Wolf Trek: The Dauphin

Captain’s log, stardate 80100.1: Wesley is attracted to the alien princess Salia who is accompanied on the Enterprise by a severe governess as they journey to a world where they will become the new leaders of her civilization.


I really, really hate this episode, though not for the same reason as L.I. Underhill, who hates it because it’s a Wesley episode. (You know you’re in for a ride when the title quote is that (in)famous line “Shut up Wesley!” from season 1.) I hate it because of a completely different character: Anya, the shapeshifter who serves as Salia’s “guardian,” though frankly, I feel like that’s understating it somewhat.

I can’t stand her because, though I understand that Salia fills the same role as “princess on her way to becoming queen” that we see all the time in fiction, that doesn’t give Anya an excuse to treat her charge like she’s a not especially bright five year old, or the crew of the Enterprise like they’re alternately enemies in a war or comparative dust-motes compared to how Great and Terrible allasomorphs like her are.

I was particularly annoyed by the scene in sickbay where Anya, who has already gotten on my nerves by telling Geordi how to do his job and insulting the 1701-D as being primitive, when we know she’s the pinnacle of Starfleet technological development, decides to order Pulaski to murder the patient she’s treating… before deciding to do it herself when Pulaski, understandably, refuses.

I really do have to wonder about the mindset of someone like that. No wonder poor Salia has been feeling so confined, as she expresses to Wesley during one scene:

SALIA: When I was on Klavdia Three, all I could think of was leaving that isolation. What makes me sad is having to face it again after seeing what else is possible.
WESLEY: Is that what awaits you on Daled Four? Isolation?
SALIA: Yes.
WESLEY: I thought you were going there to reunite two warring parties.
SALIA: What else do you know?
WESLEY: Very little. The ship’s computer doesn’t have that much on Daled Four. How will you stop the fighting?
SALIA: I’m not certain. I only know I will have many responsibilities when I get there. Your language has no word for the position I’ll hold. In many ways I’ll have even less freedom than I did on Klavdia Three.

All Salia has had, in the absence of real parents, is an extremely overbearing mother figure who goes through life (or at least the ship) believing that everything and everyone around her is a threat or too primitive to be worth caring about. It doesn’t matter that the patient in sickbay is nowhere near Salia’s quarters, all things are either threats or they are not. I mean shit, she even forbids Salia to join her on the tour, because apparently it isn’t safe anywhere else ON THE FEDERATION FLAGSHIP!

The plot between Wesley and Salia, well-acted though it is (Wheaton has always been a better actor than anyone, including himself, gives hm credit for) is still nonetheless boring and repetitive, because I’ve seen this exact dynamic in a million other things. It’s another Original Series remake, in this case, of “Elaan of Troyius” from 1968. 20 years later and we get this, only with unconvincing creature effects.

There’s a better way to do the plot of “Young teenager finds herself ruling an entire country,” and for me that would be the fourth through ninth seasons of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic.

While Twilight isn’t groomed to rule from birth in the same way Salia was, one gets the sense that Twilight succeeding Celestia and Luna as ruler of Equestria was in the cards at least as early as the start of season 3’s “The Crystal Empire.” Starting from season 4, where Twilight becomes the de-facto princess of Ponyville, the show has her learning deeper concepts about friendship through the journal before transitioning to diplomacy missions via the cutie map in seasons five to nine.

Once you get to season 9 itself, where the Sisters formally announce their retirement and Twilight prepares to take over at the end of the season, you get to really appreciate how she’s grown as a pony since we first met her all the way back in “The Mare in the Moon”/“The Elements of Harmony.”

(And having written all of that, I have the sudden urge to dust off my old MLP blogs…)

Do I expect TNG to do something like that in the space of 45 minutes? Not really, no. They probably could’ve done something similar in the Pocket Books line of novels though. After a rough start, the TNG book line really started to hit its stride in 1989 with Peter David’s Strike Zone, published a month or so after this episode aired.

Coincidentally enough it’s another story where Wesley is the central character, but unlike in “The Dauphin” where he’s supposed to be sympathetic, he instead becomes the victim of a friend’s coercion power and spends most of the book collapsing under the pressure of trying to find a way to save that friend from an early demise.

As noted by Memory Beta’s plot summary, “Wes recovers from both Jaan’s pushing and his death, breaking down in front of Picard about his need to know everything and ability to solve every problem—things he thinks would have saved his father’s life. Picard offers comfort and Wesley comes to realize the true expectations that others have of him.”

That’s the kind of Wesley story we really should have seen more of in The Next Generation’s TV episodes. I still don’t think he’s as bad a character as everyone seems to think he is, but he does get poorly served more often than not – just like Tasha Yar before him, and Deanna Troi after him. The TNG writers just get in a rut, and end up not knowing what to do with characters who aren’t Picard, Riker, Worf, and Data. (And sometimes Geordi, though not nearly as often as those four.)

That’s one of the drawbacks to ensemble projects – when you have a lot of characters to work with, giving them all spotlight can be really hard, and I say this as someone who’s spent a decade or so running into exactly that problem in her Star Trek fics. (At least with New Endeavours. I have fewer issues with A New Generation, since Gem is more explicitly The Protagonist in that, ala Michael Burnham in Discovery.)

Next week, the Enterprise runs into a few… technical difficulties.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑