Claim Yourself: “Sweet Sixteen”/“Lollipop Girl”/“Family Reunion”/“The Claiming”/“Silver Lining”

Welcome, Casters, to the endgame. 

This week, we cover the final five chapters of Beautiful Creatures, as Lena’s birthday finally arrives. Today, her life will be changed forever, in the ultimate battle between good and evil. Loyalties will be tested, lives are at stake, and someone close to Lena will make the ultimate sacrifice… 

So what are waiting for? Let the battle begin.


First thing to note? It’s a bad day to be Lena Duchannes. At the start of the chapter she’s reciting T.S. Eliot, and when Ethan goes to Ravenwood to check on her, the house is wrapped in feelings of hate, resentment, rage, and general unpleasantness… and of course, Aunt Del, Reese, and Ryan are freaked out. Ethan tries to go up the stairs, but Lena throws him off, and only relents after he threatens to report her to the school authorities.

But it works, so Ethan enters Lena’s room to find her looking distraught and listening to a heavy metal version of “Sixteen Moons,” the song whose verses have been appearing throughout the book since her arrival in Gatlin. (Incidentally, this version from the German book trailer is a decent approximation of what the rock mix probably sounds like… but being me, I imagine it being a little closer to “Helter Skelter.”)

But it’s not all bad. Ethan comforts her the only way he knows how – by giving the scared, frightened birthday girl a necklace from Lila’s jewelry box. (It’s true, we really do like jewelry – I have three necklaces that I switch between on a daily basis.) And just look at the description! “It was a carved gold circle, three strands of gold—sort of rose colored, and yellow, and white—all braided into a wreath.”

His Lena loves it, and I know I’d love it too, if Sophie gave me something similar. And they kiss… and in the process, undo the destruction Lena did to her room. See? Magic does have its perks! (I wish I could do stuff like that… keeping our room and kitchen clean would be so much easier.)

Anyway, Lena and Ethan spend the rest of the day together, at least until dusk. They go downstairs at last to be with the family, and find that they’re all dressed up for a ritual. (And I don’t mean skyclad! They’re not Gardnerians, they have a sense of propriety!) And then Ethan drops the funniest line of the whole book: “What are they going to do to you? This isn’t going to be some freaky pagan sex thing, is it?”

That settles it! Lena and her family are pagan! I mean, it’s not like Lena ever denies it, now does she? It’s just that in the Caster world, lunar correspondences work differently than they do for real-life Wiccans. It’s like how the Halliwell sisters still count as Wiccan in my book even though their cosmology is different – as long as we go in with the understanding that fictional traditions don’t necessarily map onto the real thing, the “inaccuracies” are livable.

Then we get another excellent joke: Lena’s grandma makes her debut appearance, and says she arrived ‘in the blink of an eye.’ Ethan, understandably, takes that literally… and then Lena says, “A Frequent Flyer, Ethan. On United.”

(I guess Casters can’t ride broomsticks then. Neither can I, which is a damned shame. Gods know I’d save a bunch of money not having to take an Uber to work.)

Anyway, the ritual gets started, and I have to say: between all the black robes, the candles, the dark room, and the chanting, the ritual scene hits real differently now than it did a decade ago. There’s even a circle for the working! It feels for all the world like my kind of witchcraft, the kind of thing I might’ve done for my Claiming if I’d had a coven to initiate me with.

And then, someone knocks on the door… and the elaborate Wiccan-adjacent ritual transforms into an ordinary birthday celebration, complete with cake, presents, and the “Happy Birthday” song, during which we learn that Lena likes red velvet cake. (Well, so do I, so… welcome to the club, sister!)

And who’s at the door, you ask? Only Link, Ridley, and the Jackson High entourage. Thanks to Ridley’s siren magic, not a single one of the Mortals voices a complaint about setting foot in the Haunted Mansion. There’s lights, speakers, a stage, and even a laser machine – a sixteenth birthday party to die for… and Macon refuses to let Lena attend, even though she visibly wants to.

Why? He says so himself: “The Mortals will only put you in harm’s way, or bring you pain. You can’t be normal. You weren’t meant to be normal.” Which sounds like bullshit reasoning if I’ve ever heard it. I understand that Macon has Issues with Mortals, (he’s been complaining about them all book) and I get that he just wants his niece to be safe, but this is ridiculous. Guy needs to go to therapy instead of making his problems into Lena’s problems too.

But anyway. After talking about how Ethan is a burden and is making Lena weak, our girl loses her patience and stomps off to her room, after giving her uncle the Reason You Suck Speech of a lifetime: “And what would you know about that? You’ve never been burdened with a relationship in your life, not even a friend. You don’t understand anything. How could you? You sleep in your room all day and mope around in your library all night. You hate everyone, and you think you’re better than everyone. If you’ve never really loved anyone, how could you possibly know how it feels to be me?”

And then she goes and does what any angry teenage girl would do, Caster or otherwise. Unreasonable parental figure doesn’t want the teenage witch to go to her own birthday party? She sneaks out, just like in all the movies. 

Link goes off to play “Sixteen Moons” while acting like a southern-fried Mick Jagger, and… it doesn’t suck. Actually, it’s so good that Ethan and Lena start dancing, and only stop when Lena notices her cousin Larkin (who’s been Suspiciously Helpful all chapter) making out with Emily Asher.

But at the end, when all the fuss has died down? Lena says the the four most important words of all time: “I love you, Ethan.”

Hold on to that moment, you two. Party time’s over, and the Claiming Moon is rising.


It doesn’t take too long for everything to start going all to Hell. Ethan and Link run to Gatlin’s only museum, where Mitchell Wate is standing on the roof, acting like he’s about to jump… and Ridley Duchannes is right next to him, being the villainous Dark Caster she truly is. In full view of Ethan, she continues to work her manipulations on him… but because she isn’t quite as evil as she wants us to think, Link manages to talk her out of killing Mitchell.

So, with his dad safe and sound, Ethan takes off back toward Ravenwood to check up on Lena… and arrives just in time to witness the endgame.

‘Cause guess whose Mom finally showed up?


After all this time, we finally find out what’s been going on with Mrs. Lincoln – it wasn’t really her all along, but Sarafine, impersonating her. And to her credit, she just about pulls it off… until this moment, when she calls Link by his nickname, rather than Wesley Jefferson Lincoln. Then the mask comes off once and for all.

It’s Sarafine, come home at last.

If you want to know what she really looks like, imagine an older version of Lena, but with golden cat eyes instead of bright green ones. I once got to play an evil version of Lena in a game of Werewolf, and I wrote her pretty much exactly like Sarafine, complete with the fire magic and the visceral hatred for Mortals. I even got to do a dueling scene where she faces off with someone like Gandalf from Lord of the Rings, and it was awesome.

But I digress. Lena, understandably, is the angriest she’s been all book – she’s furious with her mother, pissed as hell at Larkin (who turns out to be a Dark Caster after all) and all but losing control, making it rain so hard that Ethan compares it to a monsoon. And then, in the middle of an argument about Lena’s ultimate fate, Sarafine says two familiar words:

“[Macon]’s the one who has been lying to you all this time. He let you believe your fate was predetermined-that you didn’t have a choice. That tonight, on your sixteenth birthday, you will be Claimed Light or Dark.”

Lena shook her head stubbornly. She raised her palms.

Thunder rumbled, and the rain began to pour, in thick sheets and torrents. She shouted to be heard. “That’s what happens. It happened to Ridley and Reece and Larkin.”

“You’re right, but you’re different. Tonight, you will not be Claimed. You will have to Claim yourself.”

And there we have it, folks. The thing we’ve been building to all book: Lena’s Claiming is her own choice to make, just like mine was. The manipulations continue, as Sarafine tries to tempt Lena over toward darkness… and then Macon arrives, and it just gets worse from there. He tells her that she does indeed have a choice… and implies that he has, in fact, been lying to her about it all book.

Lena is justifiably angry with him over this, and from the way Ethan describes her, it looks as if she’s considering trusting Sarafine after all, since she can no longer trust Macon like she used to. And Sarafine, bound to explain what’s at stake, does so: if Lena goes Dark, all the Light Casters in the family will die. Thus, if she goes Light, then all the Dark Casters in the family will die. Equivalent exchange, in other words.

And then she twists the knife even further. She tells Lena that the Dark Casters have a way of ensuring that she and Ethan can be together… because otherwise, Casters and Mortals can’t “be together” without killing the Mortal. (Read: Have sex.)

The argument between Macon and Sarafine continues, with Lena caught in the middle, steadily losing what’s left of her control. And then it all goes horribly wrong: Sarafine loses patience, and Macon is attacked by his brother Hunting. In the end, it becomes a battle between mother and daughter, as Lena’s resolve to stay Light strengthens… 

But it sure looks like she might go Dark anyway, what with the fire and the spooky laughter that freaks Ethan out. (Also there’s the snark-to-snark combat, complete with Lena calling Sarafine a bitch and making a joke about witch burnings.) And then Lena throws some fire at her boyfriend…

But only to disrupt Sarafine’s shield spell, freeing Link and Ethan up to high-tail it to the Beater and make for the Lunae Libri as fast as they can. Why? So they can meet up with Marian, and get her to deliver a book to Ravenwood, bypassing whatever locks might have been cast on the place.

It works, and before long Ethan is headed off back to the battlefield again, this time with Aunt Del and Lena’s grandma along for the ride. They’re able to heal Macon and Boo, but just as Ethan hurries to find and rescue Lena… history repeats itself. Ethan gets stabbed by Sarafine, and he dies, dreaming of the Caster girl he loved… just like his namesake.

And then? Well, you know how I’ve been wanting to read this book from Lena’s perspective? Consider the wish granted. With our primary narrator out for the count, Lena steps up to take his place, and the next sceneis told from her point of view. Even apart from the fact that her portion of the chapter is in italics, you can tell it’s her speaking – she looks at the world differently from Ethan. And I love that aspect.

But also, this part makes me cry, particularly the line “Ethan, I love you. Don’t leave me. I can’t do this without you.” Because that’s exactly how I feel about Sophie. Like my namesake, I can’t imagine life without her… and to lose her somehow? It’d tear me up, just like losing Ethan tears Lena up.

I feel you, sis. But you’re not alone. 

Amma shows up, and my namesake realizes there’s no Sixteenth moon for her to be Claimed under… a reprieve, of sorts. So, Lena does the only thing she can do, the same thing I’d do if I were her and I lost Sophie, the same thing Genevieve Duchannes did for her Ethan. She casts the resurrection spell from the Book of Moons, filling Genevieve’s role, with Amma taking Ivy’s place.

But this time, there are protections. Lila’s ring, the locket, and Amma’s charm. Lena and Amma cast the spell together… but it doesn’t seem to work, at first. We get more of Lena’s descriptions of her magic, and the anger she feels toward her mother, Hunting, and Larkin for causing all this. She strikes them with lightning, and time unfreezes…

And it did work. But as any witch, Wiccan, or Caster will tell you, all magic has a price. Lena got Ethan back, but she lost Macon anyway, and didn’t even get to Claim herself…

But she will. That, I can promise you.

See you next time, Casters.

– Lena M.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑