Five years ago, I attempted to write an MLP blog series, in the style of my Doctor Who projects. I got as far as the first four episodes of season 2 before I gave up, partly due to inexperience in media criticism and also because a former friend told me, point blank, that she wasn’t interested in reading about ponies.
But now, with FIM turning 15 today and the franchise in something of a holding pattern, I feel like now is as good a time as any to dust this project off and give it another shot. I’m more confident in myself now than I ever was in 2020, and I have better friends, so… here’s hoping the second time is the charm.
And yes, we’re doing Equestria Girls too.
It’s funny how things can change over fifteen years. On October 10th, 2010, I was just a week shy of turning 16, and coming to the end of what turned out to be the wrong sort of puberty. I was entirely unaware of the equine-themed cartoon show about friendship and magic when it aired, I was more interested in things like Doctor Who and Top Gear and various other things that “boys” (like the one I thought I was) were supposed to like.
I came to MLP through a somewhat unorthodox method: a user on a now-closed furry forum I was a member of knew I liked Doctor Who, and so they sent me a comic set during Episode 2 of The Mind Robber. In the comic, the Doctor, Jamie, and Zoe are wandering the Land of Fiction when they encounter a white unicorn with a purple mane and tail, blue eyes, and various opinions about their clothes.
I didn’t know who the unicorn was, but I knew who the Doctor, Jamie, and Zoe were. Even so, I was nonetheless fascinated by her, so I did a bit of searching, found out what the first episode of FIM was called, and downloaded it from YouTube from a fan channel. (This being the bygone age when the show’s official Youtube channel didn’t even exist,much less upload full episodes.)
I had to watch it twice, for the simple reason that here I was, an alleged cisgender boy, watching a show for little girls about eight years younger than me. As it turns out, growing up in a world where there are Happy Meal toys for boys and girls and having to try very hard not to stare longingly at all the outfits in the girls’ clothing section at Target tends to give someone a lot of gender-related hang-ups that they have to work through. (Eight years later I had similar hang-ups watching She-Ra and the Princesses of Power, but I shut those down by reminding myself that despite my external appearance, I am still a woman. It worked.)
When I was eventually able to tune out the voice in my head that continually insisted I wasn’t supposed to be watching this, I realized something: the show was not, at first blush, the kind of sugary, aggressively pink, hyper-feminine thing I had assumed it would be, like any of the thousand and one Barbie cartoons had been.
Rather, it was more of an adventure show that just happened to star cute pastel ponies, and the goal of the two-part pilot (find the Elements of Harmony and use them to defeat a great evil) sounded like the Key to Time season in classic Doctor Who, with Twilight Sparkle and her friends in the role of the Doctor, Romana, and K9, while Princess Celestia and Nightmare Moon were the White and Black Guardians, respectively. I assumed the season’s arc would then be about that quest, with the final battle against Nightmare Moon occurring in the season finale.
Of course, that wasn’t exactly what happened. The Elements are found and Nightmare Moon is defeated in the second episode of the series, with the remaining 24 being largely slice-of-life stories intended to deliver a moral for kids to internalize. Sure, some episodes are a bit more adventurous than others (Dragonshy, Look Before You Sleep, Swarm of the Century, and A Dog and Pony Show spring to mind) but for the most part, these were easily digestible 22-minute chunks of TV that were otherwise, for all intents and purposes, an entire universe away from Doctor Who.
I could’ve stopped watching at any time. I hadn’t watched a cartoon of any flavor in years, not since the days of Hey Arnold! and the pre-movie seasons of Spongebob Squarepants. (Or, in secret, The Powerpuff Girls.) Yet I kept watching, either because the writing was very good even when all that was going on was Twilight trying to decide which of her friends should go to the Gala with her, or the personalities of the girls themselves. (Though honestly, it was probably both.) Nonetheless, by the time the first season ended, I was hooked. The ponies had taken me, and they weren’t letting go.
Of the six lead characters, there was one in particular that grabbed my interest pretty much from the word go, and it wasn’t Rarity. I liked Rarity, and in years to come I grew to consider her my second favorite of the leads, but as a new member of the herd, she was a bit too overly feminine for my taste. Rainbow Dash was too brash, Pinkie Pie was too random, Fluttershy was too quiet, and Applejack was too Southern. (Sorry, Sophie! I was young and stupid!) They were all good characters, but hard for me to relate to… all except Twilight Sparkle.
If I had to explain why, I would say it was because I saw a lot of myself in her. We were both introverts, preferring to spend our time in libraries with a book or two (or twelve) than outside. We were intelligent and excelled in academics. We had friends, or at the very least close acquaintances, but we only really saw them at school, and almost never outside in the real world. She was intensely relatable to me back then, and remains so even if, as Princess of Equestria, she has ascended far beyond what I could ever hope to achieve, or would want to. (I am never ever running for president.)
True, there are plenty of differences between us. I was able to make friends a lot more easily in school than she evidently could prior to the pilot, she’s more logic-driven whereas I am more creative and emotional, and she’s easily better at all things math and science related than I ever was in school. (I wasn’t awful, I always passed my classes, but I don’t think it’s an accident that my highest grades were always in English.)
Differences notwithstanding, I still fell hard for Twilight Sparkle. Even fifteen years later, she is still my favorite character on the show, and she always will be.
Another crucial component of my entry into the pony-watching herd was its fandom. Two months after I started watching the show, I joined a pony role-playing site called Fillydelphia, where I made friends of my own. My character was a unicorn, and while at first he was a barely-altered pony version of the Eleventh Doctor, a forced reboot of him a few months into my time there allowed me to start exploring my own internal sense of self, whether I knew it at the time or not.
Outside of the Fillydelphia community, I listened to pony fandom music: that is, music created by and for fans of the show, running the gamut from remixes of the show’s songs to original compositions inspired by characters. The very first fandom music I ever heard was Princess Luna as Imagined, an EP released by the artist notacleverpony. (Though she later came out as trans, her pony music career was brief, consisting solely of that EP and a Celestia-themed follow-up album, after which she disappeared.)
Short though it is, it is nonetheless a fascinating glimpse into what the early pony fandom was like: obsessed with Luna despite her brief 90 seconds of screen time in the entire first season and convinced that she would bring about a republic to her sister’s imperial monarchy. Listening to it now, nearly fifteen years after I first heard it, I feel a rush of nostalgia that I can’t quite put into words. (Certainly, I wish NACP was still around.)
But perhaps the part of fandom that’s stayed with me the longest (aside from the insane collection of pony-themed desktop wallpapers, and the music) was the fan fiction. Even to this day, I am still reading fan fiction, and even writing it. Most of it was written while the show was still on the air, but it’s new to me. To go on about why I like it so much might require a second essay though, so suffice to say that I love anything that can expand the world of the series well beyond what it could ever depict, and take its characters in new and fascinating directions.
I’m not at all exaggerating when I say that liking FIM so much made me trans. Indeed, it became something of a cliche for a fan of the show in the early 2010s to get to the end of them (if not sooner) having come out as trans. (Or a Nazi, but that’s another blog post.) Hell, I met my first girlfriend through the pony fandom: her online name was Chell, after the character in the Portal video game series. She herself was trans, as was her sister, and all three of our respective characters interacted with each other at one time or another.
There’s just something about this show that awakens the inner girl in people. Not all the people (there are plenty of cis men and women in this fandom, of course) but a large percentage of it. My OC was magically transformed into a mare several times before I ever came out to myself, and cross-dressed off and on several more times, before finally transitioning permanently in early 2015, just after my own coming-out.
So, given the previous 1600 words, the reader is probably asking: “So what the hell is this actually about?” And the truth is, it’s about many things. It’s a self-portrait first and foremost, of me and who I was back when the show began, and who I had become by the time it ended. If future entries go the way I want them to, it’ll also be about the show itself, and how it grew and changed and reacted to the world around it.
But mostly, it’s about Equestria: a magical world where ponies can talk, fly, do magic, and come in every color of the rainbow, a world governed by the principles of generosity, honesty, laughter, kindness, loyalty, and friendship, six things that those of us living on Earth in the mid-2020s would do well to re-learn.
If a fan of something can be said to live in the world where that something takes place, then allow me to say I’ve lived in Equestria for a long time, and it has changed me. I hope, as the rewatch I’m undertaking continues, to explain why. And who knows? Maybe the magic of friendship will change you, too. It never hurts to try.
So, what are we waiting for? Let’s open the book, and start again.
The first shot of the series, before we meet any of the characters, is of a storybook resting on a grassy field. Appropriately (and I am very proud to say that I absolutely called this) it is also the last shot of the series, with only a couple small differences between them. And as the scenes before the title sequence make clear, this is not just the story of Equestria’s creation myth, but the story of Twilight Sparkle, too. So it makes a lot of sense that she’s the first pony we meet. (We’ll come back to her.)
What to make of the story she reads? Yes, a typical battle between good and evil, but one not too far away from, say, the expulsion of Satan from Heaven to Hell as described in Milton’s Paradise Lost, with Celestia as God and Nightmare Moon as Satan. However, unlike God, who can pretty much do whatever he wants, Celestia does not have all the power in the world at her command. She needs a boost, and that’s where the Elements of Harmony come in.
As we’re told later, there are six Elements of Harmony: Honesty, Laughter, Kindness, Generosity, Loyalty, and Magic. We know from future episodes that Celestia and Luna once used the Elements to defeat Q, I mean Discord, and Sombra, but following their use here, their hold over the Elements breaks.
Why is this? Because we also know from the Season 2 premiere that the Elements don’t work if their bearers are corrupted. (See: The Mane Six’s first attempt at reforming Discord fails because everypony but Twilight has been made monochrome.) And Nightmare Moon, being Princess Luna hopped up on capital-d Dark Magic, is pretty much the dictionary definition of corruption.
But, this being an emergency, Celestia is able to wield the Elements against her sister, banishing her to the moon as mentioned in the story. But her use of them against another bearer causes them to go dormant for a thousand years, which brings us at last to Twilight Sparkle.
Looking at these two episodes with a decade and a half of hindsight, it’s a little trippy to see the future Princess of Friendship/Ruler of Equestria so thoroughly blow off the three mares she calls her friends. (Though it also forms the basis for one of my favorite Twilight episodes, so we’ll let it slide.) I mean, to be fair, Twilight isn’t completely lacking in social skills. She can carry on a conversation just fine, (she even apologizes!) she’s just a total workaholic.
That’s Twilight in the early seasons: a socially awkward dork who spends most of her time with her nose in a book, completely ignorant of the world around her until someone or something snaps her out of it. In other words, she’s just like how I was in tenth grade. I was so into books that I took any opportunity I had to read them, up to and including reading while walking the track in a fitness walking class. (My teacher made me stop.)
Twilight may be completely surprised that Celestia ignores her tip about Nightmare Moon coming back, but I’m not. First of all, Celestia outright says at the end of the second episode, “I saw the signs of Nightmare Moon’s return, and I knew it was you who had the magic inside to defeat her, but you could not unleash it until you let true friendship into your heart.” In addition, I can also see that Celestia is trying to prevent a repeat of the whole Nightmare Moon situation, since she’s had a thousand years to think things over.
So, the Elements then. Why are they so important to Equestria? Well, there’s the obvious: they’re great big magical super-weapons that don’t actually destroy things, but purify them. But they also represent the qualities that make up a good friend, hence why the show goes to such lengths to pair each pony with a particular Element:
Applejack knows Twilight will be safe if she lets go of her hooves because Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy (the Elements of Loyalty and Kindness respectively) will be right there to catch her when she falls, and sure enough, they are. The first pillar of friendship, therefore, is open and honest communication. Pinkie is able to make the girls laugh so the forest’s trees don’t seem as scary, establishing the breaking of tension via humor as another pillar. It acknowledges the truth of the current situation, but allows the others to see that things aren’t as bad as they might appear.
The next three are very closely related: Generosity, as Rarity demonstrates, is borne out of a desire to help those who can’t help themselves for one reason or another, which in turn comes from kindness: a true friend will always want to understand your experiences, especially if they themselves aren’t going through the same things, so they can comfort you when necessary.
Kindness and generosity, therefore, combine to lead to loyalty: the things two people have in common can be used to form stronger bonds, and you’ll always know the other person will be there when you need them. (Not for nothing have Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy been close even before the events of the series.) All three also all tie back to honesty, since it is only with open and truthful communication that we can really be kind, generous, and loyal to the people we love.
Of course, no one represents all of these things perfectly all the time. There are many, many occasions over the nine seasons that the ponies fail to be their best selves, but that’s okay, because we’re no different. Friendship is a complex and multi-faceted thing, always a work-in-progress. But if you learn the right lessons and work on improving yourself, you can become the best friend that you can be. You may not be able to defeat the forces of darkness with a rainbow, but we can’t all be magic pastel ponies.
So what of Nightmare Moon? What does she represent? Well, she’s not what happens when honesty, kindness, loyalty, generosity, and friendship are turned against one another and inverted. That would be next season. Rather, she is the personification of what can happen when those things are absent altogether.
Remember: Princess Luna didn’t turn into Nightmare Moon because she was destined to be evil. She did it because she was lonely, and believed no one in Equestria cared about her, or appreciated what she had to offer. She is an introvert in a nation of extroverts, and I can completely understand why she lashed out the way she did. That doesn’t make what she did right, but I know what she’s been through.
Like me, Luna is a creative type. I have my blog posts and my fanfics, and she has her night sky and the constellations therein. We work to the bone to create and bring our ideas to life, only to be met with indifference at best, or rejection at worst. If this happens often, it can consume us, and turn us into a twisted version of ourselves.
But what keeps me from going bad (and as Luna will discover for herself next season, when she reappears in Luna Eclipsed) is the community that I have around me, from the folks in the Fezaholics Discord server to my friends in the witchcraft community. They have, in their own ways, been kind, generous, loyal, and honest with me, and made me a better friend as a result.
If that’s not real magic, then I don’t know what is.
Leave a Reply