Staying with the theme of lasts, this story features the return of Rona Munro, who wrote the last-ever classic Who story: 1989’s Survival, in which the Seventh Doctor and Ace encounter the Anthony Ainley Master on a planet full of anthropomorphic cheetahs. Here, we get a moody pseudo-historical that draws on Roman history and Celtic myth – catnip for a Celtic witch like myself.
So, one last time, let’s dive into a pagan reading of a Doctor Who story. This seems like the ideal specimen, wouldn’t you say?
Let me preface this with some background.
As part of my continuing studies of witchcraft, I’ve recently been reading the works of Raymond Buckland and Doreen Valiente: very big names in Wiccan circles. Valiente was initiated into what became Wicca by Gerald Gardner himself, and was responsible for writing much of the early religious liturgy, while Mr. Buckland was the man who brought Wicca into North America – he even founded his own tradition, which he discusses in his seminal work, Buckland’s Complete Book of Witchcraft.
In that book, Buckland writes a little about the presumed history of the Craft, drawing on the words of Margaret Murray and her theories about an ancient witch cult. While he does acknowledge that Murray’s witch cult theory has long since been discredited, it’s still a worthy story to know.
Very basically, the theory suggests that a religion of witchcraft survived the Christianization of Europe by the Roman Empire. This theory became so popular that it later inspired Gerald Gardner to claim that he “discovered a coven of such witches – the New Forest Coven, in 1939. Gardner said that he was concerned that the religion would die out, and so initiated more members into it through his Bricket Wood coven,” thus launching the religion of Wicca.
And like I said before, nowadays no one seriously believes that there was ever an ancient witchcraft religion that survived the Christianization of Europe. There were real pagans who worshipped their own gods, of course, but so far as we know, nothing like Wicca ever existed back then.
But the story of the witch cult, fanciful though it is, is still important. It is a story of faith, perseverance, and determination to survive, even under the yoke of empire. So, with that in mind, welcome to The Eaters of Light, a story that throws together an actual Roman legion and Scots Picts together to create magic all its own.
Sullivan helpfully explains where Munro got her ideas from: “Drawing upon her own interests as a child growing up in Aberdeen, Scotland, Munro’s thoughts turned to Rome’s Ninth Spanish Legion. It was posted to Great Britain in the mid-first century, but had vanished from Roman records just a few decades later. Most scholars assumed that it had been annihilated in a conflict, although debate remained as to whether such a battle had occurred in Great Britain itself or following a redeployment on the continent. A popular belief was that the Legion had been decimated after an uprising by Scottish tribes; Munro recalled this theory from Rosemary Sutcliff’s 1954 children’s novel The Eagle Of The Ninth.”
“Munro was also familiar with the Pictish Beast, a seahorse-like icon which appeared on numerous carved stones attributed to the Picts, who were the tribes of northern and eastern Scotland in the latter half of the first millennium. Their name probably came from the Latin for “painted”: a Roman allusion to the Picts’ custom of elaborate tattooing. The Pictish lands were eventually subsumed into the Kingdom of Alba, and their culture into that of the Gaels. Given the remoteness of their territory, Munro imagined that the Pictish Beast might represent a real creature with which the Picts had come into contact.”
Being me, I can’t help but appreciate the other question the episode tries to answer: why crows make the sounds they do. (The answer is, they are memorializing Kar, who sacrificed herself to keep her fellow Picts safe.) What draws me to the crows, though, isn’t just the fact that they are associated with death – but for me anyway, it’s a specific invocation of the Morrigna. One of them, Badb, most often appeared in the form of a crow, just as her sister Morrígan is associated with ravens. (In Irish, her name literally means crow.)
Now, I know full well that the Morrigna are Irish goddesses, not Scottish ones. And this is a story that has more to do with Scottish history than Irish mythology. But I still think the invocation angle works here, because the crows don’t integers in the progress of the events: they let things play out, serving mainly to comment on events, or warn the other characters of danger.
The way I look at it is, if the Morrigan can appear in my circle while I live in upstate New York, Badb can appear in second-century Scotland to act as a bird-shaped Greek chorus, if you will. This isn’t her culture, so she simply hangs over the story, rather than taking a more direct role like the Morrigan did in Face the Raven.
Further research indicates that in Scottish myth, “The bean nigheachain of Scotland appears as a washerwoman scrubbing the clothes and armor of those who are about to die in battle,” something Badb is said to do in Togail Bruidne Dá Choca.
Further Badb resonance comes in the conflict that between the Celtic Picts and the Romans that drives this story. The Roman Empire had conquered southern Britain by the time this story takes place, and they tried (in fits and starts) to do the same with Scotland, though they were ultimately unsuccessful.
So where does Badb come in? In reading up on the real history of Scotland and Rome during the events of this story, I was reminded of the First Battle of Mag Tuired. In that story, Badb—along with her sisters, Macha and Morrígan—fights on the side of the Tuatha Dé Danann. Using their magic, the three sisters incite fear and confusion among the Fir Bolg army, conjuring “compact clouds of mist and a furious rain of fire” and allowing their enemies “neither rest nor stay for three days and nights.”
And if you like that, check out what Wikipedia has to say regarding the Roman invasion of Scotland, and the Ninth Legion in particular: “According to Tacitus, the legion narrowly escaped destruction when the Caledonians beyond the Forth launched a surprise attack at night on their fort. The Caledonians “burst upon them as they were terrified in their sleep”. In desperate hand-to-hand fighting the Caledonians entered the camp, but Agricola was able to send cavalry to relieve the legion. Seeing the relief force, “the men of the Ninth Legion recovered their spirit, and sure of their safety, fought for glory”, pushing back the Caledonians.”
Obviously in the world of Doctor Who, things end quite differently for the Ninth Legion. Kar and the Romans sacrifice themselves for the benefit of all, and the crows, being omens of death, memorialize Kar’s name for centuries afterwards.
It’s a shame that this episode isn’t quite as well loved as Munro’s previous work, Survival, but maybe with the passage of time, that will change. I certainly hope so. The Eaters of Light is a rare story that isn’t afraid to engage with the world of Celtic Britain, before the Christians came and colonized the hell out of the place. This world has a magic and beauty all its own, and it deserves to be appreciated.
Ball’s in your court, RTD. 73 Yards was a good start, but I want something more like Eaters of Light, please.
Leave a Reply