The Midnight Hour: The Night You Can’t Remember (Hell Bent)

I admit I’ve been struggling to figure out what to write about this episode. Not because it isn’t any good: it’s one of Moffat’s Crown Jewels, and that’s a list that already includes things like The Eleventh Hour and The Day of the Doctor. Mainly, I have to work out what I can say that isn’t just piggybacking off of Elizabeth Sandifer again. So, let’s see if I can dig up some pagan readings of this thing, shall we? That seems to be a pretty solid move.

So, then. This is a story that builds on what we talked about two weeks ago regarding sovereignty, and the Doctor’s violation of it with regard to Clara. The last time he did this in Kill the Moon, I compared him to the Horned God of Wicca, while Clara was compared to our Mother Goddess.

But this time, I want to return to my invocation of the Morrigan from the Face the Raven post. Specifically in her role as a sovereignty goddess… and what she does when that sovereignty is violated.

The Morrigan and her sisters, Badb and Macha, are each part of the Tuatha Dé Danann – an Irish word which here means, “the folk of the goddess Danu.” The Tuath Dé are often depicted as kings, queens, druids, bards, warriors, heroes, healers and craftsmen who have supernatural powers. Though they dwell in the Otherworld, they interact with humans as well, and were usually worshipped by them as gods and goddesses.

The Morrigna were known to be battle sorceresses: spell-casters who excelled at the use of battle magic. They usually used their powers to lead the peoples of Ireland, both humans and their fellow gods, to victory against various invaders, keeping the land safe.

But they had other powers too. As Morpheus Ravenna writes, “They haunt the stories, chanting spells of sleep, of attack, calling fire and bloody rain against enemies, altering their shape, laying geis-traps, binding, cursing, confusing.” Basically, you do not want to fuck around the Morrigna, because they will fuck up your shit.

Which brings me to the Sisterhood of Karn. The Sisterhood first appeared in 1976’s The Brain of Morbius, and though Doctor Who never makes it explicit, they are basically the science fiction equivalent of a witch’s coven. They have a High Priestess, and they are explicitly described as having psychic powers that allow them to transport matter around, which the Time Lords cannot do. This is straight up witchcraft, plain and simple. (That they’re all female serves a delightful contrast to the all-male depiction of Time Lord society we see in The Deadly Assassin, broadcast later that same year.)

The parallels get even more explicit when the Sisterhood returns in 2013’s The Night of the Doctor, where they restore a previously-deceased Eighth Doctor to life for a few minutes, and then have him drink a magic potion that triggers his regeneration into the War Doctor. If Time Lords are all about science, the Sisterhood is all about magic, and I am here for it.

So, what does all this have to do with Hell Bent? The answer is, this is a story where the witches of Moffat-era Doctor Who finally get their much-deserved revenge on the male patriarchy, very much including the Doctor himself. The Moffat era has always been about letting the women have the spotlight for a change, and when handled well, it dovetails nicely with witchcraft. So in that spirit, let’s return, for a moment, to the subject of the Morrigan.

To quote Ravenna again, “Kingship in early Ireland cannot be decoupled from religious and spiritual functions. It was understood, at its root, as a contract with the Otherworld. The king represented the combined and balanced aspects of the whole society, meditat[ing] between them and the Otherworldly forces through which prosperity was believed to be obtained.”

Thus, kings were bound by a sacred oath with the Divine. To honor their oath was to make the land and its people prosperous, and to break the oath was to deprive the land and people of prosperity. The Divine, and the Morrigna in particular, would then appear and sacrifice the king. Then a new king would be appointed, restoring the delicate balance of power. 

I mentioned earlier that you do not want to piss off the Morrigna. The story Togail Bruidne Dá Derga, or The Destruction of Da Derga’s Hostel, vividly illustrates why. King Conaire, our protagonist, dooms himself by giving false judgement to his subjects and breaking some of his gessi – a curse-enhanced oath conferred upon the king during an accession rite. Break one of these, and divine punishment will follow, as when Badb appears to Conaire as a crone, curses him with a death prophecy, and traps him in a burning house.

The Doctor, for the bulk of this story, finds himself in the role of a doomed king, just like the ones of ancient Ireland. His ethical code, embodied by the words “Never cruel, nor cowardly,” is his equivalent of a geis, and the breaking of it in this story triggers the curse he’s faced with at the end. 

But his geis isn’t the only thing he breaks. He violates the sovereignty of Gallifrey and its people by exiling Rassilon and the High Council, he murders the General in cold blood, and then he violates Clara’s sovereignty by yanking her out of time an instant before she dies, effectively making her immortal.

So, if the Doctor is a condemned king, who are Clara, Ashildr, and Ohila?

Answer: Macha, Badb, and the Morrigan. 

Let’s start with Ohila. She fills the role of Badb, when she appears as a crone. (See: Da Derga’s Hostel.) Throughout the story, she criticizes the Doctor’s various reckless decisions and heinous acts, from how he treats Rassilon and them to everything that happens with Clara:

OHILA: You have gone too far. You have broken every code you ever lived by.
DOCTOR: After all this time, after everything I’ve done, don’t you think the universe owes me this?
OHILA: Owes you what? All you’re doing is giving her hope.
DOCTOR: Since when is hope a bad thing?
OHILA: Hope is a terrible thing on the scaffold.

Ashildr, naturally enough for someone who used to ride horses, is Macha. They discuss the prophecies of the Hybrid together, (prophecies being another thing the Morrigna are known for) and in that conversation, Ashildr brings up Clara’s sovereignty:

DOCTOR: You killed her.
ASHILDR: No.
DOCTOR: You let it happen.
ASHILDR: No, I didn’t. Neither did you. She did. She died for who she was and who she loved. She fell where she stood. It was sad, and it was beautiful. And it is over. We have no right to change who she was.

And Clara? She’s the Morrigan. As I wrote in the Face the Raven post, a raven was one of the shapes the Morrigan took in the poems and stories we have about her. In fact, it’s the form she takes most frequently. So, in this reading, it wasn’t just a raven that killed Clara, but an aspect of the Raven Queen herself. The two of them are now linked together… like a Hybrid.

So, it is very fitting that Clara, alias the Morrigan, is the one to deliver the curse upon the Doctor. Not a death curse, as happened to Conaire Mor in Da Derga’s Hostel, but the wiping of his memories of her. Which, I suppose, is kind of a death. La petite mort, you might say.

But the Morrigan is merciful. She knows that a complete wipe would do more harm to the Doctor than good, so she decides to let him keep some of his memories. The adventures, mainly. But her face, her laugh, what she said in the Cloisters… all that is gone, until he can prove to her that he is worthy of having them back.

For now, all that remains is a message: “Run, you clever boy, and be a Doctor.”

And so the Doctor flies away in his magic box, while Clara Oswald and Ashildr vworp away in an American diner, off our screens and into the Otherworld… AKA, the universe of fanfic.

And that’s Hell Bent. When paired with Face the Raven and Heaven Sent, it becomes a Morrigan myth for the modern age… or at least, it does if you’re me.

Next time: the Doctor’s (other) wife.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑