Equestria Forever: “Hearthswarming Eve/Family Appreciation Day”

Welcome back! While I’ve been lucky in the past few weeks with stories that had at least one pony in common with each other, that streak ends with this week’s pair of episodes… sort of. Instead, both of this week’s episodes center around thankfulness and how certain places were founded – Equestria itself in the first case, and Ponyville in the second.

Our first story, “Hearth’s Warming Eve,” is the second episode of the series to center around the Equestrian version of a holiday, while “Family Appreciation Day” is an Apple Bloom story where, well, she learns to appreciate the many eccentricities of Granny Smith.

“Hearthswarming Eve” is an interesting one, since like “Luna Eclipsed,” it centers on the Equestrian equivalent of a real-life holiday. In the case of the latter, Nightmare Night is pretty transparently inspired by the trappings of modern Halloween celebrations, with some aspects of the original Irish Celtic incarnation of Samhain.

Per Wikipedia: “At Samhain, the Aos Sí were appeased to ensure the people and livestock survived the winter. Offerings of food and drink, or portions of the crops, were left outside for them.” Not so different, then, from the Equestrian customs of leaving candy out to appease Nightmare Moon/Princess Luna, down to the Aos Sí being both respected and feared.

Hearthswarming is a little harder to parse, since at least in this episode, it seems to have elements of American Thanksgiving, as the story presented in the play can be read as a very loose adaptation of the American Thanksgiving myth, since both involve a group of colonists searching for and finding a new home. Which seems a little odd for a show with a predominantly Canadian crew, but then again, some of the descendants of the Pilgrims settled in Canada following the Revolution, bringing American Thanksgiving with them.

Visually though, a lot of the holiday maps onto Christmas, a comparison that becomes increasingly blatant in later episodes: Spike and Twilight are said to hang Hearthswarming dolls on the mantlepiece of the Friendship Castle in “Hearthbreakers,” and the same episode posits that present-opening typically happens on Hearthswarming Day. “A Hearthswarming Tail” from season six does a straight remake of A Christmas Carol, and of course there’s the TV special Best Gift Ever.

Turning to the play itself, I find it interesting how the three rulers of the pony lands (Puddinghead, Hurricane, and Platinum) are portrayed as giant assholes rather than being lionized as we Americans like to do with our founding figures. Obviously some of this is due to needing to sell the play’s ending, but it’s still an interesting contrast compared to real-life hagiographies.

Staying with the theme of founding a new place, remember back in “Winter Wrap Up” when Twilight mentioned that Ponyville had been founded by earth ponies, hence the lack of magic involved in changing from winter to spring? “Family Appreciation Day” reveals that Granny Smith and the rest of the Apple clan at the time are the reason why Ponyville exists in the first place.

Here’s how TVTropes summarizes it:

Before Ponyville was even on the map, Granny Smith was a young filly in a traveling pilgrim caravan. The group would search for seeds from new plants, growing the new and selling the old. One day they came to Canterlot and met none other than Princess Celestia. The princess took in an interest in the group’s seeds and pointed them to a fertile area on the edge of the Everfree Forest where they might put down roots.

Food ran short and the young Granny Smith entered the Everfree Forest in search of something for her family. She discovered the Zap Apple trees and took some of the magical apples but was interrupted by the arrival of (literal) Timber Wolves. Fleeing home, she banged a pot to scare them off. The family planted the seeds of the Zap Apples, which grew quickly enough to provide them with an immediate harvest.

As the years passed, Granny learned the ways of these strange trees and the rituals the apples preferred to get the most out of the harvest. The booming sales of her Zap Apple jam attracted ponies from across Equestria, including Diamond Tiara’s great-grandfather, who made them the foundation of his family business — and thus Ponyville began.

This story ends up being a great big embarrassment for Diamond Tiara, that annoying little filly who’s been bullying the CMC since their first appearance in “Call of the Cutie.” She thinks she’s so much better than everypony else, and it is beyond satisfying to watch her get her comeuppance this time, when she realizes that it’s thanks to the Apples that her family as wealthy as it is.

Other aspects of the episode appeal to me even more now than they did back in 2011. While the Zap Apples themselves are decidedly supernatural in origin, the various deceptively silly things Granny does as part of the harvesting process (my favorite is the one where she acts like a drill sergeant) are all part of an extended ritual working, akin to what real-life witches do when we cast spells.

As an example: when I make coffee for my wife in the mornings, I’ll often charm it to give it some extra pep, using a little incantation I learned early on in my magic studies. There’s also a few little actions I’ll do as part of the spell: stirring the coffee with a spoon while saying the incantation is one (kind of like stirring a cauldron) and the other is taking three deep sniffs afterwards, so the newly-magicked coffee scent fills me with energy.

Might this look strange to outsiders? Probably, but like Granny Smith’s Zap Apple rituals, it all means something! Earth ponies in this show do have magic, it just looks more like the kind of magic I can do as a witch than anything Twilight or Rarity is capable of. It’s not exactly the same, but the resonances are there, and that makes coming back to the show after so many years all the more rewarding.

Next week: Pinkie Pie tries her hoof at babysitting, Applejack learns to tell half-truths and goes from bucking apple trees to cherry trees, and the show courts controversy as a certain muffin-loving mailmare is given a voice as a salute to the fans… and the fans, as they are wont to do, promptly tore them apart.

(Because this is modern fandom, and no one can ever be satisfied by anything. “The Fandom Menace” indeed.)

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑