If The Legend of Ruby Sunday/The Empire of Death loosely maps onto The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang, then Wish World is roughly the Davies equivalent of Dark Water, down to the reveal that a recurring character is actually a villainous Time Lady from the Doctor’s past, and that there is a larger threat waiting to be released. (In this case, the larger threat is actually Omega.)
Davies has used his returning villains in very interesting ways in each of his three finales – his Toymaker felt like a spiritual return to John Simm’s Master, only with way more camp and intentionally dodgy accents. (Only Neil Patrick Harris can make his own American accent sound like a bad impression by a British actor.)
Similarly, the Rani is just there to be, basically, RTD’s version of Missy – the first Wicked Witch of Gallifrey, at least in the modern series. The Rani storms in to reclaim the title within the first five minutes of the episode, abducting a child and turning Jonas’s actual parents (and siblings) into plants and animals. Witchcraft indeed.
But then we jump forward in time to 2025… and that’s where things get weird.
***
“Imagine” is very much the defining song of John Lennon’s post-Beatles work. The cynical world we live in now, where it’s guaranteed to be played multiple times every October 9th and December 8th, paired with tone-deaf performances by people like Gal Gadot and other celebrities from their big, impressive mansions, make the lyrics sound trite and hypocritical.
And to be fair, the hypocrisy was noted even in 1971 – Elton John once joked to John and Yoko, ‘Imagine six apartments, it isn’t hard to do, one is full of fur coats, another’s full of shoes.’” But the accumulated cynicism of the last 54 years obscures the song’s larger point: Imagine a world where all possible points of division, all barriers, simply do not exist. That we are all, as Yoko put it later, “that we are all one country, one world, one people.” (John and Yoko’s later creation of Nutopia, a conceptual country whose national anthem is six seconds of silence, evokes the same idea.)
The song, at the end of the day, is a plea for a better world. It’s the kind of song that John had been trying to write, on and off, since at least “The Word” on Rubber Soul. But with “Imagine,” bringing it into a world that had seen the utopian flower power dream of the mid-1960s go so spectacularly wrong, John correctly realized it was gonna take more than “All You Need is Love” to fix the problems that plagued society at that time.
Wanting to change the world by any means necessary was in vogue during the early 1970s, after all: the second wave of feminism was starting up around then, leading John to try and make amends for his abusive past (as I’ve mentioned in the Four Sides of the Circle post on Some Time in New York City). 1971 was also the year Z Budapest and Morgan McFarland launched their respective forms of Dianic Wicca, with Budapest’s version being the more exclusionary of the two.
And in this episode, we meet someone who really can change the world… but not in the way John Lennon wanted.
***
When we see him again after being freed from prison in Lucky Day, Conrad Clark has moved up in the world, reading the story of Doctor Who to a captive audience. He is “the boy who wants the world to be better,” able to tap into the power of the gods and remake the world in his own image. It’s the kind of power that John Lennon couldn’t have ever dreamed of… not that he would’ve wanted to.
Because honestly, the world Conrad Clark creates isn’t anything like Lennon’s utopia. This world is more accurately represented by a radically different version of “Imagine,” a cover performed by A Perfect Circle in 2004. The APC version was recorded during that year’s US presidential election, and reinterprets the song in a significant way.
Their take is played in a minor key, with low piano chords sounding like funeral bells. When paired with the slow, haunting vocal part by Maynard James Keenan, Lennon’s wish for a utopia is replaced with a dark, dystopian admission that we’re further away from that dream than we want to be. It’s a perfect fit both for the post-9/11 era, when George W. Bush was president and overseeing the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and for 2025: whether the Trumpian hellscape we live in now, or the alternate timeline of Conrad’s creation.
Conrad, as I touched on in the Lucky Day post, feels of a piece with the modern YouTube fascists like Ben Shapiro and his ilk: the kinds of people who post on Rumble and Truth Social, or listen to Joe Rogan before going home to rape their girlfriends. He’s even reading from a book that, while its title evokes the Terrance Dicks Target novels of the 1970s, looks for all the world like the original Bloomsbury version of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone – the perfect novel for a fascist to read, given the political sensibilities of the author.
So it’s funny, then, that Conrad’s idea of a “better world” looks exactly like the stereotypical version of the 1950s seen in American sitcoms like Leave It To Beaver, and parodied in movies like 1998’s Pleasantville. (With some distinctly British touches, of course, but hey, we’ve seen the American ‘50s already. Time for the home team to get some love.)
This is an era where the well-dressed father goes to work, while the mother stays at home with the baby. There’s even a white picket fence and immaculately groomed suburban lawns! And everyone uses typewriters, not modern computers! And while there is TV, those TVs are very small and look like something you’d see in archive footage of people watching the Beatles on Ed Sullivan.
But of course, the real 1950s was never as clean-cut as media from the time led us to believe it was. There was more bubbling under the surface, just like a witch’s cauldron coming to boil. In America you had Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, and other huge figures from the civil rights movement pushing for Black equality.
Culturally, you had musicians like Chuck Berry, the Big Bopper, Buddy Holly, and of course, Elvis Presley horrifying the WWII vet fathers and scandalizing the stay-at-home moms, while Britain saw a proliferation of skiffle groups, while in the sleepy English town of Bricket Wood, a retired civil servant named Gerald Gardner was inventing modern witchcraft, foretelling big shifts in pop culture both domestically and in the US… not unlike what was happening in Liverpool at around the same time, now that I think of it.
Anyway. That Conrad’s imagined perfect world should look like a hyper stylized version of the 1950s, as the exact black-and-white peaceful utopia that it only was on television, is very telling. It’s that version of the 1950s that Donald Trump and the rest of the modern American right wants us to return to, back when “uppity Blacks knew their place” and women stayed in the home, looking after the kids and cooking.
It was a time, as the movie Pleasantville discusses in considerable depth, of repression. It’s the kind of world that evangelical Christians want America to turn into, as talked about in Talia Lavin’s Wild Faith – God is in every home, and everyone has an assigned role to play: the fathers are the authority figures, the moms stay at home and take care of the kids, and those kids are taught to grow into those roles as they age. “Good little girl, then good little wife, then good little mother” indeed.
I can’t begin to guess exactly how part 2 of this story will unfold, especially as the pseudo-50s realm of Conrad’s dream is ultimately wrecked by the Rani in the episode’s closing minutes, but that’s fine. The social commentary going on here is more than enough – RTD’s Doctor Who has always been political, going all the way back to 2005’s Aliens of London/World War Three, but this takes it up to a whole new level.
To the extent that this story is about anything, it’s this: nostalgia, whether for an imaginary version of a real decade or for Doctor Who villains from the show’s past as a scrappy studio-bound sci-fi where green bubble wrap is the height of your special effects budget, is death.
And honestly? That’s a pretty timely message. I mean, just look at what Star Trek, Doctor Who’s American cousin, has been doing lately: the flagship series of that franchise is, broadly speaking, a throwback to the original pilot, with younger versions of TOS era characters popping up left and right.
Meanwhile, some corners of fandom have spent the last two years demanding a “STAR TREK LEGACY” show to follow on the heels of Picard’s third season, which itself was rife with nostalgia and spent much of its ten episodes throwing aside all the new toys invented by the first two seasons so they could do, instead, the third consecutive “series finale” for Star Trek: The Next Generation.
(Small wonder the final episode is called “The Last Generation,” because at this rate we are never getting past Jean-Luc Picard.)
RTD, thank the gods, understands what comes of nostalgia’s temptations. His entire second era has been about moving the show forward, presenting the show’s established past as a thing to, by and large, move on from. The Toymaker, Sutekh, and the Rani all represent stagnation, and ultimately, the end of all things.
Where all this will end up is anybody’s guess… but whatever happens, we can at least say it won’t be boring.
Leave a Reply