Nearly 10 years later, and honest to Goddess, I still don’t understand what in the hell Steven Moffat was thinking when he decided it was a good idea to bring back Toby freaking Whithouse. Not just once, but twice during the Capaldi era alone, in addition to his yearly slots in the Smith era.
Well, okay, that’s slightly unfair. As I argued in Eleventh Hour 1, Vampires of Venice was a decent hit, airing slap bang in the middle of the Twilight craze, when vampires were as big as witchcraft had been in the late 1990s. (I wonder if that’s why the Beautiful Creatures books never exploded in popularity like Twilight did. Maybe, if it had been released in the mid-late 1990s, during the same cultural moment as Practical Magic, The Craft, Charmed, and Harry goddamned Potter, people would be deciding what kind of Caster they were instead of which Hogwarts House they belonged to.)
Extended parenthetical rant aside, I can at least get why he came back in 2010. He could meet the cultural moment at that point in a way that he couldn’t in 2012, when he wrote A Town Called Mercy like it was a leftover late-Tennant script. His 2011 entry, The God Complex, still contained the same boring brooding white male pain, but as my good pal Frezno put it in DMs, he got away with it “only because that was part of the back third of S6 and ultimately refuted.”
But none of this explains why he came back for Capaldi. Fortunately, Shannon Sullivan gives us an answer there: “For Season Thirty-Five, executive producer Steven Moffat wanted to pit the Doctor against ghosts in their most familiar form: as the revenant spirits of the dead. A natural candidate to write such an adventure was Toby Whithouse, who had drawn upon various supernatural traditions for his successful drama Being Human.”
Okay, fair enough. A decade out from 2005’s The Unquiet Dead is a long enough gap to do another ghost story, and avoiding the haunted house by replacing it with an underwater base helps to avoid the haunted house motif from Hide, but again, what is there for Toby Whithouse, a one-trick pony if ever there was one, to say about Doctor Who in the mid-2010s?
The answer, of course, is nothing. To quote Sandifer: “Here, however, we just have a melange of Doctor Who cliches flowing into one another without anything that can traditionally be recognized as reasons. It’s not merely derivative crap, it’s incoherent and pointless derivative crap.” A statement that could apply not only to the era that does immediately follow Capaldi, but also the one that could have, if the winds had blown in such a way that Whithouse became showrunner in 2018 instead.
Like, the only sequence anyone actually remembers from this story is the cold open to Before the Flood – this would be the one where the Doctor gives an address to camera about bootstrap paradoxes, using a story about Beethoven to illustrate his point. Taken in isolation, it’s a great scene that ends up pointing to where Twelve is going to go at the start of series 10, where he’s working as a university professor. And then it ends with Peter Capaldi doing the best rendition of his era’s title music ever – by largely drowning out Murray Gold with the power of rock and roll instead.
But in the context of the story it’s a part of? It’s a great big neon sign that reads “I AM TRYING TO DO A CLEVER THING LIKE THE BOSS, EXCEPT IT WILL SUCK BECAUSE I’M NOT AS GOOD AT IT!” Kind of like how Chibnall tries to do a bit from Blink in the second half of Spyfall, except it doesn’t work as well because the moment is about him pulling something out of his ass to get the Fam off the plane, rather than introducing the Weeping Angels, the most terrifying modern series monster ever.
And with that, I have basically run out of things to say about this story. It’s lame, it’s boring, and it gives me nothing to work with. I only got this far because I kept making digressions and veering off topic because ABSOLUTELY ANYTHING ELSE IS MORE INTERESTING THAN TOBY FREAKING WHITHOUSE.
So, let me talk about something entirely different instead.
As I mentioned last week, I was studying abroad in England during the last half of 2015, with my time there almost exactly matching the season’s broadcast time. Magician/Witch aired about a month into my stay, and Hell Bent wrapped it all up the week before I went back to the US, so the first episode of the show I actually saw in my home country since Last Christmas was The Husbands of River Song.
The two weeks of Whithouse’s empty void of nothing came, funnily enough, during one of my occasional weekend trips out of London to somewhere else. On October 10th, I decided that the thing to do would be to visit the Doctor Who Experience, since I’d never been and I wanted to check it out. So, at godawful o’clock in the morning, I dragged my ass out of bed, took the tube to Victoria Coach Station, and took a coach ride to Cardiff.
(Before anyone asks, no, I didn’t do the TARDIS set tour. I wanted to, but they weren’t offering it at the time, and when they were, I was about fly back to the US. It was either the TARDIS or Bill Bailey, and I went to see Bill Bailey.)
That’s not to say I didn’t see any TARDIS interiors though. In fact, I saw three: a reconstructed classic TARDIS set, the Tennant-era coral set that they’d actually filmed on for The Day of the Doctor, and I’m pretty sure a smaller version of the copper TARDIS set from early Smith, though the lights were low and I wasn’t allowed to take pictures. (I did, however, get to pull the demat lever. That was fun.)
Aside from TARDIS sets, the Experience also had prop from across the entire history of the series. This included everything from the Zarbi costume in The Web Planet to the Melkur statue from The Keeper of Traken, my first Tom Baker story. (Yes, I know, weird place to start, but my brother had a DVD set with it, Logopolis, and Castrovalva on it, so that was how I watched it.)
From the new series, there were things like Eleven’s sonic cane from Let’s Kill Hitler, the actual Face of Boe, the Silent TARDIS console from The Lodger, most of the Doctor costumes, (including both of Eight’s, and Eleven’s outfit from The Eleventh Hour) and a whole bunch more. It really was an incredible place, and I was so sad when it closed down.
Seeing all these props and things from a show I loved would’ve been cool enough, but what made my visit extra special was that it coincided with Colin Baker’s Q&A and autograph session. As I recall, I went into the gift shop to buy something for him to sign, (the audio Criss Cross from Big Finish) then snuck back into the main display area for the actual Q&A.
I don’t remember too much of what he said, because it was a decade or so ago, but one memory does stick out: in his opinion, what Moffat and co were doing with Twelve was what he hoped to be doing during his own era, and got to do with Big Finish. “Every six Doctors, they get it right,” were his words.
After the Q&A came the autograph line. The line was surprisingly long, but enlivened by a discussion I had with a couple of Brits (whose names I do not remember) about Doctor Who, what the latest season was doing, differences between American and British culture… I could’ve talked to them forever!
(On the off chance either of you are reading this: hi! Yes, I’m the Yank who wore a grey hoodie with the number 13 on it. Reach out to me if you want, I’d love to catch up!)
Then came the big moment, where I got to talk to Ol’ Sixie himself. As he signed my copy of Criss Cross, I decided to be unconventional and ask him something I knew he wouldn’t expect – did he prefer Doctor Who or Star Trek? (Because he’d been in an episode of Star Trek Continues.)
Naturally, he answered Doctor Who. And if I recall correctly, the question amused him. Mission accomplished!
After the Doctor Who Experience visit, I had to make a very long walk through Cardiff toward the parking lot where the coach was waiting for me. That would’ve been fine, presumably, at any other time of year… but I happened to be in town during a Rugby World Cup match… and that meant fighting through a gazillion Welsh rugby fans if I wanted to get back to London on time. Fortunately I did… at about 9 PM GMT.
Still! It was a wonderful day out, and far more memorable than anything about Under the Lake/Before the Flood. (The latter of which, incidentally, I watched on Sunday morning.)
Next week, the story of how I watched The Girl Who Died.
Leave a Reply