Wolf Trek: Samaritan Snare

Captain’s log, stardate 80272.1: Riker and the crew attempt to rescue Geordi from a slow witted crew of Pakleds who claim to need the engineer’s technical expertise, while Picard is at a medical research base receiving a heart transplant.


Look. I really hate the Pakleds, so let’s ignore them, except to say that they end up being a really great initial antagonist on Lower Decks, without losing the incompetence that defined them in their one and only TNG appearance.

Let’s move on, then, to the real meat of the episode for me: Picard’s surgery, his growing relationship with Wesley, and general development as a character. There will be some invocations of Horatio Hornblower, and of course, Gemini Shadow… but one thing at a time.


First, let’s acknowledge that Jean-Luc is written a little strangely here. After spending much of the season gradually developing into the warm father figure we all remember from seasons 3 to 7 of TNG, his appearance in “Samaritan Snare” finds him seemingly reverted to the cold, brusque hard-ass that he was for much of the first season, and he shares a shuttlecraft with Wesley, the young man whom Picard has only rarely been warm to, and certainly never been close to… until now.

Far from being written out of character, (as Underhill notes in their post on this episode) I think he’s actually being written a little closer to the character who inspired him: Horatio Hornblower, star of the eponymous series of novels by C.S. Forester. Gene Roddenberry was a huge fan of those books, and as Patrick Stewart recounts in his biography, Making It So, Roddenberry wasted no time in cluing Stewart in when he was cast as Jean-Luc:

“Did you ever read the Horatio Hornblower books?” he said.

“I did, yes—when I was a teenager,” I replied. The publication of the Hornblower books, written by English novelist C. S. Forester, coincided with my childhood in the 1940s and ’50s, and they were right up my alley—Horatio is a fictional officer in the nineteenth-century British Royal Navy who, thanks to his intelligence and daring, rises from a scrappy, unpromising background to the position of admiral.

“Read ’em all again,” Gene said. “That’s who Jean-Luc Picard is.”

And that’s who Picard is being written as in this episode, the sci-fi version of Hornblower during his days in command of the HMS Lydia. Like, Picard’s concerns about his “image” among the crew that keeps him from having the procedure done on the Enterprise? That’s not something Picard would usually care about in any other circumstance, (I mean, if he thinks an artificial heart is bad, wait until you get to “The Best of Both Worlds,” sir) but it makes perfect sense if you read Jean-Luc as Hornblower instead. He’s a stoic, lonely man for whom image is everything – a captain can’t be seen as weak to the crew, after all, and that tendency bleeds into Picard here.

Fortunately, it’s Wesley who snaps him out of it. 

Poor Wes really seems to be the butt of the joke this week, what with trying to make conversation with Picard only to be rebuffed at every opportunity. And then this exchange happens:

WESLEY: I guess you would have preferred Commander Riker as a travelling companion.

PICARD: What?

WESLEY: It’s okay. You’re not too comfortable with me. I understand.

PICARD: Ensign. Wesley, that’s not true. You’re a fine young man.

WESLEY: You don’t have to say that, sir. It’s pretty obvious how you feel.

PICARD: Is it? How so?

WESLEY: Everyone knows. You don’t like kids. That’s too bad. You’d have made a good father.

PICARD: Thank you.

(Picard takes his book to a rear seat)

WESLEY: Didn’t you ever wish you had kids of your own?

PICARD: Wishing for a thing does not make it so.

In one line, Wesley gets right to the heart of Picard’s biggest insecurity: his awkward-at-best relationship with young children. Remember Star Trek: Generations, where it is revealed that Picard’s most deeply held dream was to one day have children of his own? Wesley’s right, he would make a good father – but between Picard’s career in what is effectively naval service, and his own standoffishness, he just never has the time. He runs into the same problem Kirk does at the start of the movie, he just doesn’t know it.

And the even deeper fear, something we can only see once we’ve watched the second season of Picard, is that he’ll end up like his dad, and not in a good way. After all, Maurice Picard, when we see him in flashbacks and the extended dream sequence that is the episode “Monsters,” is by all accounts a giant douche. Even accounting for the fact that he wasn’t as abusive as Jean-Luc made him out to be, he’s still not the nicest guy in the world, and his attempt at stopping his son from pursuing his dreams in Starfleet, really doesn’t help. 

So, Jean-Luc’s fear makes a good deal of sense – but as Wesley points out, it’s unfounded. Picard’s interactions with various surrogate children, like Wesley himself and arguably Data, all point toward the fact that he has good parenting instincts, he just never gets the chance to use them. 

It’s only when he does have a canonical son, the other Jack Crusher in Picard, (and thus, Wesley’s younger brother) and willingly throws himself back into the Borg Collective for long enough to rescue Jack from it, that’s he’s finally able to follow those same instincts, and become the dad he was meant to be… but again, at least in canon.

In my fanfic project A New Generation, Jean-Luc is actually given a child far sooner than 2401. Starting in 2365, Q tricks the Enterprise into visiting the pre-warp planet of Equus to search for a “mysterious artifact,” which turns out to be the magic of friendship. This is represented in the form of a young Gemini Shadow, a precocious twelve-year old unicorn who heals a lightly injured Riker, and whose insatiable curiosity leads her to meet Jean-Luc… whereupon she informs him that she wants to be just like him when she grows up.

And this is exactly what happens. She becomes the captain of a legendary starship whose name begins with E, (Endeavour, the sole survivor of Wolf 359) assists Starfleet’s Romulan relocation effort on behalf of the Equestrian government, and most importantly, manages to be adopted by Picard during her Academy days – her mother has just died, and after the funeral, she asks Picard (with whom she’s gotten very close, thanks to them writing letters to one another constantly) to adopt her. He says yes, though for obvious reasons, they try to hush it up.

Is it Mary Sue-ish? Oh, maybe, but I’ve never let that stop me. I brought them together like I did because, when Octavia dies in 2375, Gem and Jean-Luc are both orphans – his own family died in a house fire at the start of Generations, so by now, he and Gem only have each other for company. I think it’s only natural for them to want to make that legal, given the situation at hoof.

So, being me, I can’t help but watch “Samaritan Snare” in the context of Picard’s burgeoning relationship with Gem. I don’t know if she and Wesley Crusher crossed paths during her visit to the Enterprise in “Where No Mare Has Gone Before,” but it’s probable they did offscreen. 

Such a visit might actually explain Wesley’s remark about fatherhood: he is himself fatherless, and Gem, at this point in her life, is as well. She never learns who her sire was, and doesn’t want to know. Part of the reason she burrows her way into Picard’s heart the way she does is because she doesn’t have a father figure in her life, and wants one, even if she doesn’t realize it herself yet.

Similarly, Wes is clearly yearning for a more familial relationship with Jean-Luc than he’s getting at the moment, since we know that his father is long dead. Like Gem, Wes has only grown up with his mom as his primary parental figure, and gloms on to the nearest available father figure the first chance he gets: Jean-Luc. 

He’s clearly hurt in the above quoted scene, but then he and Picard have a conversation over dinner. We learn exactly what kind of an upstart Jean-Luc was in his youth (which will become significant for entirely different reasons in the episode “Tapestry”) and over the course of the chat, you can literally watch as Picard and Wes warm up to each other. By the end, when both of them say that they enjoyed their six hour shuttlecraft ride, you can tell they both mean it.

What Picard and Wes remind me of is Gem’s relationship with Ellissia Heios in the story “Potestas Trium,” a Starlight Endeavours installment. (Available in the Arcbeatle collection A Christmas Codex, by the by.) Ellissia is Jim Wylder’s character, the pre-teen daughter of the ruler of the Outer Confederacy, the antagonistic faction in the Starcatcher series of novellas. 

By the time of Starlight, Ellissia has just helped to end the Sol System War, and in the process of doing so, burned bridges with all of her remaining blood family. She’s then adopted by Gem, who takes her in when she realizes that orphans need to stick together – there I am reusing my own plot ideas, but from the opposite perspective. (This time, Gem is in the Picard role, while Ellissia slots into the Wesley/Gem role.)

This started when I asked Jim, years ago, about what happened to Ellissia’s birth mom. They didn’t know, which led me to the idea of having Gem adopt her at the end of the war. So, when I sat down to write the story that became “Potestas Trium,” I decided to make that canonical. Jim’s own explanations as to where Ellissia is, mentally, at this point in her life helped guide the story along, and by the time I’d finished it, I had something that I could be proud of.

All of that is to say that we all go through our lives with families of various sorts. Some of them are blood family, and others are chosen, born from friends or work colleagues or whoever. We all yearn for connection in this world, and none of us are meant to be alone.

So… here’s to family.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑