For those wondering, this entry’s title song is actually a reference to Bonnie T Zygon being extremely hot. Sure, she’s an evil alien shapeshifter who manipulates the heroes into thinking she’s the Doctor’s companion, but damn it, she looks amazing in that jacket, and I think it deserves to be celebrated. (I will also give points to Clara’s freshly-woken-up look in the apartment scenes.)
So anyway, the episode.
The last time I wrote about a Peter Harness script, I got to basically dismiss the entire “political” angle of the story and focus instead on spinning a reading of it inspired by various aspects of Wiccan lore.
I can’t do that this time. Part of this is down to the fact that unlike Kill the Moon, nothing about this story has any spiritual resonance to it. Even the fact that it was broadcast on Samhain (Halloween for you mortals) is largely incidental. So with this essay, I have to get down to business and focus on the nitty gritty.
What we have here is the first of two stories that follow up on plot lines from The Day of the Doctor, which gets recapped for the people who either hadn’t seen it or had forgotten most of it. (So, normal people, as opposed to us anoraks.) Invasion/Inversion covers the Zygon plot, while Hell Bent tackles the Gallifrey portion.
In the story, we learn that the peace treaty instigated by War, Ten, and Eleven has gone horribly wrong due to a renegade splinter faction of Zygons, led by the evil Bonnie. They call themselves Truth or Consequences, after the city in New Mexico. (It’s a real place, by the way.)
Their demands? To live freely among humans as themselves, rather than pretending to be something they’re not.
Now, obviously, we all know how that’s going to go. The peace treaty will be maintained, with the Zygons continuing to remain in their human forms, because Doctor Who’s makeup budget doesn’t really allow for Zygon extras to be present in Earth scenes any more than it would allow for Silurian extras too. (I would ask ‘What happened to the other non-human species living on Earth, but in-universe the events of Hungry Earth/Cold Blood are still five years out, so I guess that’s the answer.) What matters is how we get there.
And how we get there is a story that has aged… extremely weirdly, politically speaking. It was already weird in 2015 itself. 2015 was the year ISIS was in the news seemingly every week, and politically, though Donald Trump hadn’t yet become the nominee or even president, a lot of the things he was saying presaged what he would do as the fascist-in-chief. (It was around November 2015, when the attack at the Bataclan concert hall occurred, that he first floated the idea of a Muslim ban.)
One scene, set during Kate’s visit to New Mexico, feels at once timely and evergreen all at the same time:
NORLANDER: The Brits came two years ago. We didn’t want them. They just They just turned up. No jobs. Nowhere to live. No money. And they were, they were odd. They started getting into fights. Couple of them got killed.
KATE: More than a couple. What happened here?
NORLANDER: After the murders, they started banding together. And then, one day, one of them changed.
KATE: Changed?
NORLANDER: One of them was walking down West Main, and suddenly, it turned into a, a reptile.
Everything about Norlander’s dialogue here, ignoring the fact that she’s actually an alien Zygon and thus not eligible to vote in a presidential election, still sounds a bit like that of a Trump supporter. She probably would’ve voted for him if Kate hadn’t “fatally shot” her, as the common parlance goes.
The fact that Republicans are anti-immigration isn’t news – that was true in 2015, and it’s really true now, what with DJT going full on Adolf Freakin’ Hitler at his rallies these days. (Note: I am writing this in mid-October and will update portions of it for the WordPress version once the election results are known.) They want a white ethnostate, and they’ve finally stopped pretending otherwise.
What is news is how far to the right that Democrats have gone on immigration. In 2015 you still had Obama’s DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) program, and the rhetoric during the 2016 and 2020 campaigns were still focused on helping people get into this country if they wanted to live here.
Now, you’ve got Kamala Harris and the rest of the contemporary Democratic Party doing policy proposals that, though they lack the sheer visceral hatred of anything Trump did, would still not have looked out of place in the administration of George W. Bush. Or, hell, a McCain or Romney administration.
An article by Christian Paz of Vox, published after the 2024 Democratic convention, goes into greater detail on this shift: the main cause is the COVID-19 pandemic, which saw the number of Americans who want all forms of immigration to be decreased go from 28% to 55%. Talking about “securing our border” and increasing deportations used to just be Republican talking points.
Now, I’ve seen mailers from Democrats running for office in NEW YORK advocating for border security. Which is just nonsensical. What the hell are we worried about, invading Canadians?! They have their own problems, what do they need us for?!
But getting back to the Zygon story. As Sandifer observed, “This is a story that never for a moment takes seriously the idea that the Zygons do not, in fact, have a right to live peacefully alongside humanity, indeed unapologetically following up on the moral logic of Kill the Moon to decide that this is not actually an issue in which there are democratic rights to be considered. Regardless of whether one agrees with the extremism of this position (I’m pretty sympathetic) there’s an admirable moral boldness here.”
Really, the depressing thing about this story is the way in which its rhetoric on allowing the Zygons to live peacefully here is extremely jarring, in today’s far more cynical world. I can’t even imagine what the response to it would be like in a world where the words “President Donald Trump” is a historical fact as opposed to a plot point in a really bad political thriller movie. (And depending on how the election goes, our lived reality. Again.)
It’s not unlike the closing speech from the pilot of The West Wing, where President Bartlet turns a meditation on tomato rosaries into saying of the Cubans that have been heading for Florida all episode, “Through the clothes on their backs they came through a storm. They want a better life, and they want it here.”
The problem isn’t that the story is naive for suggesting that we treat immigrants like people instead of something to be solved.
The problem is us.
It’s always been us, ever since the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798, passed during the John Adams administration. (As in the Founding Father, not his son John Quincy.) And who knows how many laws besides, in countries all around the world. But in America specifically, it all feels especially egregious, because ours is a nation of immigrants. And yet, all we ever want to do is pull the ladder up behind us.
Freedom for me, but not for thee. How very American.
Leave a Reply