Captain’s log, stardate 80982.6: After taking the Enterprise into a mysterious asteroid belt to examine the only known relic of a long-dead race, Picard discovers that the belt is actually a lethal snare and assigns La Forge the impossible task of finding a way out before it’s too late.
All the way back in the post on “The Arsenal of Freedom,” I made an observation regarding one Mr. LeVar Burton as Geordi La Forge:
Moving on to Geordi La Forge, our guy gets his best outing all season. While he will go on to become a legendary engineer, as my girlfriend commented when she watched this episode with me, you kind of wonder why there’s never been a Captain Geordi show. You definitely get he understands the basic principles of command, not just from watching Picard, but his own intuition.
There’s something of “LeVar Burton the Reading Rainbow host” about the way he acts here, most prominently in the way he interacts with Troi during the ready room scene, but especially in the way he puts that jackass Leland Lynch (chief engineer number 4) in his place. And as for his plan to separate the ship so he can go into battle while Lynch commands the saucer section? Sheer brilliance.
“Arsenal” proved beyond a doubt that Burton was being absolutely wasted in his first-season role as the Enterprise’s helmsman. Sure, it means we got to see him up on the bridge every week, rather than hunkering down in Engineering like he does for much of the rest of the series, but on the other hand there’s only so much Acting you can do when 90% of your lines center around being the navigator.
Season 2’s “The Child” is otherwise an abominable disaster of an episode, but there is one good scene in it: the one where Geordi gets his much-deserved promotion to chief engineer:
LAFORGE: We’re constructing the enclosure on cargo deck five.
PICARD: (back to his Yorkshire roots) Grand. Take a look at the containment module our Chief Engineer has designed.
RIKER: Chief Engineer. It still has a nice ring to it.
“Booby Trap” sees that promotion come in very handy this week, when the Enterprise finds itself caught up in an ancient trap and only Geordi’s engineering know-how (along with some deft maneuvering of the helm by Picard) can break the ship free, with an assist from, essentially, a holographic recreation of Leah Brahms, the woman who helped design the Galaxy class in the first place.
As Geordi and Leah work the problem, (and I have to tell you, I love those sequences – this show is the living definition of Competence Porn) it transpires that the only way they can possibly escape the trap is if the computer pilots the ship:
LAFORGE: God, what am I supposed to tell the Captain? It’s possible and yet it’s not possible. Everything we’ve done says we can’t adjust that fast, but if we could, it might work.
LEAH: I could do it.
LAFORGE: Data couldn’t even do it. It’ll take a hundred, maybe even a thousand adjustments every second. How are you going to do it? It’s humanly impossible.
LEAH: I’m not human.
LAFORGE: You mean the computer could do it.
But then, just when you think the episode is about to endorse machines replacing humans at tasks that only humans are suited for, Riker comes out with this: “Computers have always impressed me with their ability to take orders. I’m not nearly as convinces of their ability to creatively give them.”
And then we get the best moment in the entire episode. La Forge, showing far more insight than most modern day Big Tech executives, tells Picard that the only way to get the ship free is with human intuition… and the episode ends, as noted earlier, with Picard taking the helm himself and putting some extremely precise maneuvering skills to good use.
Picard’s skill at piloting isn’t anything new – there’s that wonderful scene in “Coming of Age” where he talks a frightened kid out of avoiding a crash, and of course, he’s the man who invented the Picard maneuver, as seen in “The Battle.” But all the same, that’s nothing compared to actually watching him do his thing! (See also: The scene in “Et in Arcadia Ego” where he improvises a variation on his own maneuver in order to fool the Romulan armada.)
This episode, I have to admit, hits very differently here in 2025 than it did when I watched it for the first time back in 2022. As I noted back in the post on “The Big Goodbye,” we live in an era where machine learning models are not only becoming more and more popular, they’re actively changing the world… and not for the better.
There are news reports all over of students using ChatGPT to complete their homework assignments and refusing to think for themselves, in favor of allowing the equivalent of the Enterprise’s holodeck to do their thinking for them… even though this is how we end up with, say, spaghetti recipes with gasoline as a key ingredient.
And of course, you can’t forget about all the tech companies, particularly Microsoft, shoving AI “assistants” and Goddess knows what else into their operating systems because the execs have decided that computers are better than humans at everything, including writing, painting, and video editing.
Watched in today’s AI-generated nightmarish hellscape, a Star Trek episode from 36 years ago extolling the virtues of human ingenuity shouldn’t feel like a revelation, but it does. Our real-life 21st century world feels less real than the fictional 24th century one, because at least in the world of Star Trek, even freaking Data would rather give up all his android superiority just so he can be human instead.
And here, having spent all episode with the walking, talking personification of the Enterprise computer right next to him, it’s Geordi who stands up and says that no, the computer can’t get them out of this, only a human brain and ingenuity can. All leaving it to the computer does is get everyone killed.
Even a similar moment in “The Last Generation,” regarding flying the Enterprise THROUGH A BORG CUBE, which is supposed to be impossible, only works because the computer in question (Data) is now technically human, and thus, he has what Leah Brahms’ recreation didn’t – gut instinct.
This is the kind of Star Trek episode that, if it were made today, would be widely derided by fans for being “woke” or something because, at least in spirit, it is the antithesis of everything that Sam Altman and Elon Musk stand for. They want computers to take over the world, with men like them as feudal lords.
Who better than the chief engineer of the USS Enterprise to tell them, at least in action, to go fuck themselves?
(As for the whole Leah Brahms thing… we’ll tackle that in season four.)
What this episode is, at bottom, is the exact same story archetype as The Doctor’s Wife, a Smith-era Who episode rather extensively rewritten by Steven Moffat on the basis of an idea by a certain cartoonishly evil children’s author.
In that episode, the Doctor is magically allowed to speak to, and share in an adventure with, his TARDIS, as the two of them race to save Amy and Rory from being killed off by House – a sentient asteroid. “Booby Trap” is the exact same idea but done 22 years earlier, with Geordi filling the Eleventh Doctor’s role and Leah taking on the part of Idris – the humanoid personification of the ship whose adventures we’re following on.
In one gorgeous scene near the end of Wife, the Doctor has a tearful final conversation with the TARDIS… and then, later, reacts joyfully when the dematerialization lever pulls itself. The equivalent scene in “Booby Trap” doesn’t contain any crying from Geordi, but it does have this:
LAFORGE: You know, I’ve always thought that technology could solve almost any problem. It enhances the quality of our lives. Lets us travel across the galaxy. Even gave me my vision. But sometimes you have to turn it all off. Even the [Romani] violins.
LEAH: Violins?
LAFORGE: Different programme.
LEAH: We made a good team.
LAFORGE: Maybe we can do it again some time.
LEAH: I’m with you every day, Geordi. Every time you look at this engine, you’re looking at me. Every time you touch it, it’s me.
What both episodes are interacting with is the concept of animism: the attribution of a soul to plants, inanimate objects, and natural phenomena. This kind of thing crops up in pagan circles all the time, even in my own faith of Wicca. The Enterprise, being a starship built by humans, (who are themselves beloved creations of the God and Goddess, as is the universe through which the Enterprise traverses) should therefore be expected to have some form of spirit as well, and this episode proves that she does, once and for all!
Animism was huge in the pre-Christian era, particularly in ancient Ireland. The landscape is riddled with places named for various sisters within the Morrígan trinity – after all, part of Her role as being a goddess of sovereignty included protecting the land and the people who lived upon it. In the coming seasons we’ll find the TNG writing staff running with the idea of the Enterprise as a lifeform all its own, beginning with next season’s “Galaxy’s Child.”
“Booby Trap” is one of these episodes that remind me why I fell as hard for Trek as I did. There’s magic here too, you just have to look for it.
Leave a Reply