Captain’s log, stardate 80963.4: Worf’s conscience struggles with a fatality under his command. Meanwhile, the deceased crew member’s son must confront an alien life form that attempts to take on the physical form of his mother.
This week, the debut of one Ronald D. Moore, best known now for the reimagined Battlestar Galactica and For All Mankind, but his career began with Star Trek: The Next Generation. According to Wikipedia:
“In 1988, he toured the Star Trek: The Next Generation sets during the filming of the episode “Time Squared.” While there, he passed a script he had written to one of Gene Roddenberry’s assistants, who helped him get an agent who submitted the script through proper channels. About seven months later, executive producer Michael Piller read the script and bought it; it became the third-season episode “The Bonding.”
Moore went on to become a script editor for TNG, working closely with Brannon Braga for the bulk of the series and even the first two TNG movies, Generations and First Contact. On TNG proper, he swiftly became the series’ “Klingon guy,” contributing a number of episodes that expanded on 24th century Klingon culture and politics, a role he also filled on DS9.
I’ve come to a have a much greater appreciation for Worf since I became a devotee of the Morrígan the Samhain before last. Both of them are warriors, and Worf’s particular conception of warriorship and what honor means, for me, feels like something She would appreciate and vibe with. I mention this particularly because, in this episode, Worf gets to act in the Great Queen’s role as a guardian of death.
As Morpheus Ravenna notes in The Book of the Great Queen, “Every tradition, to be relevant and of service to human communities, must find its way to engaging with death. People die, and their deaths must be dignified with sacred grace.” Regarding the work of funerary priests, shí adds, “Religious freedom in death, to be given the funeral rites that are sacred to us and that sanctify our deaths, is in a sense the final sovereignty. Denial of agency over our own deaths diminishes and indignifies us.”
I thought about this during the scene in the computer access room where Worf and Troi discuss (or rather, argue) about Worf’s desire to perform a Klingon remembrance ritual, the R’uustai. Troi cautions him against it, noting that “It’s very generous, Worf, but he’s not a Klingon child. He has different sensibilities.”
I understand what she’s trying to gesture to (that Jeremy’s views on death and loss should be respected) but I don’t think it works very well, since as we talked about last week, the humans of Roddenberry’s 24th century do not seem to possess any sort of spiritual belief system whatsoever. Hell, it’s not even until we get to the last two minutes of the episode that the kid even cries. The rest of the time, you’d think he was a Vulcan from how he reacts (or rather, doesn’t) to Marla’s death.
What is going on here? As usual, the problem is “Gene Roddenberry decided to be a dipshit again.” When Moore pitched this story during TNG’s second season, (per TV Tropes) “Gene, however, rejected the pitch because “In the 24th Century, people do not grieve. Death is accepted as a part of life.”
This is absolutely backwards from a Wiccan perspective. While it is true that we acknowledge death as a part of the endless cycle of life, that doesn’t mean that we are robots who, like Data, do not have the context needed to process emotions. We do grieve, because death is just as painful for us as it is for any other group of people. We have funerary rituals too.
I think what Worf is trying to do in offering to perform his own remembrance ritual with Jeremy, aside from communicating the fact that he isn’t alone, is to give Jeremy some kind of needed spiritual fulfillment. By the time of “Rightful Heir” from season 6 (for which Moore wrote the teleplay) Worf is shown to be a deeply religious man, in keeping with his particular interpretations of Klingon spirituality.
By spiritually adopting Jeremy and helping him to participate in the ritual that ends the episode, Worf shows that he understands all aspects of warriorship – up to, and including, reckoning with death.
Given the episode’s airdate (October 23rd, 1989) and themes, this is a very Samhain coded episode, though not quite in the same way as Dark Water/Death in Heaven, the last story in a major sci-fi institution that allowed me to make that observation. That episode was mainly about Missy subverting the reincarnation process for evil ends – this gets to grips with the spiritual heart of the holiday, as a time of remembrance for those who have died.
The energy being that takes on the form of Marla Aster in the back half of the episode assumes that she’s doing right by Jeremy in giving him not only his mother back, but his old house and his pet cat as well. But she’s really not – if I were in Jeremy’s place, I’d probably be deeply offended at the idea of some alien intelligence thinking it can smoothly replace a dead parent.
To quote Captain Picard’s speech near the end of the episode: “It is part of our life cycle that we accept the death of those we love. Jeremy must come to terms with his grief. He must not cover it or hide away from it. You see, we are mortal. Our time in this universe is finite. That is one of the truths that all humans must learn.”
Exactly right. Grieving is a difficult and painful process – it wasn’t until my grandma’s funeral in September of 2022 that I was finally able to cry, after spending much of the preceding six months hearing about how the stroke had completely changed her personality. It was hard and painful and awful, but even as I stood there by the gravesite in the middle of an Irish Catholic funeral, I could feel the Great Queen’s presence with me… even if I didn’t know she was there.
Grieving must be done. But we don’t have to do it alone. That, I think, is what this episode is trying to teach us. Jeremy’s ritual work with Worf gives him the closure he needs, as surely as a prayer to Badb, in her role as Washer at the Ford, would do for me.
On the starship Enterprise, no one is alone. What a beautiful, important sentiment.
I love this show. ❤
Leave a Reply