In 2009, the Beatles’ core catalogue (their twelve UK albums, the American Magical Mystery Tour album, and the Past Masters collection) were remastered for the first time in 22 years. The releases all took place on the same day – September 9th, 2009, to much fanfare and excitement.
There were two box sets that collected the recordings: the Original Studio Recordings was a black box that came with the remastered stereo albums, marking the first time that their first 4 UK records were issued on compact disc in stereo, while the white The Beatles in Mono collection compiled all of the remastered mono recordings – that is, Beatles tracks that were released with a dedicated mono mix.
Since mono was falling out of fashion by 1968, the White Album was the last studio album in the set – following it was Mono Masters, the two-disc monaural collection that serves that box set’s equivalent to Past Masters. The track list is largely identical to disc 1, though disc 2 contains tracks that had been mixed in mono but were previously unreleased – specifically, songs from the Yellow Submarine soundtrack album from 1969.
Let’s break those down:
Disc 1
‘Love Me Do’: This is it, the very first released Beatles recording, with all four of them playing! You can hear the nervousness in their musicianship, it’s kind of adorable.
‘From Me To You’: Their third UK single, this song is well remembered for the sung opening lick, and the augmented chord that pops up during the bridge sections. And thanks to its inclusion on the 1 album from 2000, it’s one of several songs that can define what might be called Early Beatles, an epoch of time lasting until around Beatles For Sale.
Thank You Girl: A love song written by John and Paul to their fans, it’s hard not to like it. The American mixes of the song have even more harmonica, and as an admitted fan of John’s harmonica playing, that’s never a bad thing in my book.
She Loves You: This song, more than any song they ever did, is the one that defines early ‘60s Beatlemania, particularly in Britain. This is the song that made them international superstars, and made everything that followed possible. As well as their falsetto vocal harmonies and their knack for catchy hooks, to say nothing of the sheer power behind Ringo’s drumming, this is a song that defies all convention with regard to how love songs are “supposed” to be, since it comes from a third party.
I’ll Get You: If I’m being honest with myself, this is a song that probably worked better when I first heard it as a kid. I was around eight or nine years old, and for whatever reason, I absolutely adored this particular number, along with “Thank You Girl,” perhaps because the first two lines reminded me so much of John’s later song, “Imagine”: ‘Imagine I’m in love with you/It’s easy ’cause I know…’ Nowadays, it’s a bit stalker-y. Leave the girl alone, my guy! She’s just not that into you!
I Want to Hold Your Hand: This track, recorded 17 October 1963, was the song that broke open the floodgates for the band’s invasion of America. The band’s previous singles up until now had been released on some smaller record labels, where they proceeded to flop. It was not until “I Want to Hold Your Hand,” released on the big-time Capitol Records label, that the group’s fortunes in the US changed. This song was pivotal in another way as well: the lyrics in the bridge portions, “I can’t hide,” were misheard by Bob Dylan as “I get high.” When the band were playing in America for their 1964 summer tour, Dylan met the group and turned them on to pot in August. History was never the same again.
This Boy: “This Boy” has always been a favorite of mine, showcasing the gorgeous three-part harmonies of John, Paul, and George. You don’t get to hear it often, so when you do, it’s a real privilege. Only two other songs have them: “Yes It Is,” on later on disc 1, and “Because,” on Abbey Road.
‘Komm, Gib Mir Deine Hand’: This version of “I Want to Hold Your Hand” (In English, the German title means, “Come, Give Me Your Hand.”) came about because executives at Odeon (EMI’s German subsidiary) thought that the Beatles would only sell in Germany if they sang their songs in German. And so, we got this. The Beatles, understandably, thought this was an idiotic idea, and dropped the practice after this and “Sie Liebt Dich” were made. I like them anyway, and these songs are pretty much entirely responsible for why I took German in high school. I even still remember some of it!
‘Sie Liebt Dich’: The other German language Beatles song. But where “Hand” just had the new vocals overdubbed onto the original instrumental, this version of “She Loves You” is a completely new recording – John and George’s respective guitar parts are different, and the pitch is ever so slightly higher, to say nothing of a bit more low end than on the English version.
Long Tall Sally: In which Paul McCartney displays his amazing Little Richard impression. Always a highlight of the band’s early ‘60s work, the way he can turn on a dime from the sweet-voiced crooner of “And I Love Her” and “Til There Was You” to this is absolutely something else. This song in particular was a staple of their live shows going all the way back to the Quarry Men era of the late ‘50s, and was, in fact, the last song they played as a live act – Candlestick Park, San Francisco, 1966. This version? All done in one take.
I Call Your Name: One of John’s earliest songs, “I Call Your Name” is another early Beatles song to include cowbell, and was in fact considered for inclusion on the A Hard Day’s Night album before eventually getting released on the Long Tall Sally EP instead. It’s a much better song than “You Can’t Do That” in my opinion, and I think the AHDN album would be much improved if you put this there instead.
‘Slow Down’: A cover of a song by Larry Williams, this contains two amazing things: my favorite Beatle vocal flub of all time (John can’t decide whether he’s singing about a girl or a boy and so does both at once, courtesy of double-tracking) and one of his best rock and roll screams, right up until “Revolution” in 1968.
‘Matchbox’: Ringo’s vocal spot, in one of the earliest entries in a Beatles sub-genre we might call Forlorn Ringo songs, in that his protagonists all seem to be men who are down on their luck, in the fashion of Ringo himself from his big scene in A Hard Day’s Night. Songs of this kind will appear on three UK Beatles albums: Beatles For Sale, Help!, and Rubber Soul, before resurfacing on the White Album – “Don’t Pass Me By,” Ringo’s own composition, was written around 1964. In between, of course, he’ll become the go-to guy for kid-friendly songs, like “Yellow Submarine,” “With A Little Help From My Friends,” and “Octopus’s Garden.”
I Feel Fine: Another song with a particularly notable beginning, the start of “I Feel Fine” happened when Paul McCartney plucked an A note on his bass while it was pointed in the vicinity of John’s guitar amp, causing feedback. Doing this technically violated EMI’s recording rules, but as so often happens in the story of this band, sometimes you have to break the rules to get the sound you want.
She’s A Woman: Another great Paul song where he gets to do his rock and roll voice again, I love any song where he gets to sing about how awesome his woman is. He’s head-over-heels for this chick, and you can tell!
‘Bad Boy’: Our last Larry Williams cover on this album, and while I prefer the earlier “Slow Down” from a few tracks ago, this is still pretty good! It’s got John doing a single-tracked vocal this time, a real rarity for him – most of his Beatles-era songs, at least in the moptop era, were double-tracked, though he moves away from it as the ‘60s progress.
‘Yes It Is’: George breaks out his volume pedal for this song, the mournful B-side of “Ticket to Ride.” According to John, this was him trying to rewrite “This Boy” (down to the 3-part harmonies and a solo John section) but if you ask me, I think it’s more like the dismal sequel: the guy trying to warn the object of his affections away from That Boy has found a new love, but he’s failing to move on, to the point that he doesn’t want his new beau to wear red because it reminds him of his ex. Poor guy.
I’m Down: Out of all the songs where Paul did his Little Richard voice, “I’m Down” is probably the best one ever. It came out as the B-side of the “Help!” single, but it never got a proper album release until Rock ’n’ Roll Music came out. The studio version is great all by itself, but for a good time, watch the Shea Stadium performance from 1965, on the Anthology documentary, where John plays the keyboard with his elbows like a madman.
Disc 2
‘Day Tripper’: “Tripper” was, at once, a drug song (specifically LSD) and a reference to people who go on trips and then come home in the same day. Personally, I’ve always liked “Tripper” more, as it was the first Beatles song I learned to play on guitar.
‘We Can Work It Out’: Released as a double A-side with “Day Tripper” toward the end of 1965, “We Can Work It Out” proved to be the more popular of the two songs, as that was a Paul song, with John contributing the bridge. During recording sessions, George Harrison suggested performing the bridge sections in ¾ waltz time, to go with the minor chords used in those sections.
‘Paperback Writer’: Released as the first single of 1966, “Paperback Writer” all but defines the word distortion in its lead guitar part, though more attention is paid to Paul’s bass, which appears on a record for the first time as basically a lead instrument. Lyrically, this track is also one of the first Beatles songs, and the first single, not to have anything to do with love in any way whatsoever.
‘Rain’: The coolest fucking song in the entire Beatles catalog, paws down. This song has everything! To record it they played the song at normal speed, then slowed the rhythm track down, making everything sound bigger. The drum sound in particular is out of this world – hell, it’s Ringo’s favorite! He said, “I think it’s the best out of all the records I’ve ever made. ‘Rain’ blows me away … I know me and I know my playing … and then there’s ‘Rain’.” Also listen for the reversed vocals at the end, entirely because John was high and decided he liked it.
‘Lady Madonna’: The Beatles started ‘68 in a big way with this song, a piano-driven story track about a single mom trying to raise three children. Inspired by Fats Domino and Humphrey Lyttleton, the blues-inspired feel was a big shift from the psychedelic flavorings of their recent tracks. Paul has described it as a tribute to women, starting with the Virgin Mary.
‘The Inner Light’: Just as “Love You To” was George’s first Beatles song to translate Indian classical music into Western rock form, this song is his last stab at the concept. An instrumental version appears as a bonus track on his first solo album, Wonderwall Music, from 1968, while the title inspired a particularly famous episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation’s fifth season.
‘Hey Jude’: The first song to be released on the Beatles’ own Apple label, “Hey Jude” began life as an attempt from Paul to comfort Julian Lennon, John’s son, as his parents were in the process of divorcing. The record-buying public certainly got the reassuring vibes, as it stayed at #1 for nine weeks, the longest run for any Beatles single, and remains their most successful song ever.
‘Revolution’: Like “Paperback Writer” before it, “Revolution” defines the word distortion, as the guitar sound came from the guitars being plugged into the mixing desk directly and played so loudly as to overload the meters. It was one of Lennon’s earliest political songs, responding to the revolutionary fervor gripping the UK and the US by asking “What’s the plan for afterwards?” It was recorded twice: a slower version appeared on the White Album in 1968, and the single version is presented here.
Only A Northern Song: George wrote this song as a dry, sardonic response to the way he was being treated as a songwriter, and it becomes the first song in what might be called his anti-Beatle phase. He was genuinely sick of being in the band by 1967, a feeling that only got stronger as the years went by. Hard not to blame him, honestly. This mix of the song (along with the next 3) was prepared for a Yellow Submarine EP that never happened, and is released here for the first time.
All Together Now: Another children’s song from Paul that’s almost exactly as innocent as you’d hope it would be, except for one line after the first chorus. It’s hard not to like this song anyway, even if Paul thought it was a throwaway – listen to the way the tempo gradually speeds up over the course of the track.
Hey Bulldog: Good grief do I love this song, it’s absolutely fucking great. One of the best rock songs the Beatles ever did, and it’s buried on what is by some distance the least-loved album in their catalogue. I could listen to it all day! Ringo and Paul have the time of their lives in the rhythm section, the guitar solo is amazing, and the end where John and Paul screw around and bark?! It’s hard not to get swept up in it!
It’s All Too Much: Remember the feedback at the start of “I Feel Fine?” This is that, taken up to like eleven or something. It’s kind of amazing – one of the best songs of the psychedelic era, and again, it’s buried here on a soundtrack album. It’s utilized well in the movie though, as kind of an epilogue over the happy ending.
Get Back: As revealed by Peter Jackson’s 2021 docuseries, this song sprung out of thin air seemingly during recording sessions for what would become Let It Be, as Paul found the chords for the introduction seemingly at random one morning in early January 1969. With cameras rolling and George and Ringo yawning, the song just appeared, though it took a move away from the film studio where they’d been rehearsing and into their new HQ in Savile Row for it to really take shape.
‘Don’t Let Me Down’: One of John’s finest love songs, “Don’t Let Me Down” was inspired by his relationship with the artist Yoko Ono, whom he’d met in 1966. Released as the b-side of “Get Back,” both tracks feature the keyboard playing of Billy Preston, a friend of theirs from the Hamburg period, and who sat in as the “fifth Beatle” during the Get Back/Let It Be sessions.
‘Across The Universe’: Written during the Beatles’ trip to India in early 1968, this version of the song appeared on a charity album by the World Wildlife Fund. My personal favorite version of the song, though, won’t be released until 2003’s Let It Be… Naked.
‘You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)’: Begun in 1967 in the immediate aftermath of Pepper but not finished until 1969, this is the last recording we have of John and Paul screwing around and being friends with one another. It was released in 1970 as the B-side of “Long and Winding Road,” and for my money, the dichotomy of those two songs sums up the Beatles perfectly – they could be serious when called on, but more often than not, they loved to be giant hams. Paul described it as his favorite Beatles track, which (given how dearly he loved John) is a very Paul thing to say.
The Beatles purists out there (of which there are a lot) will tell you to listen to their albums in mono, because that was how the band originally heard them, along with the majority of music consumers in the 1960s. Hell, Ken Scott said that when I met him in 2013. (And then he signed my copy of the stereo White Album remaster, because it was all I had on me. I still have it!)
Certainly, there are things about those mono mixes that differ, sometimes significantly, from the stereo versions. And in a few cases (quite a few, actually) the stereo mixes are awful. Hell, I listened to the mono mixes for the British album posts, because I had them on hand and if I’m going to listen to the 2009 remasters, most of the time I’ll go with the mono ones.
But the music marketplace has shifted significantly since the early 1960s, and no one listens to mono anymore. At least, not on purpose. The tables have turned: stereo is king, and mono is rare. Hell, the Beatles were still a thing when the changeover happened! That’s how long ago this was!
It doesn’t help that the mono box set, including Mono Masters, is getting increasingly hard to find these days. The CD set is $252 on Amazon as of April 2024, and the vinyl version? $3,000. That’s a lot of money. Apple Corps could get around this by putting the mono box on streaming services, but they haven’t, for god knows what reason.
Availability frustrations aside though, there is still value to the mono mixes. They are historical documents, and while I’m reluctant to give the purists credit on anything, they are at least right about this.
Leave a Reply