Equestria Forever: “Baby Cakes/The Last Roundup”

This week, another episode that hits very differently for me now that I’m 31 as opposed when I was 18. Back then, the idea of being a parent was something I wanted no part of: while my parents tried to raise me as well as they could (and largely succeeded) that didn’t mean they were good parents.

Well, okay, that’s unfair. My dad was and is the best dad a girl could possibly ask for! Calm, considerate, thoughtful, and just plain fun to be around – some of my favorite memories of my youth are just me and him driving around singing Beatles songs at the tops of our voices in his ancient ’93 Nissan Altima. Sure, he had his tough moments, but those were very rare. Most of the time, he was laid back and chill. Parenting goals, I’d say.

My mom though… she’s a piece of work. When she was in a good mood, she could be as laid back and chill as my dad, and she liked having fun with her kids. But when she was in a bad mood, things could get tempestuous, to the say the least. Short-tempered, a bit of a narcissist, prone to committing emotional abuse, and as the oldest I got hit with that a lot more than my brother did. 

She was so terrifying to be around that I would go to my dad for pretty much anything and everything, to the point that Mom would have to scream “YOU HAVE TWO PARENTS, [LENA!]” It wasn’t until I moved out in 2023 that she and I were finally able to have a real relationship, because she no longer had the job of raising me.

So, given the mixed results of my childhood, you can probably imagine why 18 year old Lena wanted nothing to do with parenting or even babysitting. I was preternaturally afraid of ending up as a second edition of my mother, and I didn’t want to put myself in that position if I didn’t have to.

Obviously, a lot has changed since then. After four years on feminizing hormones, I’ve been thinking a lot more about parenting and motherhood. Sophie and I have already figured out names for our kids (Prue and Ethan) and even how we’ll approach holidays and stuff like that: they’ll celebrate not just the 8 Wiccan Sabbats, but all the Jewish holidays and maybe even the Muslim ones too. Whatever spiritual path they choose, should they want to, will be theirs to take.

The state of the world in 2026 may be a grim place to raise kids, but one of my witch friends just had a daughter, and my sister-in-law is due near Ostara, so if they can look at the world as it is and still want to bring up children, maybe Sophie, Ariel, and I can too. I hope I am as good at raising them as Mr. and Mrs. Cake are. (At least with two partners to share the job with, I stand a better chance at pulling it off than I would if I was on my own.)

Moving along to “The Last Roundup,” in which the writers come up with what’s probably the best example of the series in the department of ‘AJ Acts Against Her Element.’ Honesty, as a concept, is a little hard to build entire subversion episodes around – generosity is much easier since Rarity’s tendency toward vanity is built into her character, but how are you supposed to do that for a pony who is virtually hard-wired to tell the truth? 

Answer: liberal use of the Exact Words trope: “When the exact wording of a rule, promise, prophecy, etc. matters more than the spirit of the wording.” As the pages notes: “After having her ear talked off by Pinkie, Applejack finally agrees to tell everypony, under a Pinkie Promise, why she can’t go home at breakfast tomorrow. She gets out of it by simply not arriving for breakfast. Miss Jubilee says Applejack won so many ribbons. She isn’t wrong; they’re just not blue.”

This is pretty much the only way you can get AJ subverting her own Element – she tells just enough of the truth to satisfy requirements, but as we all remember from Captain Picard’s big rant in the TNG episode “The First Duty,” a lie of omission is still a lie. That’s part of why Pinkie is so stratospherically angry when AJ breaks her promise.

Unlike the last time we talked about an episode centering on a pony voiced by Ashleigh Ball, AJ actually comes off pretty well here. As we saw in “Applebuck Season,” AJ’s pride is her downfall more often than dishonesty is, perhaps because it’s so much easier for that to be exaggerated into a negative trait than a positive one.

As another example of what I mean, take Dash and loyalty. She is fiercely devoted to making sure AJ comes home safely and getting her to see that it’s not the ribbons that make AJ special, but who AJ herself is as an individual. But in doing so, she leaves Pinkie and Rarity behind, leading to Rarity’s frustrated growl of “I’ll get you for this, Rainbow Dash,” at the end of the episode – a difficult case of divided loyalties, just like in “Return of Harmony.”

For a darker take on that idea, I highly recommend the story To Serve in Hell, which I’ll discuss in greater detail when we get to season five. That story is set in the Nightmare Moon timeline from part 2 of “The Cutie Re-Mark,” and builds upon not only Rarity’s portrayal, but Dash’s as well. 

There, it’s revealed she betrayed her friends and joined up with Nightmare Moon, leading to what we see of her as a guard in the episode, but it’s portrayed as more of an act of survival than anything she wanted to do. She’s still a good pony at heart, it just takes her going through Hell (literally) in order to realize it.

Next week: It’s an episode about the perils of the Industrial Revolution, as Applejack takes a break from learning about her pride (again) to instead learn nothing at all, and Rainbow discovers the joy of reading in a story that really should have featured LeVar Burton, but sadly doesn’t. It’s “The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000” and “Read It and Weep!”

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑