that looked, for all the world, like a cinematic remake of Genesis. Then the Doctor arrives, and he does his usual “rescue the kid by talking to him so he can escape on his own” thing… and then he discovers that the kid is named Davros.
And that, ladies and gentlethems, leads us into what is, in my opinion, the Moffat era’s best ever Dalek story. If we still did one title for multi-part episodes, I’d want to call it The Genesis of Davros. (Maybe for the eventual novelization?)
Part of what makes Apprentice/Witch work so well is the way in which it centers on, basically, the Doctor and Davros sitting in a room conversing about morality and ethics. You wouldn’t think television like that could be compelling, but it all comes down to the masterful performances of Peter Capaldi and Julian Bleach – those two could make anything look compelling.
Honest to Goddess, Bleach actually managed to make me feel sympathy for our favorite wrinkled fictional fascist. I even laughed at the joke they shared, because it was really funny! (I also quite enjoyed “the only other chair on Skaro,” and the refusal to explain where the Doctor was able to procure a cup of tea.)
But more than the Doctor-Davros stuff, (which, IMO, is miles more interesting than what we got in Stolen Earth/Journey’s End) what appeals to me about Magician/Witch is the way it all harkens back to, of all things, Moffat’s first-ever Doctor Who story – The Curse of Fatal Death. Broadcast in 1999 as a Comic Relief special, Fatal Death isn’t a Doctor Who spoof per se, but something that feels like an actual episode of 1970s Doctor Who, just with a larger quantity of jokes.
In both stories, we have the Master sharing screen time with Daleks, there’s a sewer containing refuse that becomes important to the plot, and of course, some new unique stuff in the form of Missy and Davros facing each other for the very first time, which leads to this immortal line of dialogue:
MISSY: Can I just say, it’s been an absolute pleasure to finally meet you?
(She gives a little curtsey and holds out her hand, then pokes Davros in his blue eye. It hurts. Then she runs out.)
I love Missy. She’s the best version of the Master that we’ve had since Roger Delgado, and I say this as someone whose first Master was Anthony Ainley. (Because I watched The Keeper of Traken in my early teens.) Michelle Gomez plays her role with the perfect amount of genuine menace and sheer, unadulterated joy and euphoria, it’s hard not to love her. Especially in this, where she’s able to steal the show in an episode that has Davros in it.
Like so many trans women who came out in the mid-2010s, it’s hard not to look at Missy and see a cracked mirror version of what it’s like to transition into femininity. It’s an imperfect metaphor, but I don’t really care, because the way Missy luxuriates in being female is intensely relatable. I came out as trans in January 2015, around two months after Dark Water/Death in Heaven, so I was absolutely thrilled to have Best Master back, as I started exploring my own womanhood.
Obviously, a lot has changed since then. I’ve transitioned, I’m living happily as a woman with family and friends who accept me as such. But I can still find commonality with Missy – not only are we women who enjoy the experience of being female, we’re both witches to boot! When I look at The Witch’s Familiar now, I see it as a signpost pointing me in the direction of the woman I would eventually become.
(Also, the fact that an episode with that title came out around a month or so after I binge-read the Beautiful Creatures books, a series about another witch named Lena? No such thing as coincidences in matters of the Craft, at least in my book.)
And all this, for me, is why I will always go to bat for Magician/Witch. Moffat finally figures out how to do the Daleks right, and as it turned out, it’s the same way he figured out how to make the Cybermen work – drop Missy into it and let her control the story, just through sheer force of personality. (And it has to be Missy. As we saw in series 12, the same trick doesn’t work with Sacha Dhawan.)
Next week: two episodes in which the trip I took to the Doctor Who Experience was more interesting than the story I was watching on iPlayer. It’s Under the Lake/Before the Flood, and the not terribly triumphant return of Toby Whithouse to the Doctor Who writing staff.
Goddess have mercy on us all.
Leave a Reply