The Midnight Hour: Punk Love (The Pilot)

It’s funny how, in a time of rampant authoritarianism and ascendent conservatism, even the smallest and slightest forms of representation can become revolutionary. Particularly when conservatives are in power, forms of love that depart from the “traditional marriage” framework are considered to be subversive. RTD got away with quick references to gayness in the 2000s because he was in Britain during the Tony Blair years – something like that would not have flown just across the pond in George W. Bush’s America.

The first Trump administration was a jarring shift from the Obama years. As soon as the clock struck noon on January 20th, 2017, the government’s attitude toward anyone who wasn’t cisgender, straight, and heterosexual soured to an extreme degree. Being publicly queer became next to impossible in the states that voted for Trump, and even in blue states, there was an atmosphere of uncertainty and worry.

And now here we are, 8 years later, with another Trump term to contend with. Second verse, same as the first.

It doesn’t help that even in the UK, Keir Starmer’s Labour party is about as friendly with queer people as the Tories were – meaning, not in the fucking least. Which leaves those of us who are in the queer community, facing hostility even from nominally left-wing parties, feeling alone and abandoned.

This is where representation becomes important. RTD may have been gay when he brought the show back in 2005, but the relationships he chose to depict were almost entirely heterosexual, at least among regular and recurring characters. (Remember those two elderly lesbians in Gridlock? I know I do!)

How ironic, then, that it fell to notable straight man Steven Moffat to give us the show’s first lesbian couple, in the form of Madame Vastra, a Silurian, and Jenny, a human. First debuting in A Good Man Goes to War, their appearances in series 7 and 8 confirmed that they were married, complete with truly outrageous flirting.

While Bill and Heather are not nearly as well developed as Vastra and Jenny were, it’s still a delight to see that, even with the ever-changing political situation, Moffat’s desire for representation remained unblemished. On that score, he’s a cut above his immediate successor, who waited until Jodie Whittaker’s final three episodes to bring in the “Thasmin” plot line, only to shut it down immediately thereafter. (And that’s without factoring in series 11’s depressing habit of using gay people as cannon fodder.)

Russell T Davies, back in charge since 2022, has wasted no time in building on Moffat’s progress in queer rep. In The Star Beast, the first of the 60th anniversary specials, we were introduced to Rose Noble – Donna’s transgender daughter. While the episode doesn’t make a huge deal out of Rose’s transness, it does still play a part in the story, and I was thrilled to see that both Donna and Sylvia were nothing but supportive. 

The inclusion of Rose came at a time where Britain was actively hostile toward its queer citizens, particularly those who are trans. Labour’s Wes Streeting actually agreed with his conservative predecessors on the matter of trans health care, leading to the Starmer administration banning puberty blockers for trans youth within weeks of taking power. Given this hostility, making Rose Noble a big part of Gatwa-era Doctor Who indicates that RTD isn’t about to kowtow to the right wing, in either Britain or America.

Let’s move along, then, to some non-queer aspects of the episode. Staying with the theme of RTD, something I found interesting about The Pilot is the way in which, as with Steven Moffat’s first season, it interacts with RTD’s storytelling style. In series 5, this was more of a structural thing: 13 episodes, a couple of two-parters with returning monsters, a cheap one, an experimental one, and a finale centered around a narrative collapse, all of which had very Moffat-esque touches. 

The Pilot applies this same idea not to storytelling itself, but to characters. Bill Potts is pretty clearly meant to be in the mode of Rose Tyler – an entirely ordinary working class girl who finds herself swept up unexpectedly into the Doctor’s life, and ends it as his latest companion.

This is an interesting move for Moffat, and a logical one. Since he only has one season left in charge, why not go back to basics and do a character as far from Clara, or indeed Amy, as possible? Making her a lesbian, even though it’s not a focus on her character, is still important representation, especially in an era where queer stories were (and are) under significant threat.

The Twelve/Bill era, particularly at mid-season when Missy is made a recurring character, is one of my favorite parts of the show, right up there 11 and the Ponds. (Including River.) Moffat has always excelled at writing 4-person TARDIS teams, which by itself is something of a minor miracle, given how tricky that can be to do right. (Witness, for example, Five/Adric/Nyssa/Tegan in the classic series, or Thirteen/Ryan/Graham/Yaz in series 11.)

Where Moffat does diverge from Davies is how Bill’s arc ends. In the original RTD era, Rose and Donna both found themselves forcibly separated from the Doctor due to traumatic experiences involving Daleks, while Martha chose to leave of her own volition. 

Bill leaves the Doctor by dint of being reborn as a water goddess, and deciding to travel with her girlfriend Heather, whom she meets in this episode. Happy endings are always very Moffat – even Amy and Rory got to live happy lives after being sent back in time by that Weeping Angel.

It’s fitting, then, that RTD’s return in 2022 saw him try and do a Moffat-esque character: Ruby Sunday feels like the Davies equivalent of Clara Oswald, and not just because Millie Gibson looks kind of like a younger, blonde Jenna Coleman. From the first moment we meet her in The Church at Ruby Road, there’s something very fairytale about Ruby – her mysterious origins, the way she’s hounded by bad luck, dealing with the goblins… all of these things echo aspects of the Moffat years, particularly during the Matt Smith era.

Even the finale of Ruby’s story feels very Moffat-esque. Watching Empire of Death, one might think RTD saw The Name of the Doctor and took extensive notes, what with the re-imagining of a classic series villain, a focus on the origin story of one of the leads, and keeping a tight focus on a small core of characters: Fifteen, Ruby, and Mel. The rest of the fandom might’ve turned their noses up at Empire of Death, but not me. 

In my book, the neo RTD era has been a rousing success, and I can’t wait to see where it goes next.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑