This week, we talk about two very important episodes: Cutie Mark Chronicles, of course, contains the story about how Rainbow Dash performed her first sonic rainboom and got her cutie mark, which I referred to back in December, but with five other ones as well. It’s also technically our third CMC episode in the last two weeks, but they take a supporting role this time around since the bulk of the runtime is devoted to flashbacks.
Cutie Mark Chronicles has a very simple plot: Sweetie Belle, Applebloom, and Scootaloo ask around Ponyville for cutie mark stories, seeking inspiration in their own attempts to find their marks. Through a series of flashbacks, we learn how each of the mane cast got their marks, in the following order: Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity, Twilight, Pinkie, and Rainbow.
And while all these stories are interesting, I want to focus on two: Twilight and Rainbow’s. According to a deviantArt comment, Lauren Faust suggests that Celestia had a hunch Twilight may have been the bearer of the Element of Magic, which is fascinating in light of not just everything that happened with Sunset Shimmer (Twilight’s immediate predecessor as Celestia’s student) but also in light of future events.
We know from the season 5 finale that Starlight Glimmer manipulates the timeline of the series by preventing Dash from completing her Rainboom, by implication this means the rest of the mane six never earn their marks, or if they do, they’re different from what they’re supposed to be.
Those episodes focus on three major alterations: a timeline where King Sombra, as dictator of the Crystal Empire, went to war on an Equestria where Luna never returned, one where Queen Chrysalis took control as she planned to in the season two finale, and most importantly, one where Nightmare Moon defeated Celestia when she returned from her banishment.
And while all these timelines are fascinating in their own right, I believe the Nightmare Moon one was the most likely to occur, since she was the first villain of the series. With no rainboom, Twilight never passes her entrance exam into the School for Gifted Unicorns, leaving the Elements lost and Equestria defenseless. While it’s never said in dialogue just how long Nightmare has been in control, I can’t imagine it must have been that long, since without a sun to warm up the planet, Equestria would’ve eventually frozen over and become the wasteland that Starlight and Twilight end up at before resetting the timeline back to normal.
So what do we take away from this? Firstly, Celestia’s guess was absolutely right: Twilight was the Element of Magic, she just needed a spark, like the Rainboom, to unlock her natural abilities. Sunset might have been as well (her backstory indicates she had just as much magical ability as Twilight) but her egotism and ambition were her downfall, whereas Twilight was just a total introvert.
Secondly, as I’ve said, that Rainboom (much like Clara’s leaf in Doctor Who) was the most important thing in the world. Twilight says at the end, “Everypony everywhere has a special magical connection with her friends, maybe even before she’s met them,” and as we’ll see in the next season, we’re gonna need that reminder.
On the other side of the coin is Owl’s Well That Ends Well, which as above is a very important episode, just not in a good way: it’s a Spike episode.
Poor Spike gets the worst treatment out of anyone in the show, and I am including Applejack (who never gets much of an arc compared to the other five) in that statement. Of his focus episodes over the run of the show, they are all among the worst-received by the fandom until the last third, beginning with Gauntlet of Fire in season six.
The reason why appears to be that until then, the show writers never quite figured out what to do with him when he wasn’t sharing screen time with anyone else, especially Twilight. Power Ponies in season 4 at least tries to fix this by making him the hero of the hour while his friends are unable to act, but other than that, most of his other focus episodes twist his character in order to make the plot work.
In this episode for example, Spike first lies to Twilight about what happened to the astronomy book, then later suddenly becomes jealous of Owlowiscious and concocts a plan to discredit him, which while highly unlikely to succeed (even Twilight notices how badly it was put together) is still jarringly out of character for someone who is otherwise selfless and conscientious. For crying out loud, he even goes on a fishing expedition for praise when everyone is on the hillside watching the meteor shower, which he otherwise wouldn’t do!
All that said, Spike isn’t completely useless. The tie-in comic book line from IDW has him, per TVTropes, “fight off a Changeling invasion, infiltrate the palace of the Nightmare Forces by himself (and then escaped capture), help Luna solve a series of arson attacks in Fillydelphia, help Zecora cure Ponyville of a disease (and figured out the cause of it by himself, to boot), and went on an adventure with Celestia to the Crystal Mountains,” while the show usually turns him into a jerk for 22 minutes. (Then there’s Spike At Your Service from season 3, which is awful for entirely different reasons…)
The good news though is that now, we have just two more episodes to look at before we wrap up season 1. Party of One is notable for being the first Pinkie Pie episode, among other reasons, and The Best Night Ever serves as a culmination to the Gala plot line, while also being one of only two single-episode finales in the whole show. (The Last Problem, the final episode of season 9 and the series as a whole, is the other one.) Stay tuned!
Leave a Reply