One of the things that quickly becomes clear, at least if you’re a Celtic witch like myself with a love of the Irish pantheon of gods, is that you can’t swing the Dagda’s club without hitting Lora O’Brien with it. She’s made quite a name for herself in the world of Celtic paganism – her 2004 book, Irish Witchcraft, aims to be a comprehensive guide to the basics Ireland’s own brand of magic practice, in the tradition of the Welsh and Scottish Witchcraft books by Mhara Starling and Barbara Meicklejohn-Free.
And, to be fair, it is that. O’Brien, being a native-born Irishwoman, is clearly knowledgeable of the material she covers. Her sections on the Tuatha Dé are some of the most in-depth I’ve ever come across, and her explanations on the four Irish sabbats (Samhain, Imbolg, Bealtaine, and Lúnasa) makes for fascinating reading.
And if all this was written in a warm, welcoming tone similar to that of Kristoff Hughes in Cerridwen or Mhara Starling in Welsh Witchcraft, I likely wouldn’t be writing this post, because there’s only so many different ways you can say “The author presents the material in a way that makes it approachable to non-native seekers.”
O’Brien certainly appears to do that at first glance – there’s a reason why this book sold like hotcakes when it came out in the ‘00s, and became the launching point for her current fame and general reputation as being The Authority on Irish paganism.
But if you ask me, all these people were taken in by O’Brien’s charm. It’s not their fault – we Irish are a charming lot. They wouldn’t think to look beneath the surface. Once you do, suddenly the whole book takes on a different cast, and that is not a compliment.
There was an unpleasant vibe to the book almost from the first chapter. Despite not being Wiccan, O’Brien still seemingly thought it was appropriate to explain to me how my own religion works, and then adds this toward the end of the chapter: “[Wicca] is not the same as Witchcraft. Wiccans don’t necessarily use magic. That being said, most will at least believe that magic is possible; that it is possible to effect the world by channeling and directing energy, even if they choose not to do so.”
This is a pretty massive mistake to make, considering that magic and witchcraft is quite literally the cornerstone of the Wiccan religion. Gerald Gardner honestly believed he was preserving an ancient European witch cult, and magic, as my friend Anna Katherina has said, is the main mode of worship in this faith. You can’t follow this path without doing magic. It’s a requirement.
But the thing is, I don’t think Lora O’Brien really cares about what Wiccans actually believe or do in our regular practices. Whenever neo-Paganism in any form is mentioned, and Wicca is most often the term she uses, the general vibe with which she treats the faith is one of grudging acknowledgement mixed with disdain. Or outright hatred, in the case of eclectic Wiccans.
It is very ironic that O’Brien is so vehemently against contemporary paganism, given that her own spiritual beliefs are also syncretized and pieced together from the surviving bits and pieces of Irish lore, Wiccan coven structures, ceremonial magic systems, and respect for the land and the spirits thereof. But I guess it’s only acceptable when she does it, and bad when everyone else does.
This narrow-mindedness crops up in other ways as well. The second part of the book (the revealingly titled How It Is) gets down to the nuts and bolts of her personal practice, which includes the requisite chapter on how SHE PERSONALLY sets up meeting the Divine. (I emphasize all this because she certainly fucking doesn’t.)
Most pagan books I’ve read, when they talk about reaching out to the gods, will keep it simple: do your research on the deity’s particular mythology, have a list of correspondences handy so you’ll know what items to use when making offerings, and when you’re in the ritual circle, make sure you’re coming from a place of respect and humbleness.
O’Brien has all those basic building blocks in place… and then she takes it a little far. The first point she makes for the non-culturally Irish, when she deigns to acknowledge us at all, is to first state that any contact with any god, particularly the Irish ones, must be done in their native language.
Now, to be fair, learning Irish if you are going to be interacting with that particular pantheon makes a certain amount of sense. You don’t want to find yourself contacting a particular deity and accidentally mispronounce their name. Pronunciation guides are extremely helpful in avoiding such mistakes, and as Anna again notes, “it’s just respectful to learn the language in general.”
Part of my work with the Great Queen will, one day, require me to learn Irish. I don’t think she expects me to become fluent in it, just to learn enough that I can engage with her, and the culture she comes from, more easily.
But in O’Brien’s opinion, even the fact that the Morrígan and I have communicated in English in the first place is Extremely Bad. She writes, “To continually address the Irish Gods in the tongue of their oppressors, with no knowledge of or reference to their own tongue and the heart of their own people, is at best rude and ignorant, and at worst can even be dangerous (depending on a number of other factors).”
First of all, the Morrígan did not send a murder of crows to chase and peck at me because I dared to conduct my first ritual for her in English. She just used the language I was speaking, and came to me where I am. That’s what the gods do. As Kristoff Hughes writes in Cerridwen, “Cerridwen is now a goddess of more than one tongue. She exists to inspire peoples beyond her native Wales. She is goddess and mother of Awen to modern Druids, but she is also a powerful witch goddess.”
Having said that, Hughes does believe it’s important to develop non-appropriative practices. He suggests to his readers that they learn a little Welsh, so we know how to pronounce words the right way, and out of respect to Cerridwen and the culture that created her. There’s no judgment in his tone, and for that I am thankful.
Because here’s the other thing that Hughes understands and O’Brien doesn’t: Cerridwen has, as noted above, moved beyond her native Wales and become a goddess worshipped by people all over the world. The same thing is self-evident with regard to the Morrígan. She doesn’t just approach people who speak Irish, she comes to everyone.
It’s telling that Hughes, a born-and-bred Welshman, describes himself and his people as Cerridwen’s custodians, whereas O’Brien sets herself up as THE authority on Irish Paganism of any form, which gets at something that’s bothered me about this entire book.
This is not a text that is geared toward non-culturally Irish people. Which seems counterintuitive, but it’s really not when you look at why the book was written in the first place. She says at the very end: “This, I hope, is the book I never had but always looked for, the book a lost and lonely 16-year-old searched the shelves of bookshops for, all those years ago; alas, in vain.”
There’s nothing inherently wrong with that approach – there are plenty of books out there, on a variety of subjects, that were written with the idea of finally fulfilling a long-yearned for need. But once a book goes out into the world, it’s no longer ours, at least spiritually. Other people take the book and make it a part of their lives, and if we’re doing our jobs right, we craft the book in such a way that not only do we satisfy our own inner children, but the people out there today who need this book as much as we did then, no matter where they live.
Unfortunately, much of this book appears to have been written from the starting assumption that most people reading it would be exactly like her: beginner Irish polytheists who may not know all the details about pre-Christian Ireland and want to learn more. The non-culturally Irish, including those who are a part of the Irish diaspora (like myself), need not apply.
As far as Lora O’Brien is concerned, Irish witchcraft is a closed practice.
Which, I am sure, would be a big surprise to the Morrígan, given that (as I stated earlier) she has appeared to a great many people, some of whom may only have tangential ties to Ireland. I don’t think she much cares – the gods call whom they call, and for all I know, she might actually appreciate the opportunity to see the cultures her non-culturally Irish devotees come from.
But Lora? She has a different perspective. As she herself says in a post on her own website: “However, if someone has deeply studied the history, lore, and culture this Goddess was born from, and has spent the same amount of time and effort building a practical experiential relationship with her as I have (or similar to be fair, as I’ve not met anyone who’s put this amount of time and effort in, anywhere in the world, to date)… and their perception or interpretation differs from mine, I won’t say they’re wrong.”
The implied subtext here? Lora O’Brien evidently believes that she is the Great Queen’s gift to paganism, and there are none more qualified than Lora O’Brien to decide who gets to be a True Believer of the Morrígan and who’s just pretending. Which, I would assume, would include everyone who does not practice paganism in exactly the same way she does… and of those who do, she’s not sure about anyone not named Lora O’Brien.
It takes an incredible amount of egotism to write a paragraph like the one I just quoted, and still more to presume that one person, alone, can preach the gospel of the Morrígan, when that is not how paganism has ever worked, nor should it ever work that way. I mean, just look at how she reacts when considering the question of approaching the gods in a way that isn’t the method she’s come up with, which involves much metaphysical journeying to the places where those gods call home:
“And really, if you are not at least familiar with this sort of magical work already, what the heck are you doing dedicating yourself to a deity? Do you have any idea what you are letting yourself in for? Go back and stick with the first few steps outlined here, and keep working on your magical development before you make such an intense commitment.”
This is Lora O’Brien in a nutshell. She has one method by which she approaches the divine, and the only allowance she makes is for people who can’t physically come to Ireland and visit the Cave of Cats themselves. And even then, it’s grudging. I can’t visualize for anything, I’ve tried, and none of the methods work for me. And since I can’t exactly afford to fly to Dublin either, by O’Brien’s own logic, I shouldn’t be pagan at all, since I can’t make the “required” pilgrimages.
You know who Lora O’Brien is? She’s Irish paganism’s answer to Bev Keane from Midnight Mass. In Lora’s world, there is one way to worship the gods, and everyone else can fuck off. It wouldn’t matter one jot to Lora that the Morrígan, when she and I first encountered each other, did the divine equivalent of throwing rocks at my window in order to get my attention. To Lora, that experience is Not Valid.
And yet, O’Brien is still held up as a community elder. Like I said at the beginning, you can’t swing the Dagda’s club in the tiny Irish Polytheism community and not come across her. She is simply everywhere, building an online paganism school, earning herself the title of reverend, and generally acting like she is the Morrígan Pope.
For crying out loud, she has a book on the Morrígan specifically coming out in August… and its sole distinguishing feature from books like Morgan Daimler’s Raven Goddess and Morpheus Ravenna’s The Book of the Great Queen is that A NATIVE IRISH PERSON WROTE IT.
I can already tell you what this book will be like: an overview of the mythology, possibly some summaries of various stories of note, like the one she gives in the Morrigan’s section of “Users of Magic” only longer. After that will come her particular framework for modern devotional practice, shot through with O’Brien’s particular blend of nationalist, prescriptivist condescension.
In other words, it’s not a book you should waste your time with. Neither, for that matter, is Irish Witchcraft.
Leave a Reply