This week’s pair of episodes, coupled with the pair we looked at last week, are for my money the strongest run of the series yet. In Lesson Zero, the show allows itself to break free of the limitations forced upon it during season 1: Back then, FIM was meant to be educational, with Twilight serving as the main learner of lessons/deliverer of morals. Hence the “Dear Princess Celestia” at the end of every episode. The main problem with that, of course, is that sometimes there’s no need for Twilight to learn a lesson, because the episode doesn’t even focus on her!
As an example, let’s take a look again at Stare Master: That episode was primarily a CMC one where they’re paired with Fluttershy, Twilight only appears as a statue to provide some drama, and that’s it! She’s not even the one who delivers the moral, that honor goes to Fluttershy! The episode could’ve worked just as well without her, and in a later season, that’s exactly what would’ve happened. Already the show is straining against its own bonds, but it’s going to take a lot more than a cockatrice and the world’s most important staring competition for it to break free.
Which is where Future Princess Neurotic Book Horse comes in!
In case I haven’t mentioned it enough, I do rather adore Twilight Sparkle. I see a lot of myself in her, even in this episode where she has a complete mental breakdown over missing a deadline. I’ve never gone quite as far as to cause a town-wide magical calamity (I may be a witch, but my magic doesn’t work like hers) but panicking over small things like project deadlines? Oh yeah, been there.
I think it’s worth pointing out just how much Twilight’s grown since the series pilot. This pony, who once scoffed at the very idea of making friends and who seemed afraid of disappointing the ones she did make with regard to the Gala tickets, now has a complete meltdown when she hasn’t sent a friendship report yet! She’s changed, but she still has a lot to learn!
Second off, I just want to take a moment to point out how the show is steadily improving visually: the show was animated in Flash, and in the first season, the limitations of that program led to things like unicorns having a generic magic color instead of getting their own, which changes with this episode. Even the title sequence has changed a bit, from the music itself to details in the animation! We’re not quite near the depth and range of the last two thirds of the series yet, but we’re getting there!
One thing I do find interesting about this episode is the final lesson: “We learned that you should take your friends’ worries seriously. Even if you don’t think that she has anything to worry about.” At the end of the season, guess what happens? The girls completely forget this lesson and the changelings invade Canterlot, all because they didn’t take Twilight’s concerns about Cadance seriously. I do so love it when things mirror each other!
And on the subject of mirroring, there’s Luna Eclipsed, a direct sequel to the pilot, and then some. Luna’s original introduction back then made her one of the first cases of the fandom taking a random pony with no real backstory and quickly giving her one, along with interests and hobbies. If you’re a pony fan of a certain age, then you probably remember Luna and her abacus: That was a reference to a very old fanfic called Progress, which centered around Luna trying to adjust to modern Equestria and clinging to an abacus as a reminder of her own time, and her portrayal in that story quickly became the gold standard for how Luna was written in other fics.
Naturally, when Luna Eclipsed was announced, everyone wondered what canon Luna would be like. Luna’s debut appearance in the second arc of IDW’s comic still went with the season 1 version of the character, with modern speech patterns and a tendency toward being quiet and withdrawn, like Fluttershy only blue.
Needless to say, the actual post-pilot take on Luna was, if possible, even more amazing than the fandom could’ve ever imagined. Far from being withdrawn, post-season 1 Luna is instead a theatrical Princess of the Goths, with a penchant for speaking in Elizabethan English. It’s kind of amazing, and that depiction of our favorite night princess very quickly became the go-to form in fan works. (Including more than a few of mine, though I admit I tend to err a little closer to her season 3 depictions, as I can never get the hang of Shakespearean English.)
As we’ll see later in the series though, there is far more to Luna than just being a giant devourer of scenery. As we’ll see in season 6, she’s still nursing severe trauma from her experiences as Nightmare Moon. That all of Ponyville is afraid of her doesn’t help, and that fear is what drives most of the episode’s conflict. In certain ways, Luna is a mirror of Twilight in the first season: a complete fish out of water, with no idea how social interaction is supposed to work.
Twilight stepping into her role as teacher here neatly foreshadows her change into the Princess of Friendship for the remainder of the series, and one of the morals she mentions in her letter to Celestia, “even if somepony seems a little intimidating, even scary, when you offer them your friendship, you’ll discover a whole new pony underneath,” carries with it added weight given what happens in the Generation 5 movie.
I’ve said before that season 2 was really when the show started to click into place and become the beloved series I fell for, and these first four episodes prove it. They still hold up well after fifteen years, and even carry new meaning now that they take place in what the G5 movie refers to as “ancient Equestria.” Is it bittersweet? Of course it is, but that doesn’t mean I can’t enjoy the ride!
Next week, it’s the battle of the marshmallow drama horses in Sisterhooves Social, and Apple Bloom comes down with a potentially fatal disease in The Cutie Pox. Join us, won’t you?
Leave a Reply