Off the Beatle Track: Now and Then

The Song

If you had told me that in 2023, there would be such a thing as a New Beatles Song, I would never have dared to believe you. And yet, here we are.

It’s difficult to know where to begin with something like this. The Beatles have been a mainstay for my entire life, from listening to Sgt. Pepper on cassette in the late ‘90s as a kid, to CDs, and now digital. My Beatles collection is so comprehensive, it took me 3 CD wallets just to hold everything.

So, when something as huge as their final song hits, what do I do? How do I process this?

With the beginning, I believe.

As Paul recounts in a documentary to promote the song, the story behind “Now & Then” begins in the mid 1990s. During the making of The Beatles Anthology, the surviving Beatles had the idea to try and record some new music. But you can’t have the Beatles without John Lennon, and his murder in December 1980 made that dream impossible…

And then came Yoko. The woman unfairly maligned as the reason why the band fell apart in 1969 and 1970 now brought them back together, via some old piano demos recorded by her late husband. Two these songs, “Free As a Bird” and “Real Love,” were chosen to serve as the basis for new Beatles recordings.

Working together at Paul’s studio in Sussex, Paul, George, and Ringo, along with producer Jeff Lynne, were able to polish up these old recordings, and overdubbed new parts, from drums to guitars and vocals. On paper, this kind of thing shouldn’t work – but that old Beatle magic, that indefinable alchemy of those four men playing together, meant it worked anyway.

Sure, John’s vocal sounded ethereal and faint, like he was singing from beyond the grave. He was! That ghostly quality gave those two reunion songs their own vibe, and when combined with the work of the other three, you have the answer to the question, “What the Beatles would sound like if they never broke up.” Time had passed, and recapturing the Sixties wouldn’t have worked at all. The “Free As A Bird”/“Real Love” duology captures the spirit of the Beatles, but for the ‘90s. “It sounds like them,” said George, “Because it is them.”

Which brings us to “Now and Then.” The real last Beatles song.

The Threetles attempted to work on this song back in the ‘90s, but only got as far as George’s rhythm guitar before they gave up – the tape was of such poor quality, they couldn’t do anything with it.

Enter Peter Jackson.

Since 2021, the man behind the Lord of the Rings movies has become something like a modern fifth Beatle. His Get Backdocuseries, chronicling the making of what would become Let It Be, contained revolutionary new audio engineering technology. His team had developed something called Machine Audio Learning, software that was able to take the raw mono recordings from late ‘60s Nagra tape recorders and perfectly separate various elements, from speech to guitars and drums, and make possible a clean stereo mix. No mic leakage, no artifacts – just pure elements.

The same technology was used on last year’s remix of Revolver: The four-track masters were de-mixed in the same way, meaning Giles Martin now had room to remix the album in a way that suited modern ears. “Taxman,” now, has more punch to it than the original stereo mix did, as each element of Ringo’s drum kit or Paul’s bass could be manipulated separately.

For “Now and Then,” he was able to perfectly isolate John Lennon’s vocal from the original tape, absolutely cleanly: if you watch the documentary, you can hear an isolated clip of Lennon singing the first verse, as clear as if it had been recorded yesterday, in a proper recording studio.

Starting with that vocal, the rebuild began. A new piano track, played by Paul. Archival audio of George’s original rhythm guitar part, plus lead guitar by Paul performed in George’s style. Paul on bass, Ringo on drums, and just to add that last bit of late Beatles polish, an orchestral backing by Giles Martin, heavily inspired by his father’s work from the 1960s.

So. What does this song actually sound like?

In a word? Beautiful.

It starts off in the same way “I Saw Her Standing There,” the first Beatles song on the first album, began: with a count-in from Paul. Then it opens much like the original demo: Piano, and John Lennon’s vocal, as clear and clean as it was in life. Listen close, and you can hear George’s rhythm guitar under the piano, along with strings.

Then John sings the last two words of the first verse, and that old Beatles magic comes surging back. Ringo chimes in on drums, Paul softly harmonizing with his oldest and best friend, just like in the old days as they head into the second verse, and in the low end, you can just make out his Höfner bass, the same one played on countless Beatles recordings.

Then we get to the last 3 words of verse 2: “…will love you.” John never finished this line in the demo, so Paul did it for him. From what I can hear, Paul sings this line almost on his own, with John lower in the mix, adding poignancy. It’s the last 43 years since John’s murder, summed up in three words. Paul misses his friend.

Then the first chorus hits, and reader, this is the exact moment I started crying. The drums, the rhythm guitar, the bass, the vocal harmonies between John and Paul… When combined with Giles Martin’s string arrangement, and some archival ooh’s and ahh’s mixed in from old recordings, and that guitar solo…

It’s The Beatles.

That’s really all you need to say. Four men, separated by time and mortality, playing the same song. It’s an utterly breathtaking experience, if a very bittersweet one. There is no more from this band. This is, genuinely, their final song.

I can’t think of a better way to say goodbye… and then hello again.

Why hello? Because, if you buy the digital or vinyl versions of the single, “Now and Then” is backed with the very first Beatles song: “Love Me Do,” the first recording with John, Paul, George, and Ringo. (The somewhat more well-known album version, infamously, had Andy White on drums.)

This version of the song, along with a few other early Beatles recordings, has for now been released only in mono, as that was the standard at the time. But thanks to the same MAL process I’ve mentioned previously, a true stereo mix now exists. It’s not a reinvention of the original mono per se, but it is nice to hear this song in stereo for the first time.

The two songs, when combined, tie a bow on the Beatles’ recording career. There’s really not too much else to say. It’s an encapsulation of everything this band was. Their story now ends… and begins again. With Giles Martin continuing his mission of remixing the Beatles for the 21st century, we can relive Beatlemania all over again, long into the future. True musical immortality.

Thank you, boys. For all you gave us.

With love,

Lena

The Video

My girlfriend asked me if I could write an entire essay on this video, and I wasn’t sure I could… two hours later, it happened anyway. Love you, darling. ❤

I really thought that this song couldn’t emotionally destroy me any more than it already did, and then the music video came out at 9 AM Eastern. I’m going to link it here, and then spoil it heavily, so don’t read this postscript until you’ve watched it.

We open with footage of the Threetles beginning to rehearse and record the song, which then transitions to footage of John staring at the sunset, while old footage of the boys in old-timey bathing suits appears… which then transitions into Paul, 81 years old and in dire need of a shave, singing to his best friend.

We continue in this mode for a bit: footage of Paul, George, and Ringo performing the song, intercut with slo-mo footage of John and George in his youth, acknowledging that this is, in a way, just as much a tribute to him as to John.

Then we get to Paul and Ringo singing together at Paul’s home studio in Sussex, and… well, this is when the magic happens.

One minute, 47 seconds into the video, and… it’s all four of them, back together again, through a seamless blending of new footage of Paul and Ringo, and old footage of John and George from the Hello, Goodbye videos, cleaned up using the same process as on the Get Back documentary. Just as the song itself reunites the band through a combination of archival audio and new recordings, the video does the same thing visually.

And the lyric that plays underneath this beautiful shot? “Always to return to me.”

Reader, as my girlfriend can confirm, this is the point at which I started sobbing again.

Being born in 1994, I always lived in a world where the Beatles were incomplete. John was killed when my mom was ten, and my dad twelve. When George died, I was six. So for most of my life, Paul and Ringo have been the only Beatles out there, I only got to know John and George through their music and the Anthology series.

Now, for the first time in my memory, they’re back together. John, Paul, George, and Ringo, reunited sonically as well as visually.

The video continues in this vein for the last two thirds of the song, showing various pieces of new footage mixed in with old footage, including several delightful scenes of Paul “looking” at his younger self in a control room, and Ringo drumming with himself, or Pepper George playing guitar with ’90s George.

In one scene, the roles are reversed: Old Paul and Old Ringo digitally inserted into the Hello Goodbye video, so it looks for all the world like the Beatles are playing and singing together again. Then there’s John pointing at Paul and mugging for the camera like a dork, albeit one proud of his best friend for finishing what he started.

In another scene, John appears to conduct the orchestra, while Paul watches from the control room at Capitol Studios… where he is then joined by his Beatles-era self, and ’67 George, who dance along to the music. Then there’s the scene of Old Paul playing his Hofner bass while sitting on Ringo’s drum riser… as two Ringos are behind him, keeping time, and George moves a cymbal around. It’s honest to god time travel, and I fucking love it.

But the most touching sequence by far?

That begins with a shot of the boys from the Penny Lane video, with various shots from the Pepper cover mixed in behind them, which transitions into footage of the boys together in reverse chronological order. We go backwards in time, from Something to Hey Jude to Rain to Shea Stadium, the colorized concert footage from the Eight Days A Week documentary, to footage from the Cavern, generously donated by the third surviving Beatle, Pete Best – the original drummer.

Fade to black and white as we move into the Hamburg era, and Astrid Kirchherr’s beautiful photographs of the boys during that period, overlaid with footage of screaming girls. School photos, that famous picture of John playing the guitar as the leader of the Quarrymen… we rewind all the way back to the beginning, to pictures of the boys as kids.

And then…

In footage from A Hard Day’s Night, The Beatles take their bows, as Brian Epstein taught them to… and they slowly fade away, leaving empty mic stands and an empty drum kit behind. The neon sign spelling out BEATLES switches off, and the video ends.

The Beatles have left the stage for the last time, leaving an immortal legacy behind.

If “Now and Then” the song was more bitter than sweet, the video is the exact opposite – more sweet than bitter. It’s truly joyful to watch John and George mess around and play with their old pals one more time, to see this band reunited once again through the miracle of modern technology.

But perhaps the best way of looking at it is how Giles Martin put it in an interview with Rolling Stone: “It’s a bittersweet song, which is very John. But with a combination of happiness and regret. It’s like ‘In My Life’ in that respect.”

That’s what the Beatles were about in the end: dualities. Light and dark, happy and sad. John’s solo work in the 1970s continued this theme, and it’s very appropriate that his old friends came together one last time to reinforce that message.

I don’t care what the detractors say. “Now and Then,” both song and video, is a fitting capstone to the greatest musical legacy in history. And as the other side of this single reminds us, the story is only just beginning, too.

Now, then, yesterday, today… forever.

So long, boys. And thank you for everything.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑