After the disaster that was The Lie of the Land, welcome back Mark Gatiss for his own final Doctor Who adventure – his second go at writing the Ice Warriors in a classic-series adjacent story, following 2013’s Cold War. I went on record as really loving Cold War, because of the way in which it functioned as a delightful hybrid of the Davison and Troughton eras, anchored by a Doctor who was, in every respect, as much a hybrid of those eras as the story itself.
Empress of Mars is clearly working in the same “neo-classic” mode that made Cold War and The Unquiet Dead work as well as it did, but this time, the era we’re echoing (versus early Tom Baker and mid-period Troughton) is the Pertwee era, particularly season 9. And for those of you who’ve been reading my work for a while, you can probably see where this is going.
For the new people, a quick refresher. My love affair with Doctor Who begins in 2007, when I was in middle school. The library at my school contained, for some reason, three Target Books novelizations of classic Who stories: Doctor Who and the Cybermen, a Second Doctor novel based on The Moonbase and two with the Third Doctor: Doctor Who and the Curse of Peladon, and Doctor Who and the Green Death.
I never finished Cybermen, mainly because I misplaced it somewhere and never found it again. (Though I still believe, 17 years later, it’s been hiding in my math class and I just missed it somehow.) I did, however, manage to finish Peladon and Green, and it was those books that led me to seek out the show itself. Tennant was the incumbent Doctor back then, and while I caught some of his era live, it wasn’t until Matt Smith came around that I really started paying attention.
You can probably guess the rest.
Anyway, I’m honestly surprised it’s taken the Capaldi era this long to do a Pertwee riff. Smith got three: Victory of the Daleks, a riff on Troughton’s debut The Power of the Daleks, The Snowmen, and the aforementioned Cold War. Gatiss’s well-known love of 60s and 70s Doctor Who meant that he intuited, correctly, that the Eleventh Doctor just works in Troughton-adjacent storylines. Hell, I’ve always thought you could put him and the Ponds in The Moonbase and it would work marvelously.
And so, just as Matt Smith evoked the Second Doctor, Peter Capaldi has always evoked the Third, both in terms of costume design (very Pertwee, minus the lace) and in terms of general vibe, down to UNIT being a core part of the era. And being the oldest incumbent since Hartnell, there’s a visual evocation here too. (Also, his hair becomes increasingly bouffant-like over the course of the era.)
The Pertwee story that Empress most straightforwardly resembles, obviously, is The Curse of Peladon from 1972. That story came out around the time the UK was getting ready to enter the EU, and this one happens during negotiations surrounding Britain’s exit from the EU. Which was, in fact, the original idea Gatiss pitched to Moffat: Peladon leaves the Galactic Federation. But that never happened, which was probably a wise choice. Constructing entire stories around fairly obscure continuity points from 1970s Doctor Who never goes well for anyone.
So instead, we get what is functionally a prequel to The Curse of Peladon, in much the same way that The Snowmen became a prequel to The Abominable Snowmen and The Web of Fear by featuring the Great Intelligence.
Taking the GI’s role in this story is Alpha Centauri, portrayed by the original voice actress, Ysanne Churchman. And the scene is so delightful that I’m going to quote it in full:
VOICE [OC]: Are you receiving us? Mars, are you receiving?
IRAXXA: This is Iraxxa, Queen Empress of Mars.
VOICE [OC]: Ah, excellent! We have received details of your situation. We would be happy to send a fleet to your aid at once. A physical marker of some sort would be appreciated to guide our ships.
IRAXXA: To whom am I speaking?
VOICE: This is Alpha Centauri. Welcome to the universe!
The situation that Alpha Centauri refers to is what this story is actually about: Victorian astronauts have arrived on Mars, home planet of the Ice Warriors, leading the Doctor to try and save the Ice Warriors from the greedy invading humans. In other words, this is exactly the story that I wrote about in volume 2 of Back to the Eleventh Hour.
In the chapter on the Flesh two-parter, I wrote: “Maybe, just maybe, it would be nice if the show did a base-under-siege that argued for the rights of the monsters instead of demanding they accede to the will of the humans. Humans can be monstrous all by themselves, we don’t need external threats to show that!”
Empress of Mars is just what I had in mind, and I didn’t even realize it when I wrote that chapter. Here we have a story where the notion of empire, and British exceptionalism in general, is taken apart and shown to be not nearly as “good” as we were led to believe. There’s even some nuance here – it’s not that all the humans are evil invaders, just the one guy, Catchlove. Godsacre not only survives to the end of the story, he pledges to serve the Ice Warrior Queen, because she follows the same warrior code of honor that a Klingon might find familiar.
If this really is it for Mark Gatiss, and all indications seem to be that it is, then I am glad he got to go out on a high. Combining his love of Victoriana with his love of vintage Doctor Who was absolutely inspired, and he managed to turn in a story that does justice to both influences. Gatiss wasn’t a perfect writer, but when he was good, he was absolutely fantastic.
Well done, birthday twin. Well done indeed. ❤
Leave a Reply