Equestria Forever: Sisterhooves Social/The Cutie Pox

Hi everypony, and welcome to just another week in the lives of our favorite sextet of pastel equines! We pick up right where I left off with this week’s pair of episodes, both of which center around two members of the Cutie Mark Crusaders. The first of these is “Sisterhooves Social,” a Sweetie Belle story that explores her relationship to her older sister, Rarity.

It also marks an important first in the history of Friendship is Magic: this is the very first episode of the series in which Twilight Sparkle doesn’t appear. The slight retool back in “Lesson Zero” means that Twilight no longer has to be shoehorned into the action, so for the first time, it’s Rarity and Sweetie Belle who write this week’s letter to Celestia, with an assist from Spike.

We learn quite a bit about Rarity’s family in this episode: you would imagine that her parents were elegant and posh like their oldest daughter is, but you’d be wrong! Cookie Crumbles and Hondo Flanks are instead more like their youngest daughter, down to Cookie being responsible for Sweetie Belle’s… uh… disastrous cooking skills.

This suggests that much of what we see of Rarity is entirely self-invented: she has worked hard to affect the mannerisms of the wealthy and powerful because, if she tried to present herself as an ordinary Ponyvillian, she’d be laughed out of the room – we know from “Green Isn’t Your Color” and other Rarity episodes from season 1 that the world of fashion is big on appearances, and not just on the runway.

To wit: The Mid-Atlantic accent Rarity speaks with is her way of making herself presentable to the movers and shakers of the fashion world, much like George Martin and Patrick Stewart both did in order to get work in the worlds of music and acting. As for how that goes on to affect her career… well, we’ll get to that in “Sweet and Elite.”

“Sisterhooves Social” is largely concerned with Rarity and Sweetie Belle’s difficult relationship with one another, which is put to the test as Sweetie’s various attempts at bonding with Rarity all go spectacularly awry, leading to a furious argument in which the two siblings disown each other ahead of the titular event, an annual tag-team competition for sisters. 

Much of this episode is very relatable for those of us who have younger (or older) siblings – I myself have filled Rarity’s role in the plot more times than I want to admit, even though the gap between me and my younger brother is only four years. In other words, it’s a textbook case of the “Annoying Younger Sibling” trope, and does it ever ring true for me.

On the day of the Social, Sweetie begins the contest by running with Applejack, but then she ends up covered in mud, and it wasn’t until I went back and scrolled slowly through the race scene that I realized the point at which AJ and Rarity switch places. It’s only when Rarity’s horn is exposed near the end that the switch becomes clear to all.

The best thing about this episode for me is the way it plays with Rarity’s Element of Generosity. Sweetie Belle is completely right when she accuses Rarity of being selfish, suggesting activities for them to do together that Sweetie has no interest in. True generosity, as Applejack notes, is about give and take – the making of compromises, as noted in the friendship letter at the end.

I’m not entirely sure AJ’s apple pie analogy completely works, but it makes for a sweet moment in the closing race scenes.


We move along now to “The Cutie Pox,” the second aforementioned CMC episode. This time around, the trio are back at their usual cutie-mark hunting antics, but things take a surprising turn when Apple Bloom ends up coming down with a bad case of the titular disease. She finally earns a cutie mark… and then about a dozen more, performing all the associated talents absolutely perfectly.

It’s important to note that this affliction isn’t random – AB only comes down with it because she commits petty theft by stealing a flower, Heart’s Desire, from Zecora. It isn’t stated directly, but Apple Bloom’s evil grin just before the scene change implies what comes next… or does it? 

I mention this because the trope page for the episode presents an interesting theory under “Alternate Character Interpretation”: “Did Zecora leave Apple Bloom alone with the Heart’s Desire just because she had no reason not to trust Apple Bloom, or was Zecora actually hoping that Apple Bloom would take the Heart’s Desire, for the purposes of teaching her a lesson?”

As with many things in life, it all depends on how you look at it. Personally I like the second option, since it would tie in nicely with Apple Bloom’s earlier complaints about her lack of cutie mark, and refusal to listen to Zecora in the first place when she suggests, multiple times, that good things come to those who wait – which ends up being the final moral at the end. But because it’s the CMC, it’s immediately forgotten about – after all, most of their episodes kind of require it!

The more interesting angle on this episode is the unspoken third lesson: cutie marks are not the be-all end-all, it’s entirely possible to live your life without them and still be happy. Watch how Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo act after they’re kicked out of the bowling alley. They’re just happy to have spent time with each other, earning a cutie mark is entirely secondary. But poor AB is still stuck in the same mindset that she was last season, which this episode could be seen as an attempt to break her out of.

For my part, I’ve always found the idea of cutie marks to be a little strange – they are often quite vague, which can make divining meaning from them a little difficult. “The Cutie Mark Chronicles,” for example, shows us that Rarity’s talent isn’t in fashion design per se, but finding gems, which she then uses in her work as a clothes maker. 

For Apple Bloom, I don’t think it’s literally the lack of a picture on her flank that bothers her, but not knowing what it is she’s meant to do with her life. Look at how happy she is when she thinks she’s earned a cutie mark in loop-de-hooping, only for her to freak out when further cutie marks come along as a result of the disease.

Fortunately, from this episode on, the “we’re going to get our cutie marks in X” angle of CMC episodes gradually drifts away – maybe coming down with the Cutie Pox wasn’t such a bad thing after all?

Next week: A Rainbow Dash duology, though only one of those episodes is any good. 

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑