We come at last to the end of season 1 of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, and I’m happy to report that our last two episodes for the season are true classics, with a lot going on in both of them, so without further ado, let’s just dive right in and get the party started! I promise, unlike the Grand Galloping Gala, that it won’t be boring.
Party of One starts off normally enough: Pinkie invites the girls over to Sugarcube Corner for Gummy’s first birthday party (Gummy being her toothless pet alligator) and they have such a good time, that she decides to organize another party for the next afternoon, only to have each of her friends decline, citing other activities. Pinkie starts to get suspicious, and spends the next several minutes spying on her friends, wearing a series of ridiculous disguises.
The pivotal moment comes when she overhears the following conversation between Fluttershy and Rarity:
Rarity: Have you seen her?
Fluttershy: Not since this morning.
Rarity: Me neither. Can you believe she was planning on throwing an after-birthday party today?
Fluttershy: I’m just glad I was able to come up with an excuse for why I couldn’t be there.
Rarity: Me too! This is obviously going to be so much better.
Fluttershy: As long as we keep her from finding out about it, it will.
Sounds pretty incriminating, right? Without context, it’s completely understandable that Pinks would conclude her friends didn’t like her anymore, or her parties. After chasing Dash across Ponyville (again) and interrogating Applejack, she realizes they’re hiding something from her, so she questions Spike, since he’s the only one not directly involved with the plot.
Of course, because he doesn’t know anything, the interrogation quickly gets derailed, with Pinkie getting increasingly enraged. Andrea Libman is absolutely on fire this week, doing a magnificent portrayal of Pinkie’s shifts in mood from calm and casual to furious. But there’s more…
Pinkie demands Spike tell her what she wants to hear, and Spike (not knowing any better) does just that: “Your friends are all lying to you and avoiding you ’cause they don’t like your parties and they don’t want to be your friends anymore!” What follows is the darkest scene in the entire season (and perhaps the series) as her mane deflates, and after the act break, she has a complete nervous breakdown, using inanimate objects as party guests (with voices!) and disquieting background music.
Remember, this is a children’s cartoon intended for 7 year old girls, and we’re watching the happiest pony in Equestria seemingly lose her grip on reality altogether. What the voices are telling her is even worse:
Pinkie Pie [as Rocky]: I’m just glad none o’ them ponies showed up.
Pinkie Pie: Oh, they’re not so bad.
Rocky: Not so bad? Puh-lease! They’re a buncha losers!
Pinkie Pie: Oh, c’mon now. “Losers” might be a little strong, dont’cha think?
Sir Lintsalot: After the way they treated you? I say “losers” isn’t strong enough.
Pinkie Pie: Well, it was pretty rude…
Madame le Flour: Pretty rude? It was downright deespicable!
Thank goodness Rainbow Dash showed up when she did, (and that this is rated Y) because if either of those things weren’t true… one imagines something akin to that episode of Star Trek: Lower Decks where an animated holographic character, Badgey, tries to murder Ensigns Rutherford and Tendi after he malfunctions. (Indeed, there’s an infamous fanfic called “Cupcakes” in which Pinkie really does try to kill Rainbow… though I wouldn’t suggest looking for it.)
Obviously, I’m not against darkness and maturity of subject matter in children’s media. My favorite book series when I was growing up started off with the protagonists’ parents being killed in an arson incident, and ended with the main villain attempting to marry the eldest child, with dialogue suggesting there might have even been sex involved, had Violet not managed to ruin the whole thing by signing with her left hand rather than her dominant right one. For crying out loud, Roald Dahl made an entire career out of putting dark shit in his children’s books! Even the sweetest treats have to be balanced out with some bitterness, to use a baking analogy that Pinkie might agree with.
And this entire sequence lets us see Pinkie’s biggest fear: her friends no longer needing her. We saw in The Cutie Mark Chronicles that before Dash’s rainboom, our pink party pony was absolutely miserable! She had no friends, only her stern and austere family. Moving to Ponyville and pursuing her dream job as a party planner was the best thing that ever happened to her, and it got even better when she met Twilight Sparkle and the rest in the pilot. And as an extrovert, Pinkie needs her friends to be happy, otherwise… well, now we know.
Luckily, things end on a happy note: Dash drags Pinkie to Applejack’s barn, and discovers that they aren’t throwing her a farewell party, but a birthday party! When Pinkie realizes this, her mane re-inflates and she goes back to being the cheerful mare we know and love. Twilight leaves us on a good note with her letter to Celestia: “Always expect the best from your friends, and never assume the worst. Rest assured that a good friend always has your best interests at heart.” A solid note to end on if there ever was one.
And so we come to The Best Night Ever, the final episode of season 1. It serves as the culmination of the Gala plot line referred to in The Ticket Master and Suited for Success, featuring the dresses shown in the latter episode, and most of the plot is spent with the girls trying to do what they said they’d do in the former: Sell apples, meet a prince, commune with the animals, hang out with the Wonderbolts, do exciting party things, and chat with Princess Celestia about everything she’s learned over the past twenty six episodes.
And at first, everything seems to be going well! AJ makes a sale, Rarity finds Prince Blueblood in the castle gardens, Pinkie is impressed by the look of the dance floor, Twilight says hello to Celestia, Dash gets invited to hang with the Wonderbolts after rescuing Soarin’s pie, and Fluttershy hears what she thinks is a bird singing. So far so good, right?
Well, not exactly. Very rapidly, events begin to spiral out of control: Blueblood turns out to be a sexist jackass who treats Rarity as The Help and then an equine shield, Dash causes property damage, Pinkie drives everyone nuts when she tries to liven up the party, Twilight gets so busy greeting guests that she and Celestia only say a few words to each other, AJ doesn’t make any other sales, and Fluttershy… she has a psychotic episode. (Link goes to the relevant clip.)
No, I’m not kidding. For the second time in a row, a pony voiced by Andrea Libman goes completely batshit insane, and it’s amazing. She’s like, “I’ll catch you yet, my pretties. Oh yes. As soon as one of you little birds or monkeys or bears touches this net… you’ll be mine! Mine!” And then she laughs maniacally, only to get caught in her own trap. It simply has to be seen to be believed, mere text doesn’t do the moment justice.
The best scene for me though is the last one at the Gala: Applejack came in with a huge cake which she intended to give to the attendees, only for Pinkie to do a stage dive onto it, splattering cake everywhere… and in particular Rarity, when Blueblood uses her as a shield, as I mentioned above. Rarity turns around on him and absolutely explodes, giving him a much-deserved dressing down: “You, sir, are the most uncharming prince I have ever met! In fact, the only thing royal about you is that you are a royal pain!”
And then she attacks him by splattering cake in his face! That’s about when Dash tries to stop a statue of Celestia from falling to the ground and shattering, but it’s too heavy for her, so the statue knocks into a column, and then… well, imagine what happens with dominoes, only with ionic columns of the sort favored in Ancient Greece.
Then, from Twilight: “Well… it can’t get any worse.” Cue a stampede of panicking animals coming in from the garden as Fluttershy yells out, “You’re… going to LOVE ME!”
Like I said, it’s kind of amazing.
Gushing aside though, I have a much greater appreciation for this episode than I did when I first saw it in May 2011. At the time I thought it was pretty good, (especially the mass chaos described in the past several paragraphs) but later season finales were much better at the whole “being a finale” thing.
But then we got to The Last Problem, the final episode of the series as a whole. That episode, told primarily in flashback, is all about Twilight leaving Ponyville to return to Canterlot so she can rule Equestria, and it even shows her coronation ceremony. And just like with the Gala this time around, everything goes wrong: Twilight almost misses her train, there’s a screw up with the animals, the food, and the acrobatic display, even Twilight’s dress gets ruined!
While the lesson in that case was unspoken, it’s a well-deserved repeat by implication of the one Twilight gives at the end of this episode: “Friends have a way of making even the worst of times into something pretty great.” And that’s a good place to wrap things up, if you ask me – they even return to the donut shop at the end.
It’s been a long ride, rewatching this season again, in places for the first time since the original airdates. Truth be told, season 1 isn’t even close to my favorite of the nine, but it’s still an important one, and there are plenty of promising moments to be had. I hope this series of posts has been an engaging read, and I’m looking forward to continuing on with it in the months and years ahead. I hope you’ll all come with me.
Leave a Reply