Captain’s log, stardate 80195.7: While on an extended research patrol, Data makes contact with a primitive being on an unstable planet which is in immediate danger and has to plead with Picard to help his newfound friend.
This is another episode that frustrates me more than anything. Wesley’s plot is actually quite good, and shows the extent to which the writers are trying to treat the character with a certain amount of realism, rather than as the wunderkind they wrote him as in early season 1. In this episode, he’s given the task of assembling, and commanding, a group of science officers as they run planetary mineral surveys, but suffers from a lack of self-confidence along the way.
This is not something that would have happened in early season 1. That season’s version of Wesley would’ve found him boldly forging ahead with the entire team congratulating him and telling him how great he is. But here, we get to see him be vulnerable and unsure of himself. I think a lot of Wesley’s detractors tend to skip over episodes like this, so they miss that Wesley grows as a character considerably over the course of the series.
I mean, just look at his conversation with Riker in Ten Forward:
RIKER: Family emergency. (goes to Wesley’s table) You don’t look like a person who came here to relax.
WESLEY: I didn’t. I need your advice. Yesterday, when Ensign Davies turned in his geological survey, I asked him to run an ico-spectrogram. He didn’t agree.
RIKER: Do you think you were right?
WESLEY: Yes. I guess. I could have just been picking nits. […]
RIKER: Wes, responsibility and authority go hand in hand. I know you’re responsible, now we’ve got to teach you a little bit of authority. One of the reasons you’ve been given command is so you can make a few right decisions, that will establish a pattern of success and help build self-confidence. If you don’t trust your own judgment, you don’t belong in the command chair.
WESLEY: But what if I’m wrong?
RIKER: Then you’re wrong. It’s arrogant to think you’ll never make a mistake.
WESLEY: But what if it’s something really important. I mean, not just a mineral survey. What if someone dies because I made a mistake?
RIKER: In your position, it’s important to ask yourself one question. What would Picard do?
I really like Riker’s point here, though this is the wrong episode to make it, for reasons that I’ll get to a little later. But in general, Picard has been presented to us as the ideal commanding officer – tough, yes, but not unfair or cruel. He listens to everyone’s opinions and makes his own decision from there, rather than imposing his will on everyone else. He’s not perfect (season 1 Jean-Luc is a bit of an ass, and that reoccurs here) but that doesn’t diminish Riker’s point. If you’re a person of authority, Jean-Luc Picard is an excellent person to model yourself after.
Actually, Wesley’s plot reminds me of what Boimler gets up to in the Lower Decks episode “In the Cradle of Vexilon.” In that episode, everyone’s favorite neurotic wanna-be captain (as a recently-promoted lieutenant) leads his first away mission and it goes catastrophically badly, as he tries to do too many things himself rather than trust that the rest of the team knows what their job is.
In the end, as Memory Alpha notes, “T’Lyn tells him that she’s studied his records, and his promotion was not random, but that his exemplary work earned him a rightful promotion. She further states that as Ransom trusted him with his work, he needs to trust his team with theirs, as they could have potential he’s holding back.” Boims listens to her advice, and surprise surprise, the rest of the mission proceeds without any issue!
Well, apart from Boimler dying, but he gets better. (After all, this is Star Trek. Death isn’t permanent around here.)
I wish I could say that the rest of “Pen Pals” was as good. Because what we have here is yet another fucking Prime Directive episode, and I cannot tell you how much I hate those. While it’s all well and good to try and avoid causing accidental harm to people you don’t know, it doesn’t take very much to start using the Prime Directive in exactly the way Picard almost does here, where he nearly abandons Sarjenka to die, and only changes his mind because Data pursues an emotional appeal.
This goes back to why I said that “Pen Pals” is a bad episode to ask the question “What would Picard do,” because what he almost does is allow an entirely preventable death to occur. And if he had done that, he wouldn’t be worth his uniform, or our love and fandom. I don’t see what Data did as a mistake at all – it’s an entirely understandable reaction to, if you hear a call for help, respond and say something like “Help is on the way.”
It’s a bad idea to let yourself become callous, because that’s how you get to, say, denying the state of California wildfire relief money because you don’t like that they voted against you and you want to get revenge. Or to give Ukraine all the aid available because they’re white, while at the same time you support Israel in its campaign of genocide against brown Palestinians.
If you are in a privileged position such as “commander of a powerful starship,” or “president of a country,” and someone begs you for help, then your job is to help that person. If you can’t do that, then you don’t deserve to be in command.
Data, thankfully, sees that. Brent Spiner puts in a marvelous performance in the last quarter of the episode as Data goes about owning the situation, even as he disagrees with the decisions Picard makes. And he has a lot of work to do, whether it’s questioning Pulaski directly as she prepares to wipe Sarjenka’s memories, or leaving the singing stone in her hand, so that she still has some token of her brief friendship with him, even if she doesn’t remember it.
To his credit, Picard realizes in the ending ready room scene that he was acting like a heartless bastard in letting Sarjenka die… but that doesn’t make his subsequent wiping of Sarjenka’s memories okay either. After all, for all he knows, Sarjenka could have been born to become a Starfleet officer like Data.
But we’ll never know. Because sometimes, Star Trek chooses to do what is easy, rather than what is right.
Leave a Reply