The Midnight Hour: Have You Seen It in the Snow? (Thin Ice)

The usual angle on this story, and the one that I took in 2021 when I contrasted Rosa with it for Adventures in Narrative Substitution, is to focus on the racial angle, and the way in which it feels like a response to The Shakespeare Code and how that story approached having a person of color visit Earth’s past. But I did that angle already, why go back to it?

With the election, and the transfer of power that will accompany it still weighing heavily on my mind, I want to focus on something else instead. Specifically, the Doctor’s speech after the moment where Sutcliffe gets punched in the face. In that moment, the show isn’t just endorsing anti-racism, but endorsing the systematic taking down of the wealthy and privileged:

BILL: Why? Production down, huh? Not enough people dying?

SUTCLIFFE: Girl, you show the ignorance of all your kind. Without that beast, my mills would rely on coal mines, and men die in coal mines all the time.

DOCTOR: I preferred it when you were alien.

SUTCLIFFE: When I was?

DOCTOR: Well, that explained the lack of humanity. What makes you so sure that your life is worth more than those people out there on the ice? Is it the money? The accident of birth that puts you inside the big, fancy house?

SUTCLIFFE: I help move this country forward. I move this Empire forward.

DOCTOR: Human progress isn’t measured by industry, it’s measured by the value you place on a life. An unimportant life. A life without privilege. The boy who died on the river, that boy’s value is your value. That’s what defines an age. That’s what defines a species.

I’ve been thinking a lot about that speech of the Doctor’s over the last few days. I’m writing this about a week or so after the 2024 presidential election, which not only saw Donald Trump win a second term by a landslide electoral college vote, but he got a landslide popular vote too, for the first time since George W. Bush in 2004.

And like, we all know what Donald Trump thinks of unimportant lives. Because for a raging narcissist like him, all lives other than his own are unimportant. Sure, he might be able to use and manipulate people into doing what he wants them to do, but all that means is that he suddenly needs these people for something. Once that goal is accomplished, they are disposed of. (Remember Rudy Giuliani?)

For the last two presidential elections, supporters of the Democratic presidential candidates (Hillary Clinton in 2016, Kamala Harris in 2024) had won the popular vote. This assured me that a majority of voters shared my values in an America that can be, if we work to make it so, the best version of itself. A society that is truly devoted to the principles laid out in the Declaration of Independence: Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

In 2024, there were good results for Democrats on the down ballot level. My former home state of Missouri voted to overturn the abortion ban in that state, the New York Equal Rights Amendment was added to the state Constitution, my hometown of Ithaca will be represented by a Democrat in the next Congress, and Sarah McBride of Delaware became the first transgender member of the House of Representatives.

All of this is progress, and all of this is worth celebrating. The New York ERA piece in particular will be crucial for me, as Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James have already promised to protect New Yorkers from the coming abuses by the Trump regime, via the “Empire State Freedom Initiative.” As they were in the last Trump regime, blue states will be critical in defending against, to borrow a phrase, ‘government overreach.’

On the federal level though the picture is far more bleak than that. We didn’t just elect Donald Trump to a second term with the electoral college. He got a majority of the popular vote too, as I said earlier. The Republicans won control of the Senate once again, and while it’s possible that Democrats might come back from behind and take the House, denying Trump unified control of government, I’m not hedging my bets. In all likelihood, Sarah McBride will have to watch from the minority as the feds attempt to, say, ban trans healthcare.

Because that’s the kind of country we elected: a country where unimportant lives don’t matter for shit. The 2024 election has made this clear on a national level. More people voted for Trump, by huge margins, than for Harris. The Democrats tried running the same warmed over campaign playbook that they’ve been running since 1992, and this was where it got them: political Siberia.

So given all of that, let’s return to the quote that spawned this extended digression: “Human progress isn’t measured by industry, it’s measured by the value you place on a life. An unimportant life. A life without privilege.” What can we say about the value of unimportant lives in the American electorate?

That’s a little more complicated. While there are plenty of Trump voters out there who are out and proud fascists, and they will tell you so because “I’M A TRUMP SUPPORTER” is their entire goddess-damned personality, there are also plenty of people out there who simply do not give two fucks about politics. As Elizabeth Sandifer wrote in a recent Bluesky thread, “Their experience of the political world is simply that it has been enshittifying for the past while. Four years? Five? Idk. About as long as a Presidential term. So they want change.”

And this year, Trump was that change. If you’re reading this you know that isn’t really true: Trump was running the same campaign in 2024 that he ran in 2020 and 2016, but with more vengeance and retribution and outright Nazism this time. But the point was, he still represented America’s immediate past. that was the entire premise behind the early Harris tagline of “We’re not going back,” and the later Harris tagline of “Turn the page.”

But it worked anyway. It worked, and he won by a landslide, because of something else that’s fundamental about politics: the importance how voters feel about the state of the country. In 2005, comedian Stephen Colbert coined the term “truthiness,” defined as ‘the belief in what you feel to be true rather than what the facts will support.”

To these ordinary American voters, they either don’t know, or don’t remember, how disastrous Trump’s first term was in reality. They felt like things were great for them back then, and voted for him based on that premise. They thought their lives worsened under Biden, and assumed that Kamala Harris’s potential presidency would lead to more of the same, so a vote for Trump, in their minds, is a vote for making their lives livable again.

That’s the national Democratic Party right there. They’re still a party capable of winning, just not on the national level. Which is a problem, considering the only viable alternative is the fascist Nazi Party, otherwise known as the GOP. And discussions about “figuring out how to win” at the national level are not helping matters at all.

The Democrats who are going on the news shows, speaking to the pro-Trump rags like The New York Times and The Washington Post loudly denouncing “identity politics” in general and trans people specifically, or the people who insist it was the economy or immigration or whatever that led to Harris’s loss, are doing a spectacular job at demonstrating the old Simpsons meme about the DNC is true. You know, the one with banners that read “WE CAN’T GOVERN” and “WE HATE LIFE AND OURSELVES.”

This is not a useful governing philosophy, and yet it seems to be the only ones that national Democrats know how to deploy. There were glimmers of something new in the early stages of the Harris campaign, what with the whole “calling Republicans weird” thing that got Tim Walz on the ticket, but then the summer became fall and all of a sudden the Harris campaign was listening to Clinton-era strategists who told her to tamp that down and run the safe plays instead, like campaigning with Republicans, rather than turning out their base.

And how did that work? Well, fewer people voted for Harris, on average, than voted for Biden in 2020. And the Republicans did what Republicans are always going to do: vote for Republicans, including Donald Trump. I genuinely wonder if this may be the election cycle that gets the Democrats to realize they can’t keep running Clinton 1992 and expect the same result. Or, for that matter, Obama 2008. But I’m not getting my hopes up.

We leftists might win back some power in the 2026 midterms. We might even win the presidency again in 2028, but I don’t know who the fuck is going to run, or what the party’s message is going to be, because as everyone should’ve figured out by now, “Vote for us and stop Trump” is not actually, and has never been, a viable electoral strategy.

It worked in 2020 because Trump had just caused the deaths of millions of Americans because of how he botched the COVID response. It worked in 2022 because American women had just lost the protections of Roe v Wade. Democrats hoped those same dynamics would lead them to victory in 2024, and it didn’t happen – they fell prey to the same anti-incumbent fever that’s been sweeping the world all year.

Now, this incumbency disadvantage cuts both ways. In four years Trump might lose again, just as in 2020, and then we’ll be in a cycle where no presidential term lasts longer than four years because we keep voting out the current guy and replacing him with a new guy. (And it will be a guy, because I really doubt America will elect a woman president, regardless of what race she is.)

That still doesn’t solve the messaging problem, but at this juncture I am well past the point of giving a shit about what Democratic consultants think will fix the national party’s propensity to steal defeat from the jaws of victory. Because they’re just going to insist that the Way to Win is to start sounding like Republicans on social issues, as Seth Moulton of Salem, Massachusetts is already starting to do re: trans people.

I don’t have a solution here. I don’t know if anyone has a solution here. All I know is that the climate is fucked, and the thin ice we’re standing on is going to get thinner and thinner until one day, we’re drowning.

God bless America.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑