Wolf Trek: Peak Performance/Shades of Grey

Captain’s log, stardate 80330.3: The Enterprise undertakes Federation war-games, as Zakdorn tactical observer Kolrami observes. Picard is pitted against Riker in a maneuver that is harmless until a Ferengi attack puts the crew of the Enterprise in a no-win situation.

While exploring planet Surata IV with Geordi, Riker is stung by an alien thorn whose poison creeps up his spine toward his brain. Pulaski brings him back to the ship and tries to trigger emotional responses to destroy the poison.


At long last, we end our look at season 2 of TNG with a pair of Riker episodes, though I admit I’m mainly going to focus on “Peak Performance” here because I think “Shades of Grey” sucks ass. I mean, of course it does, it’s a clip show centering on Riker, and no good has ever come out of a clip show.

Meanwhile, “Peak Performance” is brilliant, and if you swapped these two around in viewing order, you’d actually have season 2 ending on a good note – which makes the fact that it didn’t air that way reflective of how, as a season, S2 of TNG is a great big misfire. While I’ve gone on record as being warmer toward season 1 than most people, I’m gonna have to agree with the crowd and say that yes, season 2 is awful.

Some of this is outside of the control of the production team. Television production has always been a fiendishly difficult business, and trying to make TNG during a strike, without being seen as crossing the picket line, is next to impossible. That they were able to put 22 episodes on screen in the first place is a miracle in and of itself.

But even with that caveat, we’re still dealing with a season in which the show fails more often than it succeeds. There are bright moments like “The Measure of a Man,” “Elementary, Dear Data,” and “The Icarus Factor,” but much of what’s in this season of TNG is insipid by-the-numbers Trek at best, and deeply offensive to anyone with eyes and a sense of taste at worst. 

Which, ultimately, makes “Shades of Grey” the perfect finale for S2 as it actually was: it’s 45 minutes of a glorified ‘greatest hits’ collection strung together with a weak framing device, and you spend much of the time looking at the clips they pulled and wishing you were watching those episodes instead.

“Peak Performance,” thank goodness, is much better than that. It’s also a Riker episode, but it’s one that deals with the somewhat brushed-over militaristic aspects of Starfleet by putting it in the context of a simulated battle between the crew of the Enterprise, led by Picard, and the crew of the Hathaway, led by Riker.

As Underhill notes: “Similarly, he and Captain Picard, and their respective crews, approach the actual training exercise is as essentially an overblown game of Chess or Go. The appeal of the game for them is to guess the thought process of their friends, which, if you look at it a certain way, is another way of showcasing the close, familial bond they share with each other that Kolrami and his Starfleet peers find so upsetting (think back to Dexter Remmick here too).”

“Peak Performance,” coming as it does at the end of a season which by and large felt like a fourth season of TOS in all the wrong ways, works because it is an episode that is tailored specifically to the crew of the Enterprise-D. And not just in scripting terms either – the feeling of familiarity the bridge crew have with one another is matched only by that same feeling in the actors. 

Stewart et. al loved coming to work every day because it meant they got to be with their friends, and that love has endured across the nearly four decades since “Farpoint” aired. I may have a considerable number of issues with the third season of Picard, but even I am woman enough to admit that Terry Matalas made the right call in saving the TNG reunion for last. All of them on that bridge again, working the problem in the way they always did, it almost felt like watching an imaginary 36th season on TNG.

So it is with “Peak Performance.” Watching Picard and Riker on opposite sides is fascinating, since you get a glimpse into how each of them approach command and their respective strengths as tacticians. Riker knows that Picard has the ability to absolutely crush the Hathaway, thanks to the Enterprise being the pinnacle of Starfleet design and engineering, and the Hathaway being an old relic, forcing him to rely on guile and wit. (And of course, Worf, for whom this episode is his finest hour to date as the 1701-D’s tactical officer.)

Watching this, you really do get a sense as to why Starfleet kept offering Riker all those promotions for so many years. He has all the makings of being an excellent captain. And next season, when Riker is forced into this exact position a second time in his face-off against Locutus of Borg, there’s a part of me that honestly wanted to see what would happen if he became captain of the Enterprise permanently. (Luckily, the Titan books fill that niche instead.)

There’s another angle of “Peak Performance” that appeals to me, and that’s the war game itself. It reminds me a little of when I used to play Werewolf: part of the fun of that game was the strategy, trying to figure out who might be evil, and building a case against them based on evidence. 

In one game, I was one of the murderers, and was forced into a confession early on day two… which ultimately worked to my advantage, because since I knew I had a day and a half to operate without pretending to be good, I instead came up with a plan (aided with a magic potion and a hostage scenario) to take three baddies down with me when I got executed on the third day. 

As Riker said to Worf, “You’re outmanned, you’re outgunned, you’re out-equipped. What else have you got? Guile.” That’s the key to successful Werewolf, no matter which side you’re on.

“Peak Performance,” for me, will always be one of my favorite TNGs. It’s a standout performance for everyone involved, as “Arsenal of Freedom” was on season 1. It’s a reminder of exactly why this show lasted seven seasons, and I think, has long since surpassed TOS as the gold standard of what Star Trek should be like.

And speaking of gold standards, onward we go to season 3! And while we’re at it, a very blessed Beltane to all of you at home!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑