Equestria Forever: “Putting Your Hoof Down/It’s About Time”

This week, it’s another Fluttershy episode, and this time it’s explicitly dedicated to developing her character. Much as I like her, she is perhaps the hardest character of the main cast to write for because, unless she’s dealing with animals, she is so incredibly shy it borders on absurdity more often than not.

While it is true that she can be assertive when the moment calls for it, two of those moments (“Dragonshy” and “Stare Master”) involve interacting with non-equine beings, and the most recent (“The Return of Harmony”) was mainly because Twilight and the others successfully goaded her into it so she could chase down a corrupted Rainbow Dash.

Outside of those occasions, Fluttershy is an appalling doormat, but to her credit she has the presence of mind to realize it and figure out she needs to do something about it. The problem isn’t that she’s gone to a self-help seminar, the problem is that the person holding the seminar, a guy named Iron Will, is giving her terrible advice that she then proceeds to act upon, turning her into… well, a non-Discorded version of Flutterbitch, to use an old fandom term for her Discorded self.

The trope for this is called “Jumping Off the Slippery Slope,” where a character makes a sudden and dramatic personality change at the drop of a hat with absolutely no room for ambiguity or nuance in between. But the thing is, Shy pulls this off twice in opposite directions – she goes from being a doormat to a bitch and then to being too terrified to even interact with others, particularly her friends.

What saves her in the end is none other than Iron Will himself. Realizing she hasn’t paid him for his services, he goes to see Fluttershy and asks for his money. She replies that she will not be paying him because, as per a clause in the advertising for his seminar, she would get her money back if she wasn’t 100% satisfied, and she wasn’t. Iron Will accepts that, and leaves without a fuss.

Thankfully, the lesson she learns in this episode does eventually stick – later in the series, the writers will find more things for her to do that don’t involve being a sentient doormat, particularly in season 9 – probably her best one, in my humble opinion. But that’s not to say the shift is immediate, as we’ll explore next week when we tackle “Hurricane Fluttershy.”

For now though, let’s turn our attention to our second episode of the week, “It’s About Time” – otherwise known as Lena’s favorite Twilight episode. Hell, I might even go out on a limb and say it’s one of my favorite episode of the entire series! Part of this is because the lesson Twilight learns is something I’ve struggled with all the time, but also because it contains Maximum Bookhorse and it involves time travel. And it’s written by M.A. Larson, the scribe behind “Luna Eclipsed” and “The Return of Harmony.”

Let’s start with the time travel. Back in 2012 when this episode first aired, I was still living and breathing Doctor Who, and obviously that show is entirely about time travel and, in the Moffat era particularly, whether or not time can be rewritten. This is a matter of particular concern during the Eleventh Doctor’s era, since it comes up in different contexts in each of his three season finales and his penultimate episode as the incumbent, “The Day of the Doctor.”

Those episodes, though, are primarily concerned with retroactive changes to the timeline, be it saving Gallifrey while appearing to destroy it or the various attempts at undoing the Doctor’s day-saving escapades. “It’s About Time” is dealing with a time travel trope that is often discussed but always dismissed on Doctor Who – the possibility of changing the future by preventing a terrible event from occurring.

Twilight believes that if she’s able to solve the puzzle of what her future self was trying to tell her, she’ll be able to prevent the Bad Future she assumes is coming – “an epic pony war,” specifically. In the end though, all Twilight manages to accomplish is the creation of a stable time loop: in trying to prevent the future from happening, she ends up becoming Future Twilight, leading her to go back in time to warn her past self about what not to do… and of course, Past Twilight is too busy babbling excitedly to listen.

Of course, those of us who watch a lot of Doctor Who (as I was doing at that point in time) could’ve seen this coming a mile away. Stable time loops are something of a hallmark for the series, and again, they recur quite frequently in the Moffat era – his period of the show was heavy on narratives that dealt with time travel both as plot device and on a more conceptual level.

Around the period “It’s About Time” aired, we Who fans were still a few months out from the premiere of what turned out to be Smith’s final season of the Doctor, and his entire era, we would discover, is nothing less than a giant stable time loop all by itself.

As Eleven notes in The Time of the Doctor, “You can’t change history once you’re part of it,” which gets at another reason why Twilight’s gambit failed. The appearance of Future Twilight, to borrow some Who lingo, is a fixed point in time – it can’t be rewritten, no matter what anyone tries to do, and attempts to do so will always end in failure.

Well, almost always – as we learn in “The Wedding of River Song” and “The Day of the Doctor,” it turns out that you can change fixed points, provided that on the surface level, events proceed as they’re supposed to: the Doctor still appears to die on the beach in Utah, because it’s actually a robot duplicate and not the actual Doctor. But of course, none of that applies to “It’s About Time,” I just thought I’d mention it.

Anyway: “It’s About Time” is a fabulous early series MLP episode, and as I said above, one of my favorites from the entire series. But as we’ll explore when we get to season five, this won’t be the last time Best Pony stars in an episode about time travel and the ramifications of altering fixed points in time.

Or, as River Song would say: “Spoilers.”

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑