Wolf Trek: Who Watches the Watchers

Captain’s log, stardate 80944.4: A hidden outpost on Mintaka III is revealed after an essential holographic generator malfunctions, polluting the primitives’ religious and ethical beliefs and causing one of them to identify Picard with God.


Welcome back to another exciting edition of Wolf Trek – this week, My Favorite Science Fiction Show of All Time decides to do an entire episode about how silly it is to believe in gods. There is no possible way that this can go wrong, right? Right?! (Insert that one Natalie Portman Star Wars meme here.)

Sigh. Let’s get this over with.

In the episode, Picard finds himself pitted against a proto-Vulcan race who are described as once having had religious beliefs – going by the episode dialogue, it’s likely they practiced some form of alien paganism. 

After Liko is healed and beamed back planet-side, he says to his daughter: “Long ago, our people believed in beings with great powers. These beings made the rains come, told the sun when to rise, they caused all life to be born, to grow, to die. […] But perhaps the beliefs of our ancestors are true. Nothing else can explain what’s happened.”

It then turns out that the main reason Liko is so obsessed with this idea that Picard is a god mainly has to do with the fact that his wife died the previous year, and he is still deep in mourning for her. He believes Picard can bring back his wife from the dead, and it’s not until Picard is injured when Liko shoots him with an arrow that he realizes no, the crew of the Enterprise are indeed as mortal as they claim to be.

Now, if that was everything this episode was about, I would probably be a lot warmer toward it than I actually am. It could have been the TNG version of a similar episode from Discovery, 2019’s “New Eden.” In that episode, we are introduced to a small colony of humans who, after being mysteriously rescued from nuclear annihilation in the church they were hiding in, founded for themselves a syncretic faith based on, as Burnham calls it, “the primary faiths of Earth.” 

Burnham lists seven different religions, some of which are monotheist and others that are polytheist: Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Shinto and Wicca. As a very devout Wiccan myself, I am thrilled that my religion is listed in the same breath as the ancient heavy hitters. No doubt Gerald Gardner would be tickled pink by this!

Just to make it even better, Captain Pike, being the son of a comparative religions professor, treats these people with respect, even if he doesn’t believe a god himself. Which is more than can be said for Picard in “Who Watches the Watchers,” even allowing for the fact that he’s already having A Day what with the whole “being mistaken for divine” thing.

In one scene, set in the observation lounge, we get this:

BARRON: Like it or not, we have rekindled the Mintakans’ belief in the Overseer.

RIKER: And are you saying that this belief will eventually become a religion?

BARRON: It’s inevitable. And without guidance, that religion could degenerate into inquisitions, holy wars, chaos.

PICARD: Horrifying. Doctor Barron, your report describes how rational these people are. Millennia ago, they abandoned their belief in the supernatural. Now you are asking me to sabotage that achievement, to send them back into the Dark Ages of superstition and ignorance and fear? No!

Now, obviously Picard isn’t speaking specifically about humanity’s past as being as similarly grim with regard to the question of religious belief. But it’s very easy to read him as doing so in order to make his point about the Mintakans, given how often he portrays the humanity of the mid-24th century as having evolved past other shortcomings, as in “The Neutral Zone” or First Contact. 

But even so, I can’t really find fault in him here – his issues with regard to faith in this episode stem pretty much entirely from the fact that he, an imperfect human being, is being held up as divine by a less advanced civilization.

No. The character I’m angriest at here isn’t Picard at all, but Troi. Near the tail end of the episode, when Picard has beamed down to the planet to try and reason with Liko and the rest, she is trying very hard to not get killed. Then this happens:

TROI: Liko, you don’t want to kill me.

LIKO: I have no choice. I must do as the Picard wishes.

TROI: Are you sure you know what he wants? That’s the problem with believing in a supernatural being. Trying to determine what he wants.

This, dear reader, sent me flying into a rage just as surely as the Twelfth Doctor’s insistence that “Gods never actually show up” did, back when we talked about The Girl Who Died, but for different reasons. In the latter case, I was annoyed because the Doctor was making a blanket assertion about what gods do, or rather don’t do, despite the fact that my own experiences prove him wrong.

Troi’s assertion here is a little different, but no less infuriating: she is instead looking at our inability to directly speak with the divine as something that makes belief in them pointless, rather than something to be worked around as part of religious practice. Liko’s struggles with trying to figure out what “the Picard” wants him to do will look very familiar to any pagan who thinks she’s heard a message from her god or goddess, but isn’t certain. 

In brief, here is the issue: The gods, as we know, cannot incarnate, so they can’t communicate with their followers as we might communicate with each other. (But if they could, I would absolutely be up in the Morrígan’s DMs all the freaking time.) Instead, they’ll pass on messages to us through other means. The Morrígan has been known to communicate with people through dreams before, and in my own case, even specific songs.

The thing is, knowing for certain what a particular deity wants of you is a very inexact science. The Lord Protector in Wolfwalkers thinks it’s his god’s wish that he massacre an entire pack of wolves so the trees can be cut down, for example, when it’s more likely his own personal biases are influencing his decision-making but he’s assuming it’s coming from on high.

It’s the same with me and the Great Queen. While I can never know for certain that She wants me to be a priestess, I have had plenty of experiences over the past year that seem to be pointing in that direction, since I am her raven, and out of all the gods I worship, She is the one that I interact with most frequently. 

The thing is, Troi, NONE OF THIS IS ACTUALLY A PROBLEM. IT’S JUST HOW RELIGION WORKS. 

What really grinds my gears though is how even the Mintakans conceive of their Old Religion, to make a “witch cult theory” joke. As part of the whole proto-Vulcan thing, it is repeatedly stressed by those characters that they believe their former faith to be a silly superstition. “Liko, all this talk of supernatural beings. No one has believed that for countless generations. Just as we no longer believe the stars control our fates, or the spirits of the dead haunt the living,” says Nuria early on, before she ends up becoming a follower of The Picard herself.

This kind of bullshit is what I was talking about back in the post on “Where Silence Has Lease,” when I said that “there are times where it wears its atheism in such a way that you’d think the episode was being written by Richard “The God Delusion” Dawkins.” 

After spending much of the TOS era doing things like showing the Enterprise’s chapel, an episode about Roman Christianity, and even one where they meet Apollo, the ‘90s-era Trek shows go all in on the space atheism bit, and absolutely drives me crazy. 

I hated it so much that last year I decided to just go and write Actual Wicca into Starlight Endeavours, because I wanted something Star Trek-like that treated faith with respect, rather than as something to be moved on from.

Because like, here’s the thing. I agree that if we want to get to a Star Trek style future, we should move on from things like capitalism, racism, homophobia, transphobia, ableism, etc. But we don’t have to get rid of religion, and frankly, or should we. My faith has helped me grow into a better person, and it now touches every aspect of my life. That’s something to be celebrated, not scorned. 

It is absolutely possible to do a story about not revering ordinary people as divine beings, without making it sound like you’re accusing all religions as being somehow false or foolish compared to the superiority of atheism. And Star Trek, on a good day, can do that kind of thing beautifully. For crying out loud, this won’t even be the last time we talk about Trek and religion.

“Who Watches the Watchers” did not do that. It couldn’t even be bothered to treat a fictional religion with respect, nevermind a real one.

And frankly, fuck it.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑