The Midnight Hour: A World to Beguile (Smile)

For those wondering, I am technically cheating with my choice of essay title this week, since it’s a lyric and not a song… but the song in question, from 2006’s The Tragic Treasury, already shares the name of the episode, so I had to do something. And I didn’t want anything straightforwardly villainous – i have enough villains to worry about these days, what with the current occupants of the White House and everything. (Current as of February 2025, anyway.)

Anyway, since we’ve not looked at his performance in a good while, let’s talk about Peter Capaldi.

The Twelfth Doctor has grown by leaps and bounds from the grumpy old man that he was during series 8, transforming into the rock-and-roll grandpa come series 9, now mixed in with the aged college professor of series 10. Much as I love Matt Smith’s portrayal of Eleven, even I have to admit that Twelve’s arc over the course of three seasons is a bit less… formulaic.

I remember that Capaldi had been invited by Chibnall to stay with the show for a fourth season, but he chose to leave with Moffat instead – a decision that, with six years of hindsight, feels like the wiser course of action. (Not least because I can’t imagine him managing to make Chibnallian exposition work.) I get a lot of enjoyment out of watching him in series 10, where he feels so comfortable in the role, it’s difficult to imagine him doing anything else.

In keeping with the “back to basics” approach for the first half of series 10, Smile fills the “companion’s first trip off Earth” story previously occupied by things like The End of the World, Gridlock, The Beast Below, and Space Babies. This means we get to see 12 in rare form: he’s not matching wits with Daleks here, just exploring and investigating in a way that feels vaguely reminiscent of early Matt Smith.

In terms of plot, Smile has aged very interestingly in this era of LLMs and bullshit like Google’s AI summaries recommending that people add glue to their pizza and gasoline to their spaghetti dishes. Despite the name, “artificial intelligence” isn’t actually intelligent.

We may all think we’re dealing with the modern-day forerunner to, say, Commander Data from Star Trek: The Next Generation, but we’re really not. Just look at what this story’s TVTropes page has to say about our killer robots:

“The robots were programmed to make sure the colonists were kept happy and their needs met. Computers can only follow instructions they have been given, and they follow those instructions exactly. They don’t have morals or emotions.”

“When the A.I. observed sadness “spreading” from person to person, it assumed it was dealing with a plague that contradicted its prime programming (“keep people happy”), so it started killing people to stop what it perceived as a disease from spreading. All because the A.I. hadn’t been given instructions in how to react in that situation.”

Contrast this with how Data reacts to Tasha Yar’s funeral at the end of “Skin of Evil”:

DATA: Sir, the purpose of this gathering confuses me.

PICARD: Oh? How so?

DATA: My thoughts are not for Tasha, but for myself. I keep thinking how empty it will feel without her presence. Did I miss the point?

PICARD: No, you didn’t, Data. You got it.

Since then, Data kept a small hologram of Tasha among his possessions, where it serves as a plot point in two episodes: “The Measure of a Man,” where it is used as part of Picard’s case to prove Data’s sentience, and in the PIC installment “Surrender,” where it is part of an extended ruse by Data to merge with Lore, preventing the latter from taking over the former.

Now, granted, the world of Star Trek is far more aspirational than the world of Doctor Who is. But even so, it’s funny to me that what Frank Cottrell Boyce comes up with, in essence, is basically a sci-fi LLM with the attendant difficulties relating to what humans are like. Shannon Sullivan explains where they came from:

Eager to portray a future which would appear bright and optimistic — at least on the surface — Cottrell-Boyce created an environment which would largely be regulated by an advanced form of artificial intelligence. A key element of the narrative would then become the thorny ethical issue of the artificial intelligence’s autonomy after achieving a form of self-awareness.

The notion of a nanobot swarm was inspired by another of Cottrell-Boyce’s contacts, Andrew Vardy, a computer scientist at Memorial University of Newfoundland in St John’s, Newfoundland and Labrador, at Canada’s uttermost east. His specialty was swarm robotics, and especially robots which operated based on biologically-inspired principles; Cottrell-Boyce duly decided to call his nanobots Vardies.

At least they’re cute, I guess!

In the end though, I’ve never quite figured out what to make of Smile. I appreciate the focus on Bill’s growing friendship with the Doctor, but the actual sci-fi concepts depicted seem a bit… generic. Killer robot stories are something like a dime a dozen in science fiction, though I will give this one credit for the decidedly modern approach to presentation.

If I’m honest, I’d say I liked In the Forest of the Night more, if only because it had such wonderful pagan vibes that allowed me to do a Beltane-focused reading the story. Smile doesn’t even have that going for it, just a vague echo of The Happiness Patrol but without that story’s biting commentary on conservative politics.

Speaking of biting commentary, next week’s story seems far more up my alley… and there are elephants! Elephants are cool.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑