The Midnight Hour: All Dressed Up in Dreams (Sleep No More)

Note: the following was written prior to Donald Trump’s victory in the 2024 election, and the absolute failure of the Democratic Party to mount an effective opposition in response to the same. Please enjoy this preserved last remaining shred of optimism.


So, Sleep No More. It’s probably Mark Gatiss’ worst work for the series since Night Terrors, a statement that isn’t quite as damning as it was in, say, 2018 or so when I was first getting my paws wet in media criticism. If The RTD Rewind and Back to the Eleventh Hour have taught me anything, it’s that I sorely misjudged Gatiss as a writer.

When I was first watching the show back in the early 2010s, I couldn’t stand his work, but I’ve honestly come to really like him in the years since. Part of this is down to the fact that we share a birthday: the 17th of October. (I’m writing this two days afterward, so, happy belated birthday, sir!) But the other part of it is that he has very specific niches, and when you let him go off and do something that fits those niches, what he turns in is genuinely great TV.

Unquiet Dead? Classic. Idiot’s Lantern? Hated it on the first go-around, appreciated it way more on the rewatch. Robot of Sherwood? Beautiful. Crimson Horror? Enjoyable, and even better in the book version. I’ll even give him points for Cold War and everything about Victory of the Daleks that isn’t Winston Churchill! Next season we get The Empress of Mars, which despite not being the Peladon story it was originally pitched as, still has all the vibes of the Third Doctor, and he was one of my earliest Doctors. (More on that later.)

Point being, Gatiss is a much better writer than I initially gave him credit for, provided he sticks to what he’s good at. (Can I ever relate: I can’t write a Doctor Who fic to save my life, but I do military-adjacent sci-fi like Star Trek really well.) It’s when he goes and does something like Night Terrors, by some distance his worst-ever work for Who on TV, that problems come up.

Fortunately, Sleep No More is nowhere near as dire as Night Terrors was. (It is, however, really funny that both of his worst stories relate to sleeping and the avoidance thereof.) This is definitely a misfire, but it’s an interesting misfire.

For starters, I love the concept inherent in something like a found-footage movie where you present a fictional narrative as being true events. That worked very well for Daniel Handler (aka Lemony Snicket) when he wrote A Series of Unfortunate Events 25 years ago, and even better when the Netflix version came along. (Remember when Netflix made good TV? For more than one season? Me too.)

But part of what made ASOUE work in the first place was the cultural zeitgeist of the moment 1999 was the era of The Blair Witch Project, the biggest found-footage movie ever, and the primary inspiration of Sleep No More. (Just ask Mark Gatiss.) People who saw Blair Witch then came across ASOUE, which presents itself as the end result of a long investigation by Mr. Snicket, and were primed and ready for a narrative that blurs the line between fiction and reality.

This is the problem Sleep No More has: it’s trying to do a found-footage movie at a point where the genre had largely become a parody of itself. It’s a bit like, say, dedicating an entire Doctor Who spinoff series to the idea of “a British version of Buffy the Vampire Slayer” when that show had been off air for 13 years already. Sure, people still liked it, but it wasn’t a dominant part of the culture anymore.

Still, at least there’s something to be said for Gatiss’ commitment to the bit. I particularly like the replacement credit sequence, where the character names and the series title are mixed in with digits and code numbers, feels very Matrix adjacent, and we all know how extremely trans The Matrix movies are.

I’ve found this tends to happen with trans creatives – we may not be explicitly writing about trans subjects, but on a subconscious level, the vibes are there. The Wachowski sisters had this with The Matrix, and I had this with the first three books in my Star Trek: New Endeavours fanfic series.

It’s ironic, then, that Gatiss and Shearsmith, both of whom have done exceedingly transphobic work in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, should find themselves in a story that contains the very first trans person to appear on Doctor Who, comedian Bethany Black. She plays 474, and though her voice is deepened in post, the narrative still treats her as female. As I recall she was very happy about this, and she even had her episode credit as her social media cover photo for a good long time.

In hindsight, the rep was far from perfect, but it mattered a lot to us back then, and I believe it paved the way for Yasmin Finney’s character of Rose Noble in the RTD2 era. RTD has spoken at considerable length over the past few years about trans rights, and how essential we are to the rest of the queer community.

And when you think about it, trans rights, and the ongoing battles in relation to them, really are the oft-unremarked B-plot to the Capaldi era. I haven’t addressed the subject much in this series (I think the last big essay about it was the Deep Breath post) but now seems like a good time to bring it up, given the importance that gender, womanhood, and transitioning into that play in the later stages of this portion of the show, a period that we are very rapidly approaching.

The cynic in me would probably say that it feels like we haven’t made any progress since the Capaldi years were the present day of Doctor Who. But we have, and Doctor Who itself, via Missy and 474, has played a part in helping us win the acceptance we’ve always deserved.

In 2015 alone, we had Caitlin Jenner’s big interview with Diane Sawyer, me coming out as trans to my parents, the premiere of I Am Jazz, and Laverne Cox having a big role on Netflix’s Orange is the New Black, alongside Kate Mulgrew of Star Trek: Voyager. Things were going great, and I remember thinking that as disastrous as coming out to my parents had been, there was still no better time to be trans.

And then 11/9 happened.

All of a sudden we were suddenly public enemy number 1, as Trump’s administration did everything possible to make our lives a living hell. Add in the fact that an increasingly large number of trans Americans live in right-wing dystopias at the state level, and it feels like it almost doesn’t matter who gets to be president, because the ongoing war on trans rights remains the same.

It does matter, though. The Biden administration has been trying, despite the best efforts of a Trump judiciary, to make our lives easier at the federal level. But everything he’s tried to do gets blocked by the Fifth Circuit or whatever, meaning that even if Harris wins in November, she’s going to have an equally impossible time trying to get shit done. After all, we don’t even know if she’ll have a Democratic trifecta or not.

To the extent that I am still hopeful about anything these days (and I admit I’ve gotten increasingly cynical over the past decade) it’s that Republicans lose at the ballot box when they run extremely anti-trans campaigns.

In the 2022 midterm elections, pollsters predicted a red wave would sweep Republicans into Congress… and then they managed to maintain their hold on the Senate (just) and only barely lost the House because New York Democrats were doing what they do best: being incompetent dipshits.

(I’m a New Yorker now, I get to make that joke.)

Now, granted, the more centrist Democrats out there (COLIN ALLRED AND SHERROD BROWN) have decided to jump on board the anti-trans bandwagon by conceding to the GOP framing on the issue, but at least you’ve got Kamala Harris going on Fox News, of all places, and side-stepping Bret Baier’s attempt at baiting her into saying something. Or Tim Walz going on a podcast and saying this:

“We see it now; the hate has shifted to the trans community. They see that as an opportunity. If you’re watching any sporting events right now, you see that Donald Trump’s closing arguments are to demonize a group of people for being who they are. We’re out there trying to make the case that access to healthcare, a clean environment, manufacturing jobs, and keeping your local hospital open are what people are really concerned about. They’re running millions of dollars of ads demonizing folks who are just trying to live their lives.”

This is the kind of thing we need to be hearing. And it is my sincerest hope that if Harris wins and we get a Democratic trifecta, trans rights will be enshrined into law, right alongside abortion rights and voting rights and all the other rights that Republicans want to take away. Because all of it matters, and all of us deserve protection.

And if the courts try to stop them? Play hardball. Do what FDR threatened to do in the 1930s and stack the courts with liberals, especially SCOTUS. Kick ass, take names, and stop listening to the unsolicited advice from the Starmerian Labour Party. Because while I have a considerable number of problems with the Democrats, at least we can work with them.

The state of transgender rights in America is patchwork, like so much else in this country. For crying out loud, Erin Reed’s ever-evolving maps of trans healthcare look a lot like election night electoral maps. New York is safe for us, but Missouri (where I used to live) really isn’t.

But England? Things were already bad for the British trans community in the Capaldi years, just by dint of them having David the Pig Fucker in office, followed by a succession of Tory PMs who made an already bad situation way, way worse. (Except Liz Truss, who is probably Britain’s best prime minister yet when it comes to trans rights.)

Then Labour comes in on the Fourth of July (yes, that really happened) and not only do they not change tack and start supporting trans rights, like they fucking should have, they instead tackle the issue like they’re… fucking Tories. You want to know what America might be like under a second Trump administration? Just look at Labour under Keir Starmer. What an absolute disgrace.

Still, I have hope. At least in the US, trans rights are not for the 2020s what gay marriage was in 2000s – something for the Republican presidential nominee to run and win on. Everyone recognizes that the GOP are sick freaks for being so obsessed about this shit as they are, and hopefully, that will play a part in a possible defeat in November.

Only one way to find out.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑