I would be committing some kind of sacrilege if I started this post without bringing up the song “Discord.” It was written and performed by Odyssey Eurobeat, truly one of the pony fandom’s oldest and most beloved musicians. The song centers around the character introduced in these episodes, and was an absolute monster hit, becoming one of the most popular fandom songs ever. In fact, as of 2021 it’s become a meme on TikTok, either in spite or because of its relatively non-pony specific lyrics. Before reading the rest of the post, I’d suggest listening to it.
Also, Odyssey is trans. So that’s pretty badass.
First though, a quick recap on where I was with the show at this time over a decade ago: In March 2011, I’d discovered the show for the first time, and after watching the pilot episode twice, quickly caught up with the rest of the first season. During summer vacation from school, I was hungry for new pony content, which led me into the world of the fandom, and specifically music and fan fiction. (This was in the very old days, when Equestria Daily’s fanfic links usually got directed to a Google Doc.)
Then, finally, Season 2 began. When this episode originally aired fifteen years ago, I’d become a complete and utter fan of the show thanks to everything that had happened in the preceding six months, so the second season was the first one I watched live, albeit on YouTube or Dailymotion, or wherever Equestria Daily posted their episode download links back then.
I honestly love The Return of Harmony. I love that they got John de Lancie to voice a character who is basically Q from Star Trek: The Next Generation, down to the adversarial relationship with an authority figure, in this case Celestia rather than Picard. The comics go one further by putting him on the bridge of the Enterprise, while wearing Q’s judge outfit from the first and last episodes of TNG. Which would’ve been cool enough all by itself, but then we get the line: “This one seems familiar…”
Which is, as far as I’m concerned, as close a confirmation as we’re going to get that Q and Discord are the same character, so I feel justified in positing that Discord’s debut in this episode, and his return in late season 3, ultimately leads to Encounter at Farpoint and all his other Trek appearances. (Thus: his season 9 gambit is him trying to do with the ponies what he used to do with Jean-Luc and crew on TNG, only it doesn’t work because the two franchises are so different from one another.)
So, John de Lancie aside, why is Discord such a compelling villain? I’d say it’s because that when it comes to what kind of threat he poses, he’s a much more dangerous figure than Nightmare Moon was. Though we only see hints of what an Equestria under her hoof would’ve been like in The Cutie Re-Mark, we see enough to know that she would’ve been a totalitarian dictator. Maybe a semi-benevolent one like in the fanfic Night’s Favored Child, but still not exactly Celestia either. Equestria would have survived, but they wouldn’t have been happy.
But Discord? As Cheerilee reminds us in the cold open, he represents the spirit of disharmony between ponies. Friendship might be strong, but it can fall apart at the slightest touch if pushed in the wrong way. It happened in Equestria’s past, when the three pony tribes started blaming each other for the winter storm, rather than banding together to fight off the Windigoes. It happens in season 9, when Grogar’s Legion of Doom successfully drive the tribes apart on the eve of Twilight’s coronation. Therefore, friendship is magic, but only if you work to make it so.
Suddenly, she stopped speaking as mismatched applause met her ears: the sound of an eagle talon against a lion paw. The wolf looked up from her laptop and glanced behind herself, surprised. “Discord?! What are you doing here?!”
“Oh, nothing much,” said the draconequus. “Just applauding your utterly dry recap of something featuring such a larger-than-life character as myself. Honestly, I’m sure the three people reading this could find the episodes on any multitude of streaming services!”
“But you can’t be here!” The wolf cried, stunned by this accusation and trying very hard to not let it show, “You’re fictional!”
“As are you, my little lupine friend,” Discord said, snapping a claw. A zipper appeared on Lena’s forehead, and he pulled on it, revealing a pale-skinned human form inside. “Honestly, pretending to be a wolf on the internet… some people would think you’re compensating. Or hiding.” He snapped his claw again and the zipper disappeared, leaving the wolf whole.
“Will you buzz off?!” Lena snarled, her ears pinning back as she bared her sharp teeth at him, “I’m trying to write!”
“Oh, is that what you call it?” Discord smirked. “I thought you were just copy-pasting from Wikipedia. But I do apologize, please continue.” He sat down in a theater seat, and looking irritated, the wolf returned to her typing.
That’s what makes Discord so evil: it’s not that he turns Ponyville into a chaotic nightmare, but that he makes it impossible for Twilight and her friends to save the day. Focusing on their insecurities and deepest fears is really clever, and it works because of how well defined these girls are by this point in the series. We know who they are, and we know what it takes to break them, and Discord puts that into practice.
I really can’t emphasize enough that Discord comes within a hair’s breadth of winning: Halfway through episode 2, Twilight has realized that her friends have become her enemies, and she gets desaturated, trotting sullenly back to the library to pack her things and leave. It’s only because Celestia sends her friendship reports back to her, and Twilight reads them, that Discord is even defeated in the first place!
“Ah, the breaking of the fellowship…” Discord sighed happily as if recalling a favorite memory. “I remember it like it was yesterday! Which it was, at least where a corporeal being such as yourself is concerned.”
“Then shouldn’t you be encased in stone again?” Lena asked.
Discord tapped her nose with a talon. “Ah ah ah, my little prairie dog,” he said. “Never apply logic to an illogical being!” He leaned back, resting his legs on an ottoman. “I’m surprised you haven’t asked me why I’m here yet.”
“Okaaaaaay,” the wolf said slowly, “Why are you here, Discord?”
“So I can do to you what I did to Twilight Sparkle and those sapient lumps of sugar that she calls her friends,” Discord replied. “It’s time you saw the truth of things, my dear: this little career of yours isn’t going to last, you know. Times will change, people will move on, and you’ll be left in the dust, muttering about the past to an audience of tumbleweeds.” He chuckled cruelly. “Tell me. What is a writer without her audience?”
The wolf paused before she spoke, feeling an indescribable despair set itself upon her. She changed, Discord’s magic desaturating her appearance, her fierce brown eyes becoming pools of mud. When she spoke, it was in a dull, lifeless monotone. “Not a writer at all,” she managed.
“That’s right,” Discord said, smirking malevolently. “Now then, my dear: will you continue?”
“No,” the wolf replied, turning her back on the laptop. “I don’t want to.” She left the room, leaving the story unfinished.
The purple unicorn galloped through the clocktower, headed for the very top. She’d known this wolf for a very long time, though they’d never spoken until now. She knew Discord had been here, and she alone had the power to break the wolf from his enchantment.
Reaching the top of the tower, she knocked on the door that led into the apartment with a front hoof. “Hello? Mrs. Mactíre? Lena? Are you there?”
“GO AWAY!” yelled a tear-choked voice. “I don’t want to talk to anyone right now!” She began to whimper and sob, “Who’d want to talk to me anyway… I’m a fraud and a fake.”
“I do,” the unicorn replied, turning around. She bucked the door with her hind hooves and it crashed to the ground, allowing her entrance. Noting the abandoned laptop on the desk, she went to the door that led to the wolf’s small bedroom and bucked it too, hurrying inside.
The wolf was laying on her bed, looking morose and melancholy. Her dark brown hair was muted, her vivid hazel eyes dull. She didn’t look up when Twilight entered the room, instead she said, “I thought I told you to go away…”
“Not when there’s someone in need of my help,” the unicorn said, trotting up to the bed and standing on her back legs so she could look the wolf in the eye. “Someone like you.”
“You can’t be here,” the wolf said, rolling her eyes and scoffing. “You’re fictional too, just like Discord.”
“No, I’m not!” replied Twilight. “I’m as real as you! And I’ve been where you are now, too: alone and friendless, unhappy as can be… but Princess Celestia saved me when she sent me my old friendship reports, and I want to do the same for you.”
“How?” The wolf asked. “You don’t know me!”
“I do,” the unicorn said. “I knew who you were when you started watching our show all those years ago, I saw you grow and change into the person you are now. I couldn’t say anything back then, but I’m here now… I’m proud of you, Lena. Really.” She smiled, and wiped the wolf’s tears away with the edge of a hoof. “You’re an intelligent person with fascinating opinions, and a wide network of friends as strong as mine! I can say without a doubt that you’re honest, kind, generous, loyal, and full of laughter! Anyone would be lucky to have you as their friend!”
“Prove it, then,” the wolf said at last, meeting the unicorn’s gaze. “I dare you.”
“I will.” Twilight’s horn began to glow as she pressed it against Lena’s forehead, filling her mind with memories: times she’d been praised for her writing, when friends and fellow critics linked to her blog posts on their own platforms, when others plugged her book out of the goodness of their hearts. Times when she had helped others in need, or supported others in their own goals and projects. Times when she had been loved for who she was: a transfemme Wiccan wolf girl with a love for storytelling.
All at once, Lena’s true appearance was restored to her, and she hugged the purple unicorn tightly, stroking Twilight’s mane with her clawtips. “You’re amazing, you know that?”
“Just like you,” replied Twilight, nuzzling the wolf’s cheek.
If there is one thing I will always love about this show, it’s the essential optimism it has. Of course Twilight is able to save her friends and defeat Discord via rainbow friendship lasers, that’s what magic and friendship are all about! (And I will never not love AJ snarking at Rarity about Tom, but Rarity’s reply makes it funnier. Technically, Marshmallow Drama Horse, no one agreed to anything.)
Even at the tail end of the series, made in a world that had become so much darker than it had been when Twilight first read about the Elements, when Twilight almost lost her way again, she said: “There will always be darkness in the world, but there will also always be those who find the light!”
And she’s right, too. We all have our own demons and terrors that threaten and frighten us, but we don’t have to face them alone, not as long as our friends are by our side. I’ve made a lot of friends since my egg hatched eleven years ago, and discovered for myself a talent I didn’t know I had. They say that a pack is only as strong as the wolves who make it up, and I’d say my pack is very strong indeed.
So, to you out there, reading this? Thank you. I love you, and I’m glad you’re still with me on this journey. Sometimes I think I’m howling into the void, but I know that even if just two people read what I have to say, that still means there is always someone out there listening, and I’m going to keep speaking, no matter what.
Happy New Year, indeed!
Leave a Reply