Equestria Forever: Over A Barrel/A Bird in the Hoof

Of the two episodes we’re looking at today, A Bird in the Hoof is very much the best one. Over A Barrel starts off well enough, what with Applejack reading a tree a bedtime story and the whispered conversation between Pinkie, Dash, Twilight, and Fluttershy after the titles about whether or not Fluttershy is a tree, (her wish to be one sparked a very long-lived fandom meme) but it all starts to go off the rails around the time the buffalo show up.

What we get is a 22 minute kid-friendly exploration into the Old West, more specifically into American westward expansion and conflicts with the Great Plains indigenous tribes that came about as a result of that. I’m all for teaching children about history (Doctor Who was originally intended to be an educational program about science and history, after all) but something as bloody and difficult as 19th century American history is really not something a show about cute pastel ponies should be talking about. It’s about as appropriate as, say, that Peanuts special where Charlie Brown and the gang are all passengers on the Mayflower: not very.

Here’s the thing about living in the United States: every single non-Indigenous person who lives in this country is living on stolen land, going all the way back to the founding of Jamestown in 1607. The area where I was born, St. Louis, was once home to the Osage, Miami, Sioux and Haudenosauneega tribes according to Native Land, an online mapping project run by Indigenous people to show who really owns the land we live on. The first French explorers came to the area in 1673, and over 130 years later, Meriwether Lewis and William Clark made their famous expedition from St. Louis to what is now Oregon, on the banks of the Pacific Ocean. (You hear a lot about these two if you grow up here.)

Admittedly, the Lewis and Clark expedition didn’t face anywhere near as much violence as that faced by other settlers during the other years of westward expansion, but then again, one of the Jefferson administration’s goals for the expedition was to impress upon the tribal peoples that their land, which they’d occupied (in the case of the St. Louis tribes) for something like a thousand years, was now under new management. So they don’t get any points from me for managing to avoid shooting anyone. (Or, in the case of this episode, hit anyone with an apple pie.)

Anyway, introducing the concepts of settler ponies and native ungulate tribal species presents some discomforting truths about Equestria: it is just as much a colonialist society as America is, albeit government-wise, they are perhaps closer to Great Britain than the US, since they have a monarchial system of government with Princess Celestia and Princess Luna (and later Twilight) at the top.

The cynical view would hold that the principles the show espouses (the paramount importance of friendship and the six traits that make up being a good person) are just the Equestrian version of American manifest destiny, or the German concept of lebensraum: an excuse people come up with to take what doesn’t belong to them. Not very magical, now is it? (Relatedly, Twilight has a few lines of dialogue early in the season 8 premiere that carry unfortunate undertones, but the rest of the episode is about a school and a racist cabinet secretary voiced by Maurice LaMarche whom she and the girls fight against, so I’m willing to give her a pass.)

Just about everything in this episode is an irredeemable mess. Pinkie’s song about the importance of sharing, caring, and focusing on what ponies and buffalo have in common (vegetarian diets and being ungulates mainly) is noble, but not exactly an appropriate response, and it doesn’t help that the other performers on stage with her are, surprise, OTHER PONIES. You can’t really do a song about the importance of sharing with people who don’t look like you, Pinks, if you’re surrounded by performers of your own kind. Even the watching crowd seems to get that it’s a bullshit argument, given that their next move is to have a food fight.

Then there’s the matter of the ending: Chief Thunderhooves, after tasting a crumb of an apple pie thrown at him by one of the colonists, (and played as a death scene, as if this couldn’t get any more tasteless) wakes up and magically comes to an “agreement” with the settlers: the settlers get to keep their orchard and their town, while the buffalo get to run the path established by previous generations… which really isn’t much of a compromise, since as Jen A. Blue points out, the settler ponies get the better end of the deal. (She cites the 1851 Treaty of Fort Laramie as a historical equivalent.)

The good news is that this is pretty much the last time the show attempts to do what would be, in Doctor Who terms, a historical episode, though not the last time they do a settlement colonialism story. The next one is Hearth’s Warming Eve, although in that case, the land that will become Equestria was presumably uninhabited, but on the other hand, a stage play put on by a speaking people we now know to be imperialists is not exactly an accurate historical record, so take it with a grain of salt. Dave Polsky doesn’t write another episode until Too Many Pinkie Pies in season 3, and based on his performance so far, I can’t say I’m too sad to see him go.

Let us move on, mercifully, to A Bird in the Hoof, in which Fluttershy commits larceny against Princess Celestia because she noticed that Celestia’s pet bird was sick, and wanted to take care of her. (No, I’m not kidding, that really is the plot.) If you read the second Harry Potter book, then you’ll probably remember that Fawkes, Dumbledore’s pet phoenix, was introduced in the same fashion, only for him to suddenly catch fire and explode, then be re-born.

This is that scene, only 22 minutes long and with ponies instead of wizards, and not written by a TERF. (Instead, it’s Charlotte Fullerton.) Fluttershy, bless her, does try everything she can think of to help Philomena, though Twilight is correct when she points out that she really ought to have asked first. Series creator Lauren Faust said on Twitter in 2013 that the episode “was originally conceived as a tug-at-your-heartstrings style episode about losing a pet,” though that premise won’t be used until season 5.

As it is, it’s a perfectly serviceable episode, complete with Twilight freaking out and making a scene over Fluttershy being potentially banished. Although, given her older brother is the head of Celestia’s royal guard, this might partially explain why she flips out so badly, along with her existing anxiety issues, which we’ll see a lot more of in season two.

I wish this part of the post was longer, but the truth is there’s really not that much to talk about! I did enjoy the chase scene, what with the same music from Ticket Master, the Scooby Doo doors, and Philomena hiding from Twilight and Fluttershy with a newspaper and mustache, ala Paul McCartney in the opening of A Hard Day’s Night. Certainly, it’s a nice palate cleanser after the debacle that was Over A Barrel. But that’s about all I got.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑