Wolf Trek: The Measure of a Man

Captain’s log, stardate 80080.6: When Data refuses to participate in experiments where he will serve not only as a blueprint but as a spare part supply, he is put on trial. As Data’s commanding officer, Picard argues at the suggestion that Data is not a free agent but the property of Starfleet.


This week, an all time classic of TNG and Star Trek in general: this magnificent episode was written by Melinda Snodgrass, an actual lawyer, and features Captain Picard passionately arguing for Data’s own sovereignty and sentience in the face of Starfleet being perfectly ready to declare him as property alone, rather than a lifeform. The season 2 blu-ray collection even includes a 57-minute extended cut, and since I have that version on my shelf, that’s the one I’ve watched for this post.

Data’s personhood becomes something of a theme across the second season of TNG – three separate episodes have dealt with it in form or another, be it Pulaski doubting that he can solve a Sherlock Holmes-esque mystery in “Elementary, Dear Data,” the ghost Ira Graves nearly killing him in “The Schizoid Man,” or his attempts to understand humor in “The Outrageous Okona.” Now, we have this, where the question of Data’s rights is finally put to the test once and for all.

And yet, as Underhill notes, this isn’t actually a Data episode. Or at least, not one in the same sense as something like “Elementary,” which is entirely about Data proving Pulaski wrong with an assist from Geordi. All he has to do is sit in trial and hope that Captain Louvois doesn’t decide to give him over to Maddox. Instead, Underhill believes that this is more of a Picard story:

“We all know who and what Data is because we travel with the Enterprise every week, but the Enterprise is in truth an outlier in the world of Starfleet, not the gatekeeper of its values and ethics: We can’t expect Starfleet officers who don’t live and work on the Enterprise to share that community’s same morals and ideals. So, when faced with a situation that directly puts him and his ship in conflict with the institutionalized system they ostensibly work for, Picard is forced to take a stand, as he knows his actions will not only have consequences for his friends, but will reflect the sort of person he wants to be.”

What we have seen of Captain Picard over the last season and a half, especially once they figured out how to write him, is that he is the kind of a man who will go to bat for the oppressed no matter what the cost. Even a pretty terrible episode like “Justice” at least has that one scene where he obliquely argues that Wesley’s life should be spared. And some 20 years later, he tries to keep the Romulan relocation effort alive, and resigns only when Starfleet makes it clear they have no interest in saving those innocent lives.

That second example makes one of Underhill’s later points shine all the brighter: “This is why “The Measure of a Man” is so revealing for Captain Picard. He’s angry because he’s being forced to legally defend something that should be self-evident. We shouldn’t need laws to tell us how to be decent fucking human beings, and Picard is rightfully outraged that the Federation apparently does.”

Underhill is more right than they know, as when their post went up (exactly ten years ago from the day I started writing this post, funnily enough) Star Trek was still something of a dead letter on the TV front. In 2014 not only was there not a new Star Trek show, Enterprise had only been cancelled fairly recently. The last big Star Trek something had been a movie – 2013’s Into Darkness. 

It wasn’t until 2020 when we got to the first season of Star Trek: Picard that we got to see the franchise return to the idea of androids as lifeforms, and the answer, despite the fact that Louvois’ precedent with Data should’ve carried weight, seemed to be no after all. Soong-type androids worked menial labor jobs on Mars, meaning that Starfleet really had built an army of disposable people, just as Guinan had feared it would. 

Then synthetic lifeforms were banned following the Tal Shiar-instigated uprising, leading to (among other things) the death of Riker’s son and Bruce Maddox, the guy who tried to disassemble Data all those years ago, fleeing to another planet to continue his research outside of the Federation’s purview. 

Picard, in his defense of Data, notes that the decision Louvois reaches “will reveal the kind of a people we are, what he is destined to be. […] It could significantly redefine the boundaries of personal liberty and freedom. Expanding them for some… savagely curtailing them for others.” The final analysis, taken with the first season of Picard in mind, is that despite Jean-Luc’s best efforts, the Federation doesn’t care about the rights of androids.

Obviously, Picard frames his argument in terms of race because he learns to see it by going back to the question of slavery, hinted at by Guinan in the Ten Forward scene. The implication is that If Louvois rules in Maddox’s favor, she runs the risk of repeating the same mistake made by the US Supreme Court in the infamous Dred Scott decision of 1857. In that case, the court ruled that “the U.S. Constitution did not extend American citizenship to people of black African descent, and therefore they could not enjoy the rights and privileges the Constitution conferred upon American citizens.” Thus, the Federation’s own Constitution wouldn’t apply to Data either.

But let’s put the analogy of androids to one side for a moment. Throughout the episode, Maddox continually refers to Data as “it” even though Data’s pronouns are he/him. This is called misgendering, and the fact that Maddox does it so often not only indicates that he doesn’t feel Data’s pronouns matter, it’s a perfect display of what has come to be known, following the re-election of Donald Trump in November 2024, as “your body, my choice.”

But as Maddox’s repeated misgendering of Data indicates, this isn’t just an argument about Data’s personhood, but his sovereignty as well. If he can’t even be allowed the dignity of preferred pronouns, what chance does any minority within the Federation have? By the time of Picard, we see that the Federation has turned completely against android sovereignty. And that dark turn, unfortunately, reflects back on our real world.

Just look at the issue of transgender rights in specific and LGBT rights in general. In 2015, the Supreme Court legalized marriage equality, and for a moment or two everything seemed to be moving in a positive direction for our community. Then Republicans started picking on trans people. 

Even though a SCOTUS filled with Trump justices found in favor of trans people in the Bostock case, the Dobbs decision of 2022 portends very bad things for the future of trans rights in this country, and ultimately LGBT rights.

A new case before the Court, United States v. Skrmetti, asks the justices to determine whether Tennessee’s ban on trans healthcare is unconstitutional. And if, say, we had a liberal majority on the Supreme Court, I might be feeling more optimistic about the outcome of Skrmetti.

Just as in 2385, precedent doesn’t matter anymore, as far as SCOTUS is concerned. Clarence Thomas believes that Dobbs, which overturned the right to abortion, gave SCOTUS the key to undo Obergefell, and Loving v Virginia if they want, and thus, they will almost certainly choose to uphold Tennessee’s ban on trans healthcare. After all, who’s going to stop them? 

Republicans have managed to move the Overton window so far to the right on trans people that not only was Trump able to successfully campaign against trans rights with that fucking “Kamala is for they/them” ad before the election, post-election moves by Democrats have indicated they are perfectly ready and willing to throw trans people under the bus if they think it will get them back into power during the 2026 and 2028 elections. 

In November 2024, Sarah McBride, the first and only trans person to serve in the US Congress, announced that she would comply with a new rule banning her from the women’s bathroom, and framed the entire issue as a “distraction.” And if that wasn’t bad enough, 80 Democrats voted to strip transgender service members of their healthcare in December 2024. Then Biden signed that NDAA into law before leaving office, breaking his promise to us at the start of his term that he “had our backs.”

That’s where we are as regards trans rights in this country: we stand to lose not only our right to healthcare, but our rights to everything else in general, including the employment ones that Bostock upheld. And our supposed allies would rather comply in advance to authoritarianism than stand up in our defense. We don’t have a Captain Picard to passionately argue for us in court.

Then again, even in the fictional world of Star Trek, Picard’s words weren’t enough. 

Which tells you everything you need to know.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑