To go to a Beatles concert in 1964 and 1965, at the height of their fame, is to go and see the band play live, but not hear them. This is because you would find yourself in the middle of a seemingly endless collective scream by hundreds of thousands of teenage girls, all for the four men playing on stage in the distance.
Compared to today’s live performance standards, Beatles shows were laughably primitive: 100-watt amplifiers for themselves, no headphones for the band members so they could actually hear each other, and any on-site sound system was meant for announcing who was next at bat during a baseball game, not rock music. Not that you’d notice, because again: the screams were what you heard.
Or at least, that was until 1977, when Capitol Records released The Beatles at the Hollywood Bowl. Their one and only live album for over 40 years, Hollywood Bowl captures the band in performance at, where else, but the Hollywood Bowl amphitheater in California. It was a difficult album to mix, given the endless scream, but when it did come out, it was a huge success, reaching #2 on Billboard’s album chart. But thanks to the screaming, it became something of a forgotten gem of Beatles lore…
Enter Giles Martin. In 2016, the Hollywood Bowl album was re-released as Live at the Hollywood Bowl, with four new bonus tracks. The album came about to help promote Ron Howard’s documentary, Eight Days a Week – The Touring Years. The music was all newly remixed by Martin and Sam Okell from the 3-track masters, utilizing what he called de-mixing technology. The end result? A truly spectacular live album, with more clarity to the music than ever before.
Let’s jump in:
‘Twist And Shout’: We begin with the closing track from Please Please Me, albeit presented here in abridged form. It’s still an amazing introduction, and I love how loud the backing vocals are, particularly Paul and that “YEAH” of his toward the end.
‘She’s A Woman’: A spirited live performance of the B-side of “I Feel Fine,” and a million times better than the version from Anthology 2, captured in Japan. John does backing vocals here, on the places where Paul double-tracked himself on the record. Also listen for the natural slapback echo produced by the bandshell.
‘Dizzy Miss Lizzy’: Thanks to the mixing job, Ringo’s drums are really evident here – he sounds fucking great, and I really like the sound of George’s lead guitar too. A few lyric changes compared to the studio version – I’m not sure if that was on purpose or not.
‘Ticket To Ride’: While not my favorite live version of “Ticket” (that would be the Blackpool Night Out performance from Anthology 2) this one is still pretty great, especially as the scream volume drops considerably for most of the song.
‘Can’t Buy Me Love’: A wonderful performance of the hit single from A Hard Day’s Night, though I think it’s in a slightly lower key than the album version.
‘Things We Said Today’: The first track on the album to be taken from the 1964 performance, featuring George doing the song intro, and then singing along with Paul during the choruses. I’m not completely sure the song works with electric instruments, but the performance isn’t too bad!
‘Roll Over Beethoven’: George takes lead vocals this time and absolutely plays the hell out of the song – honestly, it’s one of the best performances he ever did. They actually play it faster than on the album, just adding to the exhilaration of it all.
‘Boys’: Ringo’s turn now, and he absolutely smashes it, imbuing his lead vocal performance with even more energy than on the original from Please Please Me. It’s honestly incredible.
‘A Hard Day’s Night’: John introduces the title song from their first movie, and despite the fact they’re slightly out of key, it doesn’t matter because it sounds fucking awesome, particularly the solo. I’ve actually heard this one played live, when I saw Paul at Busch Stadium in 2016. He sang both his own parts and John’s, and it was really great!
‘Help!’: “We’d like to do another film song now, but from a different film,” says John, introducing the title song from their second movie. The performance absolutely slaps, though I do wish George’s lead guitar was a little louder.
‘All My Loving’: In which Paul makes a reference to “their first Capitol album,” AKA Meet The Beatles. I like that he does that – shows he’s aware of what the audience is familiar with. The performance itself is great, particularly for the while George does the harmony after the solo.
‘She Loves You’: One of exactly two recordings of this song in stereo, the performance is great, but what always sticks out to me is the way you can really hear Paul’s bass toward the end
‘Long Tall Sally’: Paul introduces the last song, while also thanking everybody for coming out to see them. It’s an absolutely brilliant performance, one of their best – probably because they’ve played it so many times.
Now for the encore:
‘You Can’t Do That’: I still really hate this song, but I suppose I can acknowledge that the performance is pretty good. It’s also faster than the album version, which means it’s over sooner.
‘I Want to Hold Your Hand’: The live recording from which the Love version was based on, I really like this version. True, you lose George’s guitar fills, but John and Paul’s voices always sound great together.
‘Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby’: George gets another lead vocal slot here, with an exuberant version of the last song from Beatles For Sale. There are TWO guitar solo sections, and they sound absolutely incredible.
‘Baby’s in Black’: One of my favorite songs gets an excellent live performance, though with a different intro from the version on the Real Love single from 1996. (Personally I prefer the longer version.) The performance itself is the same as before, just with a better sound mix than before.
In the Anthology book, John says of the Hollywood Bowl shows: “The Hollywood Bowl was marvelous. It was the one we all enjoyed most, I think, even though it wasn’t the largest crowd – because it seemed so important, and everybody was saying things. We got on, and it was a big stage, and it was great. We could be heard in a place like the Hollywood Bowl, even though the crowds was wild: good acoustics.”
The resulting live album that came from those shows is, as you’ve probably guessed by now, exceptional. The new remix from 2016 means that the music shines better than ever – the screams are still there, but they don’t drown out the band. It’s an exhilarating snapshot of a singular moment in the history of pop music, and as close as most of us will ever get to hearing them live and in person.
As George Martin wrote in the original album’s liner notes, “Those of us who were lucky enough to be present at a live Beatle concert – be it in Liverpool, London, New York, Washington, Los Angeles, Tokyo, Sydney or wherever – will know how amazing, how unique those performances were. It was not just the voice of the Beatles: it was expression of the young people of the world.”
I wholeheartedly agree.