Four Sides of the Circle: Acoustic

I am writing this post on December 8th, 2024, 44 years since John was murdered. I may not have been around for the day itself, but the outpouring of grief, love tinged with sadness, and a wistful wish that things were different… all that remains unchanged. I’ve always lived in a world where John was gone, but I still miss him. In listening to his music all my life, it feels like I knew him, at least a little.

Wherever you are now, John, know that we love you, and that we miss you. I dedicate this post in your memory.


I’ve always had something of a fondness for this album. I know that in 2004, record buyers hated it because it seemed like a cash grab: 9 of the songs had already been released on John Lennon Anthology just six years later, and the rest of the songs had been floating around in the bootleg sphere for even longer than that.

But here’s the thing: Anthology has a lot of good stuff in it, but it’s also four hours long, and bootlegs are hard to find, especially in the digital era when music copyrights are locking everything down. So not exactly what you’d call accessible to most people. 

And, well, we’re talking about a man who only recorded music for five years, six if we include his 1980 sessions for Double Fantasy and Milk and Honey. There’s just not going to be a lot in the vaults that’s worth releasing. I mean shit, even some of the super deluxe Beatles remixes have had relatively bare sessions discs. You have to make do with what you have.

So, Acoustic then. I seem to remember I first heard it when I checked it out at the library, sometime in the mid to late 2000s. In this wild age before the 2009 Beatles remasters, you found all kinds of neat stuff – Past Masters in its original 2-volume configuration for example. Acoustic was one of those obscure albums, another introduction into the adult world of John Lennon’s solo work. Finally, sometime in the late 2010s/early 2020s, I finally got my paws on my own copy.

Let’s jump in:


‘Working Class Hero’: Take 1 of one of my favorite early Lennon songs, featuring Yoko on the talkback mic, John tuning his guitar at the start, and his voice cracking on the word “hero” at 3:43. This version of the song will go on to appear again on the 2021 remix of Plastic Ono Band, in its original mono presentation instead of the flanged faux stereo mix we have here.

‘Love’: A truly gorgeous acoustic guitar version of one of John’s best ballads. The same performance, minus the mistake, also appears on Anthology, but in mono instead of faux stereo. That version is marred only slightly by him playing a wrong note at the beginning.

‘Well Well Well’: A completely different performance of this song from POB, where you can pretty plainly tell that John doesn’t have all the words down yet. Still, it’s nice to hear this song unplugged – gives it a different vibe.

‘Look At Me’: Not just an acoustic version of the song from POB, but one where John actually strums his guitar rather than doing the “Julia”-style fingerpicking he learned from Donovan in 1968. It changes the vibe of the track entirely, but that’s not a bad thing – I’m always down for John sounding close-miked and playing guitar on his own.

‘God’: My favorite track on the album, and the reason why I love it so much. Between the heavy reverb on his voice, the preacher-like tone of the spoken word intro, and the way he sings the rest of the song, it really does sound like he came down from the Summerlands to send me a message.

‘My Mummy’s Dead’: Believe it or not, this is actually a different take of POB’s closing song.

‘Cold Turkey’: Possibly the strangest version of the song I’ve ever heard, John’s singing makes him sound like a cartoon character. (Specifically, something from the very early days of cartoons – we’re talking the 1930s and ‘40s, the era of Popeye and stuff like that. Still, all the lyrics are in place, and his desperation to be off heroin is as clear as ever.

‘The Luck Of The Irish’ (live)/‘John Sinclair’ (live): Two songs from John’s performance at the John Sinclair Freedom Rally in Ann Arbor, Michigan, on Dec. 10th 1971. Film of the second song was shown in the 2006 documentary The U.S. vs John Lennon. It sounds like this version has more reverb on it compared to the Anthology version, to the song’s detriment – it sounds like him and Yoko are singing in a cave. AND HOLY FUCK, THOSE PLOSIVES!

‘Woman Is The N—-r Of The World’: A mercifully short demo of John’s feminist anthem, played on acoustic guitar. This sounds like a different take from the Anthology version though.

What You Got: A great acoustic version of this Walls and Bridges rocker.

‘Watching The Wheels’: An utterly delightful acoustic version of one of my favorite late-period John songs, describing his contentment with just letting life go by rather than chasing the next big fad or capitalizing on his existing fame. For me, this is the grown-up version of “I’m Only Sleeping” from Revolver, only from a healthier perspective than the drug-induced stupor he was in during 1966.

‘Dear Yoko’: In case you though “Oh Yoko” was the happiest solo song John ever wrote, here he is in 1980 sounding absolutely beside himself with joy at being married to her. There’s a home video of his floating around online where he rehearses the song on acoustic guitar, and by the Goddess, I honestly believe he would’ve loved YouTube if he’d lived long enough to see it happen.

‘Real Love’: I love this version of “Real Love” so much. ❤ This is a different version of the song from the one that first appeared in 1988 on the Imagine: John Lennon soundtrack album, but it’s pretty similar to that one, both in key and in how John plays the song. 

‘Imagine’ (live): In December 1971, John and Yoko performed live at the Apollo Theater in New York to benefit the families of those who were killed during the Attica State prison riots the previous September. This is a wonderful acoustic version of “Imagine” that might just be my favorite version of the song ever. The Apollo show caps off a year which saw John play his first American concerts since the Beatles’ final US tour in 1966.

‘It’s Real’: We end as we began, with John strumming his acoustic guitar and whistling. It’s a nice, peaceful way to send us off, I think.


In the end, I don’t particularly care what the buying public made of this album. To me, this is John at his most intimate. When I took guitar lessons in my early teens, I thought of this album a lot – I wanted to play acoustic guitar just as well as John could. (I never got that far, because I stopped after three years and haven’t played at all since my freshman year of college, but still.)

Really, I wish this collection was longer than it is. It could’ve included some Beatles era stuff, since we know he used acoustic guitar a lot in that period. I mean hell, you could put his Esher demo recordings on this disc and it would work perfectly, though I understand why they decided to stick to solo material only.

It’s an interesting little album, this. You wouldn’t do something like this now, in an age where solo Lennon releases are more strictly controlled than they used to be. Remixing the back catalogue is pretty much all we get these days, and while that’s very far from bad, it does still make you wonder what would happen if they put out something like this now. (Certainly, with the new MAL de-mixing software, they could dramatically improve the sound quality.)

Anyway: next week, we dive into even more John Lennon demo tracks, as we jump forward to 2010’s Lennon Signature Box. Hope to see you then.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑