I had hoped, when I realized I would be writing this post close to the 2024 election, for a happier ending than this.
As some of you might have gathered, there were times during the series 9 portion of the project where I seemed quite negative on the election, since it was in progress at the time I wrote these posts. (I write for Patreon first, and then it goes to WordPress after.) What I now realize, as I take in the results of November 5th, was that this negativity was actually quite prescient.
I had hoped, and even planned, on writing this post the morning after a Harris victory. I would probably have started out writing something like “What a difference a decade makes,” followed by a list of all the things that have changed since this story first aired versus me covering it now. I had hoped to write about the repudiation of Trump, and the particular brand of fascism he represents, to contrast it with the story’s original broadcast.
I can’t do that now.
Instead, I am writing this post at about 5 in the morning on November 6th, having spent the entirety of the previous night watching the returns come in. Trump got an early lead in the electoral college, and never lost it. By all accounts, he cruised to a re-election victory, in spite of… well, the fact that he’s Donald Trump.
This isn’t the space for me to try and figure out why Harris lost, because the truth is, I don’t care why Harris lost. That’s an academic exercise at best, and entirely pointless in the face of a confirmed Republican Senate majority, a confirmed Republican presidency, and a likely Republican House majority.
And speaking of majorities, there is one key difference between Trump’s first election in 2016 and now: last time, he got into power because of the Electoral College overriding the popular vote. A majority of voters in that election wanted Hillary Clinton, but our asinine electoral system landed us with Trump instead.
This time? He got a majority of the popular vote too. Which is, at least, clarifying.
Though I’m writing this the day after the election, you all on WordPress won’t be reading it until after the inauguration on January 20th. So, in a way, I’ve come full circle, looking at the last third of the Capaldi era in the context of the Trump years. I only wish that there weren’t going to be more of them.
I remember feeling, in 2016, how bleak everything seemed after Clinton’s loss. In the face of what was coming, a silly, slightly disposable Doctor Who Christmas special felt like a much needed burst of joy. A last moment of happiness before the long, dark night of 2017 to 2021. I clung to it as tightly as I could, up to and including reading the accompanying Ghost Stories miniseries from Titan Comics. You cling to what light you can in dark times like these.
Now, it feels like a relic from another time. That’s not its fault. Like I said, I was thinking I’d be writing this the day after a Harris victory. Instead, Trump gets to be the second-ever president since Grover Cleveland to serve two consecutive terms. And while I would hope that Trump’s second term is as much of a failure as his first one was, I admit I don’t feel much cause for optimism.
Because what’s left? Kamala Harris ran the best presidential campaign I’ve seen since Obama in 2008, and she ended up being the modern equivalent of John Kerry in 2004. I don’t know how the Democrats bounce back from that. Hell, I don’t even know if we’re still going to have elections by 2028. Or if we do, they’ll be like Russia’s where the outcome is determined in advance. (Although, considering gerrymandering…)
The point is, I don’t feel the same spark of relief in bad times that I felt then. Because Trump’s second term, from what he has said on the stump, is going to be so much worse than his first one. It’ll be like living in Nazi Germany 2.0.
All I can do now is resist. And I plan on doing that, to the fullest extent available to me.
I may not get a spark from one particular Doctor Who episode, but that’s okay. There will, hopefully, be others.
What I can do is take from the show the message that it has been trying to teach me since the day I first discovered it, all the way back in my middle school’s library circa 2007: “Never give up, never give in.”
The Doctor left Gallifrey for a variety of reasons, we’ve been told, but chief among them (at least under Moffat) was a desire to escape the ravages of Time Lord society. It was corrupt, and frankly, who can blame him? I can’t even get too mad at him for deposing Rassilon at the end of the previous episode! I’d do exactly the same if I were in his place.
The point is, we can’t just give up. We can’t just let them run us over. If there is one thing about this particular election that actually makes me happy, it is the knowledge that I have already lived through a Trump administration. And I intend to live through a second one, too.
And that, I think, is the enduring legacy of the Capaldi years. Particularly as we enter the home stretch, and Moffat is forced, however obliquely, to deal with the consequences of the 2016 election. And now, as I sit here contemplating the 2024 election, I know the only thing I can do is take those lessons and apply them to the present moment.
We have to survive. The fascists want us all to die, and the best form of rebellion is to stay alive anyway, and do what you can to fight back.
I will not let them burn me, or anyone else that I care about. I will fight them with everything I have until I no longer need to.
And so should you. For the love of all that is good and decent in this world, I implore you…
RESIST.
Leave a Reply