Wolf Trek: The Enemy

Captain’s log, stardate 81001.4: Trapped without the aid of his VISOR, Geordi is aided and abetted in his attempts to send a distress signal to the Enterprise by a shipwrecked Romulan.


This week it’s another Geordi episode, though rather than staying in the warm, comfortable environs of the Enterprise, our favorite chief engineer instead finds himself trapped in a cave with a bad-tempered Romulan – in fact, this is the first time we see the Romulans ever since season 1’s “The Neutral Zone,” where they grandly announced that “we are back,” before fucking off to go do Romulan Things offscreen during all of season 2, except “Contagion.”

If there’s any species from the TOS years that TNG goes to great lengths to flesh out, there are two big candidates – the Klingons (via Worf) and the Romulans. The Romulans don’t get as many appearances by dint of the fact that they are still on adversarial terms with the Federation, but when they do show up, the results are usually pretty compelling television.

I admit to having something of a fondness for the Romulans – I used them in New Endeavours (my now-concluded fanfic series I’ve mentioned here before) to serve as co-villains with Equestrian changelings, where they were the ones to bring the insectoid equines into space and menace my protagonists throughout much of the first three books. When I wrote books 6 and 7 last year, I returned to them in chapters like “One True Captain” and “Peace in Our Time,” positioning them not as antagonists, but as good guys – my own spin on what PIC did with them in that show’s first season. 

Even TNG itself takes some steps forward in making the Romulans out to be more than their origins in “Balance of Terror,” starting with this – an episode where Geordi and Bochra (the Romulan he’s stuck with) are forced to work together to survive. Meanwhile on the Enterprise, Picard insists that Worf give some of his blood to a second Romulan, who has been fatally injured, even though neither Worf nor Patahk are on board with the idea.

Oh yeah, and this is the first appearance of everyone’s favorite Romulan commander, good ol’ Tomalak! He’s one of those characters that you think appears more often than he actually does – in truth, he’s only in four episodes, including this one. To me he’s as close as TNG gets to Gul Dukat on DS9, though the comparison isn’t perfect – for one thing, Dukat appears in way more episodes than Tomalak does.

But getting back to Geordi and Bochra. One of my favorite tropes Of All Time is perfectly executed in this episode, called “Befriending the Enemy.” To quote the page, “A character who Befriends The Enemy is basically planning to become something of a Morality Pet to try and make a villain or antagonist change their ways. This has about a 50/50 chance of success since often times the villain really is a loner, or they’re suffering from some sort of trauma and they could be redeemed if they had some friends to support them.” 

It’s a trope that Friendship is Magic uses quite extensively, particularly in the cases of characters like Sunset Shimmer, Starlight Glimmer, and of course, Discord – Q with his harder edges filed off. In the case of “The Enemy,” the trope page notes that “Geordi and Bochra start off as sworn enemies, but having to work together to survive helps dissolve their animosity. In fact, just agreeing to work together in the first place is a tacit acknowledgment that they are no longer enemies.”

This is the kind of thing that I love both in my Trek, and in my own writing. New Endeavours has a very long mirror universe plot that runs through the entire series, in which Mirror Raven (the “evil” counterpart of the Endeavour’s XO, Raven Sable) gradually finds herself warming to the Starfleet!Endeavour’s crew, thanks to not only repeated run-ins, but various circumstances forcing the two crews to work together.

The key shift in allegiance occurs in “Broken Glass,” the fifth chapter of book 4. In that story, the two crews are forced to work together to stop some inter-dimensional Klingon-Cardassian Alliance supply raids. While the story was originally intended to serve as the “final” mirror-universe story, I changed my mind and reworked it entirely because of one scene in particular – a very long two-hander between Gem and Mirror Raven. 

In that scene, Raven reveals a piece of information that will form the core of the arc for the second half of the series: she has joined a conspiracy working to depose the Solar Empire with a democratic government ruled by Mirror!Princess Twilight, like the one Mirror!Spock is said to have formed, only it doesn’t fail. 

It took years for me to figure out how to wrap up the arc up, but I will say this – the otherwise-execrable Section 31 film did provide me with the bones of a story in which Raven disposes of the last thing that might ruin the pro-democracy conspiracy’s plan once and for all.

Geordi and Bochra go through something similar to the above mentioned conversation in “The Enemy.” If you watched only those scenes, you’d have an episode where two sworn enemies gradually begin to work together, learn more about each other, and ultimately triumph, forming a bond in the process. TNG’s episodic nature means that we never see Bochra again past this episode, but I like to think the two of them kept in touch when they could.

The planet-side scenes of this story, IMO, are the best ones, especially as they serve as neat counterpoint to the equivalent action going on with Worf and the blood transfusion. In that plot thread, Worf, due to his earlier beliefs in “The Neutral Zone” regarding the Romulans being not honorable, at least insofar as Klingons think of the concept, refuses repeatedly to give his blood to the Romulan.

Near the end of the episode, Picard is trying to convince Worf to do it anyway with a combination of facts, logic, and the desire to not order Worf to do something against his beliefs… and then Beverly announces over the intercom that the Romulan in question has died of his injuries, rendering the whole discussion moot. (The next scene is Geordi and Bochra finding the beacon they need to call out to the Enterprise.)

The trans plot line proved to be very unpopular by pretty much everyone except Rick Berman and Michael Piller, but in particular Michael Dorn, who had this to say on the subject:

“I called the producers and said I didn’t agree. I thought [giving blood] was the honorable thing to do. I thought people would look at [Worf] as a murderer. The producers felt that Worf was getting to be too Human…just a guy with a big head. When the opportunity came for them to show that Worf was not Human, that he is not bound by the same morals as we are, they felt it was a wonderful opportunity.”

I can see the point that Piller and Berman were trying to make, but ultimately I’m on Dorn’s side here. There are other ways to demonstrate Worf’s alien ethics that don’t involve compromising the themes of the episode. If both of this story’s plot threads had ended with cooperation between the Federation and the Star Empire, this episode (I think) would be just as warmly regarded by me as “Booby Trap” is.

But it’s not. There are good things about this story that will pay off in future Trek series (as we’ll explore when we get to Picard) but in the end, those good things don’t outweigh the bad things in this case. This is a deeply flawed episode, one where its good points very much exist in spite of the wider story, rather than because of it.

Better luck next time, folks.


Supplemental: Happy 60th anniversary, Star Trek! As this is the first post of the franchise’s diamond anniversary, I figured the occasion deserved an acknowledgement. On the blog, get ready for further Wolf Trek posts as we continue our voyages through TNG’s third season, along with some other Trek-related projects waiting in the wings. See you next week!

-Lena

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑