Captain’s log, stardate 80023.1: After answering a distress call from Grave’s World, Data is taken over by the consciousness of Dr. Ira Graves, who refuses to relinquish control.
The first time I saw W. Morgan Sheppard in something was all the way back in 2011, when I watched The Impossible Astronaut, the series 6 premiere of Doctor Who. (Readers of Back to the Eleventh Hour will recognize it as the first half of that season’s American two-parter.) In that episode, Sheppard plays an elderly version of Canton Everett Delaware III, an ex-FBI agent played by his son, Mark, in the rest of the story, set in 1969.
Old Canton’s role is a simple one: arrive on the beach, inform River and her parents that the dead man lying in the sand really is the Doctor, and that he is most certainly dead… then stand by and watch as the three Ponds put the Doctor’s body on a boat, light it on fire, and send it sailing into the depths of Lake Silencio. (Or rather, Lake Powell, whose water is becoming as fictional as its name in the story.)
But as we know, appearance and reality are often two separate things, especially where Doctor Who, and sometimes Star Trek, are concerned. We know from The Wedding of River Song that the Doctor who’s shot by the astronaut in the lake isn’t actually the Doctor at all, but the Teselecta, an android starship whose crew work not too dissimilarly to a group of Starfleet officers.
The Doctor asks the Teselecta to take his place on the beach in Utah, fulfilling the “fixed point” presented by his death there, but much like the way Gallifrey is eventually saved by dint of thirteen Doctors freezing it in time and making it appear as though the planet was destroyed, there was a bait-and-switch. The Doctor materializes the TARDIS aboard the Teselecta ship later, entirely unharmed, and returns to adventuring.
So. An episode of a major science fiction franchise featuring W. Morgan Sheppard as a prominent guest star involving a dying old man concealing himself within an android’s body. Am I describing The Impossible Astronaut or “The Schizoid Man?” Well, considering the title of the latter can describe the Eleventh Doctor and Ira Graves at the same time, I would say… neither, it’s both.
But where the Doctor’s deception is so good that absolutely everyone who watched series six live in 2011, as I did, was fooled, Ira Graves pretending to be Data is absolutely terrible. The actual transfer of Graves’s mind into Data’s positronic net happens offscreen, but it’s pretty clear (at least on a subsequent rewatch) that when we next see Brent Spiner again, he’s not playing Data, but Ira Graves doing an impression of Data that manages to remain convincing… for about as long as it takes for Data to beam back to the Enterprise and talk to Captain Picard in his ready room. And that’s being generous.
I want to pause here to reflect on how good of an actor W. Morgan Sheppard is. The two roles I’ve seen him in are entirely different in terms of style and tone – Old Canton is played with warmth, genuine love and affection, and melancholy, while Ira Graves is a lecherous old man with a tendency toward manipulating people, as he does with Data during their scenes together in Graves’s lab. And Sheppard pulls them off with aplomb, affecting a gruff American accent for both parts. (Hilariously, his pronunciation of “doctor” in Astronaut is better than it is in Schizoid.)
But the real praise goes to Brent Spiner, who is for my money the best actor in the cast, and this is a cast that includes a Shakespearean. It’s not that Stewart is a bad actor, far from it. Across TNG’s 178 episodes, he never phones it in, approaching even the worst episodes with the same amount of dedication as he does in TNG’s greatest hits. But the thing is, Captain Picard is always Captain Picard, aside from his transformation into Locutus in “The Best of Both Worlds.” (Small wonder why Stewart wanted to really flex his acting chops when they get to the TNG movies.)
But Brent Spiner, by contrast, gets way more to do than Patrick Stewart does. Just last season we’ve seen him play Data’s evil twin brother Lore, Data pretending to be Sherlock Holmes, and now we get to see him play Data as possessed by an egotistical old man. It’s an incredible range, and we’re still only at early season two. It’s a pleasure to watch him work, especially as the mask slips the deeper into the episode we go. By the time we get to the big climactic scene in main engineering, when Picard orders Graves to give Data back, Spiner’s menacing cruelty is handled with aplomb.
As a great big music freak, I appreciate the many song references in this episode. There’s “If I Only Had a Heart” from The Wizard of Oz and the namedrop of George Harrison’s masterpiece All Things Must Pass, (both song and album) but my personal favorite has to be the invocation of “To Know Her is To Love Her” (albeit gender swapped) during the memorial service scene.
That was a Phil Spector track, later recorded by the Beatles and released on the first Live at the BBC album. Their version is well worth checking out, especially if you’re a fan of John in his Please Please Me/With the Beatles-era balladeer mode. It was originally mixed in mono, but there are some great fan-made stereo mixes out there for those inclined to look for them.
Lastly, let’s talk about something that sticks out ever more clearly in light of Star Trek: Picard. Much is made in this episode of Graves’s genius as a cyberneticist, and the transfer of a living human mind into an android body, specifically a Soong-type android, will go on to have enormous ramifications for Captain Picard. In the ready room scene just before the climax, he says of Troi’s remark regarding the bridging of the gap between man and machine, “It seems he built that bridge. I may be forced to tear it down.”
Maybe for now, Captain. But it will be a mind transfer into an android body that saves your life at the end of the first season of your eponymous show, and almost dooms the entire galaxy at the end of the third, but for your timely intervention aboard the 1701-D. You may be burning down the bridge for now, but bridges can be rebuilt, and one day in the future? You’ll end up crossing it yourself.
Gods, I love Star Trek.
Leave a Reply