Captain’s log, stardate 80042.3: Investigating the death of all personnel aboard the USS Lantree, Dr. Pulaski exposes herself to a premature aging drug and faces certain death if the crew of the Enterprise can’t find an antidote.
One of the recurring frustrations that one has with the second season of TNG is the replacement of its chief medical officer in the gap between “The Neutral Zone” and “The Child.” Gates McFadden was fired from the show at the end of filming on season 1, so Diana Muldaur was hired to play the new Enterprise CMO, Kate Pulaski. The goal here was to create a character who would serve as TNG’s answer to Leonard McCoy from The Original Series, down to the… rapport shared between him and Spock.
In practice, however, it turned out to be a big mistake. The problems with Pulaski become evident as early as “Elementary, Dear Data,” where she repeatedly treats Data like he’s a machine rather than a humanoid lifeform who just happens to be cybernetic, like everyone else on the ship does. (Recall, for example, the scene where he has to teach her how to pronounce his name: She says Dah-ta, everyone else says Day-ta.)
Then we get to this episode, intended to be her big showcase where everyone sees how good she is, and surely she can stick around another season… and then it all falls flat, as if the writers are realizing in real time that the character simply doesn’t work. Muldaur plays her scenes well, but there’s no warmth to her.
Having her argue with Picard just makes her come across as argumentative and insubordinate, because our Jean-Luc is more of a by-the-book sort of guy than James T. Kirk ever was. It’s all very well to try and go for a McCoy-type character, but you really have to try and modify the template to fit the new setting, and the TNG writers largely didn’t.
When Beverly Crusher returns at the start of season 3, there’s a distinct sense of the show finally starting to become the thing we all love and remember. Much as I disagree with the fandom advice to ignore the first two seasons and jump right into the third, I can understand why they make the argument. Season 3 clicks in a way that the first two don’t as consistently. But at the same time, I feel like watching the first two seasons gives you important context, so the growth reached in season 3 can be properly appreciated.
That said, we’re still left with the problem of how to redo McCoy with more than surface-level differences. The answer comes, at least for me, not from TV Trek at all, but from the world of fanfic: specifically, the character of Dustin Hoofer, the CMO of the USS Endeavour in my series, Star Trek: New Endeavours.
Dustin was conceptualized as Longhaul’s own answer to McCoy, complete with the requisite penchant for sarcastic remarks and the same down-home spirit, but with his heart of gold more clearly in evidence, particularly in his relationship with my character, Gemini. In our version of the rejected TNG story “Blood and Fire,” Dustin fuses both Starfleet medical science and Equestrian magic to save Gem’s life after she inadvertently becomes the host of a parasite.
Dustin forms a key part of the crew across the first three books in the series, particularly in the third one where Gem slowly goes crazy over the first five chapters, and he wrestles with the decision to declare her unfit for duty. He leaves the series at the start of volume 4, which I largely wrote on my own due to Longhaul electing to retire. I couldn’t write him half as well as Longaul did, and so he kindly wrote Dustin out for me… at least for half the book.
Dustin makes a grand reappearance in the story “Do No Harm,” which came about when Longhaul and I attempted to start writing again. Our story is actually not that dissimilar to “Unnatural Selection”: non-equine lifeforms begin contracting Equestrian diseases, and Gem elects to pull Dustin out of retirement so he can help solve the crisis. He agrees, and the mission is a complete success.
What made Dustin work as a character, aside from his influence from Bones, was his closeness with all of the Endeavour’s senior staff, Gem in particular. In one early side story we wrote together, she discusses her distrust of doctors with him, and he is quick to assure her that whatever else happens, she will be treated like a person in his sickbay, not a medical experiment.
One of my favorite moments between them occurs in Longhaul’s solo story “Dustin’s Dilemma.” In that story, negative reports regarding his performance as CMO have been getting back to Starfleet Medical, and his position is placed under threat. After initially suspecting Gem and some of his nurses as being the ones behind the reports, their names are cleared, and a plan to clear Dustin’s own name is put into action.
When Medical contacts the Endeavour with the news that another report, allegedly written by the good captain herself, places Dustin’s job in further jeopardy, this is the bit I wrote in response:
Gem glares at the admiral, her expression stormy. “Sir, with all due respect, it is entirely impossible for me to have sent that report, because I’ve spent most of the last half hour in a briefing with my senior staff,” she says, in clipped tones. “Whoever sent that report is lying to you. Dustin’s staff have been unanimous in their support of him and the way he runs his sickbay, and I believe you’ll find the same is true for our other personnel, myself included.”
She leans in. “On stardate 80584.5, I fell victim to a bite from a Regulan bloodworm. Had he not used his magical powers to save my life, I would have died, and this entire ship would have ended up like the USS Magellan. On stardate 81770.0, my counterpart from another dimension tried to kill me. It was Dustin’s quick thinking and medical ability that I sit before you today, and that you are not subjects of whatever warped hellscape my other self might have had in store.”
She tugs at the hem of her uniform. “Should you and your fellow admirals decide to drum the best doctor since Leonard McCoy out of Starfleet, you will not only lose him, but the rest of the Equestrian officers as well. I do hope I’ve made myself clear.” She settles back in her chair.
I love this scene, not just because it shows Gem in one of her most Janeway-esque moments, but it also illustrates how, exactly, the TNG writers goofed up in their conception of Pulaski. It’s all very well to do a Bones analogue (goodness knows Dustin hews closer to the template than Pulaski herself does) but differences are key. Dustin’s bad-tempered front is exactly that, a front. He’s a big softie underneath it all, and it’s one of the reasons I love him so much.
So, if a couple of fanfic writers can understand the assignment, a room full of professionals really had no excuse.
Leave a Reply