The Midnight Hour: The Ex and I (The Husbands of River Song)

There are times when, if you are considering ending an extended endeavour, the real ending and the spiritual ending are two entirely separate things.

Consider The Beatles. In early 1969 Paul got everyone together at Twickenham Film Studios to rehearse new songs for a TV special, but it wasn’t until everyone collectively realized Twickenham was a miserable place to be and they decamped to Apple Corps’ basement studio in Savile Row that they ended up with enough songs for an album.

That album was called Get Back, named for the hit lead single that came out in April of that year. The concept was simple: this was transparently the band “getting back” to playing straight rock and roll again, raw and unfiltered, with none of the various production excesses that they’d been employing since at least Revolver.

The cover photo was taken in the same place as the Please Please Me cover had been, with the same poses – only the beards and suits gave any hint as to the passage of time. The rest of the sleeve mirrored Please Please Me perfectly, down to the liner notes on the back by Tony Barrow. And having listened to it, I think it would’ve been quite well regarded among the music press of the late Sixties.

But, of course, it never actually got released. Engineer Glyn Johns made two versions of the Get Back album for the Beatles, and the band turned out to be unhappy with both of them, so the tapes from that session simply sat somewhere at Abbey Road for a while until Future Convicted Murderer and General Insane Man Phil Spector got ahold of them. The end result was Let It Be, an album that only sounded good in 2021 when Giles Martin remixed it.

So, that was the real ending of the Beatles’ recording career, prior to the three reunion songs “Free As A Bird,” “Real Love,” and “Now and Then.” The spiritual ending is of course Abbey Road, the last album they recorded as a unit. Though there was some conversation of a follow-up, that never came to pass – by 1970 the band was dead and everyone had gone on to start solo careers. (Or in the case of John and George, continue them.)

The Husbands of River Song, then, is Moffat’s version of Abbey Road: knowing the end was nigh, he decided to go out the way he came in, with the Doctor encountering River Song. But this time, it’s the encounter she describes at the end of Forest of the Dead, just before she dies: “The last time I saw you, the real you, the future you, I mean, you turned up on my doorstep, with a new haircut and a suit. You took me to Darillium to see the Singing Towers. What a night that was. The Towers sang, and you cried.”

There’s a beautiful symmetry to River’s appearance here. Not only does it tie back to the Smith era, where she was a recurring character in each of that period’s three seasons, it brings Moffat back to the Davies era. It’s always a delight to see Alex Kingston, and here, she turns in her best-ever performance as the character. She and 12 simply work on screen – the exact reverse of her chemistry with 11, which had the vibe of A Woman of a Certain Age romancing a geeky 20 something. 

Had this been the actual final end for the Moffat years, he would’ve gone out on the highest of high notes.

But of course, it wasn’t. 

Chris Chibnall still had work to do on Broadchurch, meaning that he wouldn’t officially take the reigns of the show until 2018, following prep work in 2017. This meant Moffat now had to stick around for a whole extra season, with only a Christmas special to air in between. And thank goodness he did, because as we all know, even Moffat when he’s not firing on all cylinders is still brilliant. (I refer you to Back to the Eleventh Hour Volume 2 for more on this subject.)

But for me, my recollections of Husbands are forever bound with what I was doing, and what the state of the world was like at the time of broadcast. In terms of my personal life, recall that Series 9 itself was watched entirely while I was in Britain, primarily in my dorm room at Regents in London.

In between Hell Bent and Husbands, I flew back to the US on December 12th, where I settled in for a winter break that seemed to go on for fucking ever. Christmas Day itself was spent at my grandma’s for what would become the yearly gift-a-thon: an entire day, starting at around 10 AM, of opening presents. (We typically don’t finish until around 4 or 5 PM.) 

And she didn’t have BBC America, so I didn’t get to see this episode until sometime in the week between Christmas and New Years. I don’t remember which day, but I’m sure it was raining really hard in any case.

Politically… well. At the time of airing, Trump was talking about banning everyone from majority-Muslim countries (except ones he did business with, of course) from entering the US. Back then, I naively assumed he would drop out early on, probably after the Iowa caucuses, maybe New Hampshire at the latest. During the gift-a-thon, my reliably Democratic extended family made jokes about how he was obviously a plant and would never actually become president.

Obviously, we know how that turned out. 

Sigh.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑