For those wondering, our title song this week is probably the most obscure Beatles song out there: “Christmas Time is Here Again” is the song from their 1967 fan club Christmas record, released on its own in 1995 as one of the B-sides of “Free As a Bird.” Ringo recorded his own version in 1999, for his Christmas album I Wanna Be Santa Claus, and like the rest of that album, it absolutely slaps. But we’ll get to that when it’s Ringo’s turn in Four Sides of the Circle.
So anyway, on to the actual episode.
That Christmas specials were going to return was, following the announcement of RTD’s own return, something of an inevitability. The move to a New Years Day Special never really made a ton of sense in the first place – New Years Day is kind of a nothing holiday, since everything is closed and everyone is hung over from partying hard the night before. If you want people to care about your winter special, you do it on December 25th.
No, what was genuinely surprising was that Davies asked Moffat to write the special instead. Could it be a tip of the hat to the modern show’s best writer? Probably. An acknowledgement that the RTD of 2024 can’t write quite as fast as the RTD of 2005? Who can say? At the very least, I am glad that Twice Upon A Time will no longer be Moffat’s Doctor Who swan-song. Here he is with his 50th-ever story, and maybe his last. Is it any good?
Well, of course it is. It’s Steven Moffat, after all.
Though lighter on the callbacks to his own era than Boom! was, there are still some familiar tricks bubbling up: two versions of the incumbent Doctor appearing on screen at the same time? That’s The Big Bang again, with a dash of the Space/Time minisodes from 2011 for good measure. (Minus the sexism, thank goodness.) The Doctor staying in one place before getting on to the rest of the plot? There’s the backstory of series 10, or even The Time of the Doctor, while Fifteen’s early puzzlement as to why he’s put on his adventuring coat echoes The Snowmen.
By and large, this is by some distance the lightest of Moffat’s Christmas specials, even more so than The Doctor, the Widow, and the Wardrobe from 2011, the last time he touched on motherhood in a Yuletide context. This story has no real antagonist, or even much of a plot outside of “the Doctor must solve the mystery of a star seed.”
But that’s not to say there’s nothing to chew on, because there is. Look at the scene with the dinosaur, where Joy calls the Doctor out and screams at him over the circumstances surrounding the death of her mother. The very real rage and pain on her face from a COVID-era Facetime call, amplified by the fact that “they” (read: Boris Johnson and the Tories) couldn’t be bothered to follow their own lockdown rules.
Hell, just look at the cold open, where one of the first lines is about the collapse of democracy due to encroaching fascism. In the 1940s we had to deal with Nazis, and in the 2020s… well, it’s still Nazis, it’s just that now we call them MAGA voters instead. Or any other supporters of far-right authoritarian regimes. The lyrics change, but the song is the same.
This is the thing. Moffat isn’t stupid, he’s seen the same news headlines the rest of us have. He knows full well that the post-WWII global order is on its last legs. Kamala Harris was the last chance we realistically had to save our already-crumbling democracy, and she lost, fair and square. Americans weren’t satisfied with the status quo, so they voted for Trump, again. He’s back to palling around with dictators, hoping to get them to like him. If America can fall to fascism, what chance does the rest of the world have?
It would be very easy for Moffat to get cynical. It would be very easy for him to write his own version of RTD’s Years and Years, the show that managed to predict Trump’s second term before the first one had even finished. (They even got the year right! 2024!) But as I’ve noted previously, Moffat has never been as cynical a writer as RTD. It’s just not how he operates, and it never has been. He always starts from a place of optimism.
And that optimism is what we sorely need right now. I’m sitting here on Christmas Night 2024, fully aware that in less than a month we’ll have Trump in again, ready to use the power of the federal government against all his enemies. (Including, maybe, a loudmouthed trans witch who writes about science fiction and music.) I don’t really have much to be merry about, when I think about the dark storm clouds headed my way.
But then I really look around. I am living in a blue state, and though the national Democratic Party has proven itself to be worse than useless in the face of MAGA fascism, at the state level, you still have governors like J.B. Pritzker in Illinois willing to fight the good fight, and attorneys general like New York’s own Letitia James, ready to go to the mat against Trump. (I’d vote for her as governor over Kathy “Arrest The Illegals!” Hochul any day of the week.)
I have my fiancee by my side, and my family stands ready to get us out of the country if that becomes necessary. I’m employed, I have money in the bank, and I know my gods will do what they can to keep me safe too. And I have my magic, ready to use to defend myself against anyone who might dare to cross me.
So I sit here, watching a Doctor Who story that ends up being about the star that guided the Three Wise Men to Bethlehem to witness the birth of Jesus, and I smile. Not because I’m reminded of the Christian Reason for the Season, (I’m Wiccan, after all, and our baby Horned God was born on December 21st) but because it gives me hope. That we might all just survive this long winter, and see not just Christmas 2025, but several more after that.
In fact, it reminds me of something an OC of mine, Gemini Shadow, said when I played her during a game of Mafia a long time ago. Trapped in a castle with three murderous ghosts lurking around, and having just come back to life after being executed the previous day, she considered all that had happened to her and finally said, “Even with all the death and unhappiness I’ve found here… I’ve found joy. Friendship. Love. Family. Even in the darkest of nights, when the clouds seem to obscure everything… there are always stars, even if you can’t see them.”
And where there are stars, there is hope.
Things will be bad over the next few years, that much is clear. But we can’t let ourselves give in to fear. So, in what is (probably) his real goodbye as a Doctor Who writer, Moffat leaves us with a touching, optimistic story about the power of hope in the face of dark times.
Which, when you think about it, is exactly the way he came in.
You’re right on the money regarding the theme of hope, the line about the end of democracy and the decision to set part of the story in an intact 2025 stood out to me as making a statement that humanity will endure but I hadn’t seen anyone write about it until now. Happy New Year!!
LikeLike