You get two song titles this week, because I decided, since Pyramid isn’t really about very much except getting to Lie of the Land, to just cover both episodes together at the same time. Which means I have to deal with Series 10’s difficult mid-section, the Monk Trilogy – so named because these villainous monks are the main antagonists in all three stories, though IMO they only really work in Extremis, and it might’ve been better just to do that, leaving the episode 7 and 8 slots free for something else.
But that’s not what happened, so here we are: the point at which the Moffat era turns in, for my money, the worst stories of the Capaldi years. Even, say, something as bland and forgettable as Under the Lake/Before the Flood at least just failed to be about interesting things. This is about many things that are interesting, but fail at adequately exploring them.
I make an exception for Extremis. That story has a lot going on in it that I actually like, and Catholic iconography is always really cool, so I’m okay with that. It’s the one-two punch of Pyramid and Lie that bothers me. It’s not like Moffat is incapable of misfiring, because he is. Most people regard Let’s Kill Hitler and The Wedding of River Song as being misfires, largely because they were written very quickly and as such were not given the usual polish that Moffat gives his best work. But even unedited raw Moffat is still leagues better than, say, Chris Chibnall when writing an episode that isn’t a season premiere.
But this is only one third Moffat, the other two thirds being Peter Harness on Pyramid, and Toby fucking Whithouse, in his final contribution to the series, on Lie of the Land. So what we end up getting here is a giant mess – two stories split between three different writers that don’t actually cohere at all.
Thank goodness, then, for Shannon Sullivan, whose dutiful chronicling of Doctor Who’s production history at A Brief History of Time (Travel) has reached the Capaldi seasons. I will be quoting him extensively, because I’d really like to know how badly all this went down.
So, let’s start with Pyramid. Sullivan notes that shortly after production wrapped on series 9’s Zygon two-parter, Trump came down a golden escalator and announced his intention to run for president, launching a new era in American politics: “This prompted Harness to consider an alien equivalent to Trump, in order to explore the circumstances under which the people of Earth would willing cede their autonomy to an invading force. Faced with a crisis of global proportions, humanity would encounter beings who presented a benign facade and offered an easy solution, with the price being the world’s independence.”
I like this idea a lot. For all the grief people gave about Kill the Moon being an abortion allegory when it manifestly wasn’t, I think Harness had a good head on his shoulders. Even the mixed signals in the Zygon two-parter aren’t manifestly bad per se, they’re just not delivered very well.
An anti-Trump story would’ve been excellent, instantly placing Pyramid in the same category as things like The Happiness Patrol from 1988, which served as a vicious satire of the Thatcher administration in Great Britain. Certainly, Peter Harness had the chops to deal with Trump in a way that nodded to his slimy evilness in exactly the way Jack Robertson, Chris Chibnall’s own attempt to do a Trump-alike, never actually accomplished.
According to Elizabeth Sandifer, early drafts of Pyramid included a scene where the Trump-alike, Donald Brabbit, gets strangled by his own toupee. Which would’ve been absolutely hilarious, and timely too – same energy as the bit in Let’s Kill Hitler where Rory punches Adolf in the face. Or, for an example in this season, the Doctor punching the asshole noble in Thin Ice.
Sadly, the Trump-alike gets taken out in subsequent drafts, and what we are left with is a story that doesn’t really feel like a story. Middle parts of trilogies are always difficult to write, and this one really got short shrift: poor Steven Moffat was forced to do rewrites on his own, at his mom’s deathbed. And when something like that is happening to you, of course you’re not going to be at your best.
Toby Whithouse, however, has no such excuse.
Now, okay, attempting to coherently wrap up a half-baked arc would’ve been a difficult ask even for the greatest writer in the world, and he’s largely out of action because his mother is dying. But even so, it takes a writer as bad at his job as Toby “Main Pain” Whithouse to take something like “Doctor Who version of Nineteen Eighty Four where the Doctor is Big Brother” and screw it up. And hoo boy, does Whithouse ever deliver.
The Big Brother angle could have been interesting, if it had been allowed to stick and breaking the Doctor free of his Monk-induced brainwashing had been the entire premise of the episode, instead of being shunted to one side about 18 minutes in. Instead, the Doctor pretends to regenerate, and when the feint is revealed, everyone laughs at Bill for believing that the Doctor really had gone to the dark side.
Which, I’m sorry, is just desperately cynical. It’s a good thing Whithouse hasn’t written for the series since, because I’m sorry, but I never want to see his name attached to the program again. He’s only ever had two decent stories in his entire Who oeuvre, the rest have been tiresome Tennant-era retreads, sexist dreck, or so dull I couldn’t even be bothered to devote more than a couple paragraphs to the story before going off to ramble about the time I met Colin Baker.
I am honestly grateful that we got Chibnall instead of Whithouse in the 2018-2022 period of the show. The Chibnall era was bad, don’t get me wrong, but at least it was only bad because it was incompetent and centrist instead of whatever fucking politics a hypothetical Whithouse era would’ve had. Probably heavy on the man-pain, light on the joy and whimsy.
On the plus side, next week there are Ice Warriors.
Leave a Reply