Wolf Trek: The Icarus Factor

Captain’s log, stardate 80176.4: Riker is offered advice and a long-overdue retraction of old hostilities from his father, Meanwhile Lieutenant Worf begins to cause concern among his colleagues when he starts acting strangely.


It’s been a few years since I’ve watched this one, but a lot of the observations I had on the first viewing still hold up: Riker’s dad looks and sounds a bit like Peter Graves of Parts:  The Clonus Horror fame, the martial arts scene at the end looks incredibly stupid, and I honestly have come to really appreciate the Klingon stuff more now that I am a devotee of the Morrígan, at least in vibe if not in exact specifics. (I don’t think the Great Queen would want me jabbed at with pain sticks, anyway.)

Anyway! We’ve got a lot going on here, so let’s jump into it.

Obviously, the best place to begin is with the… shall we say, tense relationship between Riker and Kyle. It’s a different kind of tension from what Deanna has with Lwaxana though – Lwaxana is overbearing, loud, and prone to condescension, what with calling Deanna “Little One” all the time. True, there’s love in there somewhere, but it’s hard to see over all the bluster.

Kyle Riker is Lwaxana’s total opposite: tough as nails, distant, even cold. He’s sure of himself though, perhaps too much so, as that tense scene with Troi in sickbay illustrates. I love this scene, particularly Marina Sirtis’s work in it. You can see her figure out exactly who Kyle is, and systematically demolish the walls he’s put up for himself. And Kyle doesn’t like that one little bit:


TROI: What is it you want from him?
KYLE: I don’t know. Acknowledgement, maybe or
TROI: Respect is earned, not bestowed.
KYLE: Respect? I don’t need that from him.
TROI: Perhaps you want him to be proud of you. You carry great pride in his accomplishments.
KYLE: Absolutely. Look at him. First Officer of the Enterprise, just been offered his first command.
TROI: Yet you covet his success.
KYLE: Please. He’d be lucky to have the career I’ve had.
TROI: True, you’re well respected in your field.
KYLE: I may have something of a reputation for excellence
TROI: And false humility.
KYLE: My guess is that Will finds you pretty fascinating. Candor seems to be a trait he admires.
TROI: Honesty is the trait he admires most. And you should honestly consider why you’re so competitive with your own son.
KYLE: Competitive? Maybe in the past. But I’ve come here to help Will prepare for his first task as captain.
TROI: Are you sure he’ll accept such a dangerous assignment?
KYLE: He’ll accept it just because it is dangerous.
TROI: How can you be so sure?
KYLE: Because I would. And we aren’t so different, Will and I.


There’s a thing I used to say about my mother: when I was growing up with her and my younger brother, I was of the opinion that she lived vicariously through her daughter and son. She would pressure us to do things that she herself didn’t get to do as one of six kids, whether we wanted to do the thing or not. (And most of the time, it was not.)

Kyle’s concluding statement to Troi about how he “just knows” Will will accept command of the Aeries because he, Kyle, would do that is very telling. We know that Will is ambitious, and always has been, but he’s also aware of when he has a good thing going and when not to screw it up – something, I think, he learned the hard way when he first dated Troi.

But Kyle Riker doesn’t know that. He thinks he’s still dealing with a younger version of himself, and reacts accordingly. It takes him the entire rest of the episode to realize that Will is his own person, just like it took me moving to Ithaca for my mom to realize that I’m my own person. She also used to complain about always being “Lena’s Mom” when she took me to school, and all I could ever think was, ‘That’s just part of being a parent.’

All that is to say that I completely understand Will’s attitude for most of the episode. He’s spent 15 years stewing about how distant Kyle was, and now here he comes, the face of the Aeries assignment, wanting to make amends? His cold dismissal of Kyle as “this gentleman” when ordering an ensign to find quarters for him tells you everything you need to know about Will’s thought process.

He was never going to accept the Aeries assignment. But let’s talk about why that is.

First of all, the obvious: He’s not going to accept it because Jonathan Frakes is a series regular, and in fact, he refuses every other command offered to him until Nemesis, and only because that’s the last TNG movie. Him finally leaving Picard’s side is a sign that the TNG era is finally over.

Some more cynical fans and writers out there would say that there’s no point in dangling the Aeries in front of us when we know it isn’t going to happen, just like there’s no point in killing off Kate Stewart and the rest of the RTD-2 era’s UNIT regulars when we know their deaths are going to be undone. But for my money, taking that line is just bullshit, lazy criticism.

The point of the Aeries plot line isn’t to tease something that won’t happen until 2002. The point is to see how Will arrives at his decision. Rewatch that transporter room scene again, and you can see the exact moment Will decides he’s not going anywhere – when his dad turns out to be the Starfleet attaché. If it had been anyone else, he might have gone through with it. Maybe.

I think what clinches Will’s decision is Picard’s framing of the Aeries as being considerably less important than the Enterprise. True, it will be a ship that Riker gets to set the tone for, but that feels like a consolation prize compared to serving as second-in-command of the 1701-D. All this, I think, is Jean-Luc’s way of hinting that he doesn’t think Will should go through with it either, completely independently of the Kyle Riker stuff.

It’s all there, and you can see it in Patrick Stewart’s body language and line delivery: the way he awkwardly discusses the personnel transfer during the cold open, the slight awkwardness of the way he talks about leaving Will behind at the starbase, and his subtle (but noticeable) relief when Will returns to the bridge a few seconds later. Picard wants to keep Will around as badly as we do, he just won’t admit it to anyone.

And if I were in Will’s shoes? I’d stick around on the Enterprise myself. He’s not ready to command yet, no matter what anyone else thinks. He will be, eventually, but right now he belongs at Picard’s right hand.

And that should be enough for anyone.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑