This week, a surprise! A Spike episode that doesn’t suck! It’s “Dragon Quest,” written by Merriwether Williams, and it gives us our first glimpse into pony-dragon relations vis-a-vis young Spike, who desires to find out more about where he came from, so he decides to join the dragon migration that just happens to be occurring.
Unfortunately for Spike, the only dragons who pay attention to him are a group of total jerks led by a teenager named Garble. They treat him like a college freshman trying to join a fraternity by hazing him and generally insulting him like every high school bully you’ve ever seen on TV, forcing him to do various activities that Spike, being so young, can’t do as well as his much larger fellow dragons can. (But they chalk it up to Spike being raised by ponies instead.)
Events culminate with Spike being led to the nest of a family of phoenixes, where he is instructed to distract the parents so the other dragons can steal the eggs. Spike does so, but the newly-hatched baby phoenixes turn the tables on the teen dragons and scare them off, though they eventually manage to find Spike and the unhatched egg left lying on the ground. Then this happens:
“Clump”: Well, what are you waiting for, Spike? Smash it!
Spike: Smash the egg?
“Clump”: Yeah!
Fume: Yeah, throw it on the ground as hard as you can!
Teenage dragons: Yeah! Smash it! Smash it! Smash it! Smash it! Smash it!
Spike: No! It’s just a defenseless egg, like I was! And I’m not gonna let you hurt it!
Garble: What did you say?
Spike: I said no.
FINALLY, someone figures out how to write a decent Spike episode! And the answer, it turns out, is to essentially write Spike into being a character similar to Worf on Star Trek: The Next Generation. Like Spike, Worf was raised by another species, has little experiential knowledge of his own kind, and on the very rare occasions where we see him among other members of their respective species, Spike and Worf don’t fit in at all.
In the two-part episode “Redemption,” Worf spends much of part 2 serving on a Klingon vessel commanded by his brother Kurn, and finds himself a bit thrown off when Kurn spends a scene drinking with the enemy, much to Worf’s befuddlement. Our boy believes that all Klingons are just as principled, disciplined, and honorable as he is, so it’s no surprise that after spending the entire episode realizing how wrong he is, Worf decides to go back to the Enterprise instead.
Spike goes through much the same thing in “Dragon Quest,” but in his case it’s even worse than Worf because Worf, at least, had decades of Federation-Klingon relations to read through and learn from. Spike doesn’t even have that much! As Twilight says, “It’s hard to believe, but ponies know next to nothing about dragons. Apparently they’re too rare and too scary to try to talk to or study!”
So all he has to go on is first-hoof (or rather, first-claw) experience, but the whole debacle sours him on dragon culture to such a degree that for the remainder of the series, his interactions with dragons as a whole are rather limited – it’s not until early season six that we have another “Dragon Culture” plot line, with the episode “Gauntlet of Fire.”
So why does this showcase episode for Spike succeed where all his other ones (at least so far) have failed? For the simple reason that where “Owl’s Well That Ends Well” and “Secret of My Excess” had to exaggerate or otherwise invent aspects of Spike’s characterization that clash with how he’s written 99% of the time, in this episode we get to see Spike as he is – the twist is who he spends his time with. He gets treated with respect by the writers here in a way that he just isn’t in other episodes.
(Notably, “Gauntlet of Fire” pulls the same trick, after an even longer string of terrible Spike episodes. It’s also the next time we see Garble, who goes on to appear periodically in the final third of the show.)
Next up, Fluttershy versus her own self-confidence issues again in “Hurricane Fluttershy,” an episode title that sounds like it’s an oxymoron. After all, hurricanes are enormously destructive storms that can produce spectacular amounts of wind and rain, and Fluttershy (in)famously has trouble dealing with an assholic cherry sales pony.
But! It turns out that this episode has a connection to the previous one – bullying, and poor Fluttershy being a victim of it (again) just as she was in “The Cutie Mark Chronicles” last season. This time it centers on her inability to fly very well: her wings are so weak that she has a far smaller wing power rating than the average pegasus, even after training like Rocky Balboa.
Needless to say, that history renders her practically catatonic when it comes time for her to help the rest of Ponyville’s pegasi deliver water to Cloudsdale. But during the climax, with many stronger pegasus ponies falling out of formation like flies, it turns out that if Shy is pushed past her limits, she can save the day – just like in “The Return of Harmony,” when she’s successfully goaded into capturing a Discorded Rainbow Dash.
Speaking of whom, the other pegasus in the mane cast has her best showing yet this week, toning down her usual brash approach with Fluttershy in favor of a kinder, gentler version that successfully illustrates exactly why she was made Bearer of Loyalty back in the pilot. As the trope page notes, “After spending most of the second season as an abrasive Leeroy Jenkins, this episode pivots Rainbow Dash’s Character Development into a gentler, more selfless figure.”
And frankly, about damn time! Season two is downright rough on Rainbow, so it’s nice to see that as the season nears the finale, the writers are finally starting to figure out how to write for her in a way that stays true to the best of what her character can be, rather than making her out to be a complete jerk jock.
Next time: The CMC become gossip-mongers, and Pinkie and Twilight attempt to solve a mystery on a train in the Obligatory Agatha Christie Pastiche, only this time there aren’t any murders. (Because this is a kid’s show.)
Leave a Reply