Wolf Trek: Loud as a Whisper

Captain’s log, stardate 80001.2: The Enterprise is ordered to escort Federation Negotiator Riva to a dispute between two races. However, when the deaf Riva’s ‘chorus’ is murdered by one of the factions, he has no way to communicate and must rely on Data if he is to succeed at his mission.


This week, an important moment of representation: Disability, specifically deafness. While representation of minorities has become more common here in the 21st century, in the late 1980s it was still relatively rare, comparatively speaking, especially for disabled individuals. As a disabled person myself, I’m very glad to see my favorite show tackling such an important subject so early on, especially when it’s done this well.

The pitfalls for doing a representation story, though, are obvious: just look at TNG’s own “The Outcast” and the way it clumsily attempts to be an allegory for homosexuality, then stumbles into being a clumsy transgender allegory instead. Or there’s the entire series of disasters surrounding the character of Chakotay, Janeway’s XO, on Star Trek: Voyager. One shoddy bit of research or one inadvertently disrespectful bit of scriptwriting later and all of a sudden you have yourself a “Code of Honor”-level hot mess.

“Loud as a Whisper,” thankfully, handles its subject as well as it does by dint of having been conceptualized by an actual deaf person. According to Memory Alpha, “Howie Seago, who played Riva, is, in fact, deaf and uses American Sign Language. He petitioned the producers to create a show about deaf people, in part to dispel untrue and prejudiced myths about them.”

Which explains a lot. When you have a member of the very community you’re attempting to write a story about, things are going to go a lot smoother than they would have otherwise. (Most of the time, anyway. See, again, Chakotay on Voyager.) Thus, the character of Riva has been able to forge a career as an accomplished diplomat not in spite of, but because of, his deafness: Because he can’t hear, he’s uniquely positioned to find common ground between the warring parties he works with in his day job.

Naturally, one is reminded of Geordi La Forge and his (in)famous VISOR appliance that defines his look across The Next Generation. When we’re first treated to a glimpse of Geordi-vision in the episode “Heart of Glory,” we see that he’s able to view things that ordinary human vision would otherwise deprive him of.

All this leads directly to a wonderful scene on the bridge early in “Whisper” between Riva and Geordi:

WOMAN: What is that you’re wearing?
LAFORGE: A visor. It interprets the electromagnetic spectrum and then carries the readings to my brain.
WOMAN: And without it, can you see?
LAFORGE: Without it I’m as blind as a stump.
WOMAN: Then your visor serves the same function as my Chorus, which interprets my thoughts and translates them into sound?
LAFORGE: Yes.
SCHOLAR: And you don’t resent it?
LAFORGE: The visor or being blind?
SCHOLAR: Either.
LAFORGE: No, since they’re both part of me, and I really like who I am, there’s no reason for me to resent either one.
SCHOLAR: What is your position on the ship?
LAFORGE: I’m the Chief Engineer, sir.
WOMAN: It’s a blessing to understand we are special, each in his own way.

This is the kind of thing that I wish more abled people, or neurotypical people, or cisgender people understood about individuals within minority groups. We are capable of doing the same things as “ordinary” people, and none of us are no more or less than you as a result.

For example: I’m pretty certain I have undiagnosed autism. When I was a kid (I think maybe seven or eight) I was tested for autism symptoms that manifested in boys, but being trans, the signs I showed were more common in girls, which the doctor completely missed. The ones most relevant to me include:

  • Having unusual sensitivity to sensory challenges

  • Having passionate but limited interests

  • Challenges in making and keeping friends

  • Having conversations limited to their own topics of interest

  • Choosing behaviors that seem to be shy, quiet, or unusually passive

  • Having symptoms of anxiety or another co-occurring mental health condition

It was not until very much later (read: when I was 29) that it all started to click in my head. Sensitivity to sensory challenges explains my extremely picky eating habits and narrow range of preferences. Passionate but limited interests? These days that’s Star Trek, Doctor Who, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, and witchcraft, and most of my conversations, both with my fiancee and my friends, revolve around those four subjects to varying degrees.

In public settings, especially when I’m surrounded by people I don’t know, I am very quiet. To illustrate, I work in the back room at TJ Maxx, and even though I’ve had that job for about four months now, I still don’t really know any of the people I work with. I show up, I do my job, and largely avoid social interaction. (Having said that, my store team is really huge, and has only gotten larger with the approach of the holiday season. So that definitely plays a role – I was far closer to the much smaller team at my old Walgreens in Missouri.)

And of course, if you know me long enough, sooner or later you’re going to see me get all depressed and unhappy thanks to a nasty case of anxiety. It doesn’t take much for my mood to be completely ruined, whether a bad grade when I was in school, poor feedback from my employers, or the sudden departure of a close friend from my social life. (I don’t so much make friends as make acquaintances.)

And yet! Look at what I’ve been able to do as a result of what some people, like eugenicists, would have me killed for. I’ve written two books on Doctor Who, I run a blog that allows me to dive deep into my favorite topics, I’ve become very skilled at cooking the small range of meals I eat, and while my list of real friends is quite small, the bonds we share are deep and long-lasting. Even if we go for long periods without speaking, the love between us remains strong. I’ve even been able to parlay my Star Trek/My Little Pony crossover fics into an original setting.

And that’s the thing! Our disabilities can be advantageous. The work I’ve done in nonfiction since 2019, or in fiction since 2016, would not have been possible if I were neurotypical. An NT would never be able to write, say, a million words about a unicorn from outer space across several different continuities. But I can do it, because I’m just that skilled.

And even when our disabilities lead to other shortcomings, such as with Riva’s arrogance that gets his Chorus killed, he’s able to bounce back (with Data’s help) and rely on his own skills and knowledge in order to keep doing his job. That display of empowerment is exactly what we disabled people want to see, and it’s something we can always use more of.

Episodes like “Whisper,” in the end, are part of why I like Star Trek as much as I do. Sometimes, boldly going where no one has gone before is as simple as putting minorities in command of our own stories. And that, along with everything else, is part of why this franchise has stuck around for nearly sixty years.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑