Our final CMC episode of the season is one that I don’t think rates particularly highly among the fandom, but I personally kind of like it. In this one, the CMC go to work for Ponyville Elementary’s school newspaper, which also seems to serve as Ponyville’s main newspaper, since its circulation seems to be quite wide. As a one-time newspaperwoman myself, I can respect enterprising young journalists!
And let’s be real, the Foal Free Press seems like a much more put together outfit than my middle school’s paper ever was. Certainly, ponies actually read it, whereas I’m not sure anyone read my terrible book and album reviews in my school’s newspaper. But we all have to start somewhere, don’t we?
In any event, much of the episode centers around not just the CMC being journalists, but very specifically gossip columnists. Hilariously, something seemed to be in the air in March 2011, because the exact same subject was covered by Duran Duran on their album All You Need is Now. Track 9, “Other People’s Lives,” has lyrics that are surprisingly apropos for this episode:
Selling exes’ down the river
Every Katie’s got her price
And the details make you shiver
But it’s hard to escape
When your head is stuck in vice
Because nothing matters
In the self-obsession age
Where they dare you not to notice
But it’s everywhere
In shocking colour on the page
In the magazine
(It’s in the magazine)
Staring out at me
(Staring out at me)
Out of my TV
Other people’s lives
Pixelated lives
Just like yours and mine
Sure enough, the citizens of Ponyville prove to be just as susceptible to the puerile pleasures of gossip, or at least as much as can be shown in a cartoon show for children. But it all goes horribly wrong when Diamond Tiara gets way over her skis and demands the CMC continue to try and find more dirt to throw on the townsfolk, completely overruling their desire to stop. (And there’s blackmail involved, because of course there is.)
The end result? Literally everyone in Ponyville collectively shames the CMC into stopping their gossip column for good, and Cheerilee finally gets around to doing her job and deposes Diamond Tiara as editor-in-chief. What took her so long, I can only imagine.
This one got a decidedly mixed reception from the fandom. As the trope page puts it: “Fans are divided on the scene where the CMC are shunned by the whole town once their identities get found out somehow, whether everypony’s reaction believable or not, and more so, whether it was justified or hurtful.”
Personally I err on the former, but I can see the latter. As an episode, while I wouldn’t call it the best CMC episode ever, it’s still pretty good – for crying out loud, there are jokes in here that reference Citizen Kane and freaking Julius Caesar. How can you not like an episode with those kinds of pop culture references?!
And speaking of pop culture references that punch way above FIM’s weight class, our second episode of the week returns the focus to the mane six, specifically Pinkie and Twilight. In the episode, the two of them are forced to figure out who could’ve taken big bites out of the Marzipan Mascarpone Meringue Madness, the Cakes’ submission in Equestria’s National Dessert Competition.
In a twist, Pinkie is the one who dons the deerstalker cap for the obligatory Sherlock Holmes pastiche, which is very funny given that plot-wise, everything about this story is a great big Agatha Christie shoutout, aside from the lack of murders. Her “deductions” turn out to be comically wrong, but on the plus side we get plenty of pop culture references from the animation department, from silent movies of the early 1920s to Ninja films.
My personal favorite has to be her casting of Donut Joe as “Con Mane,” the Equestrian answer to James Bond. (Complete with a gunbarrel sequence.) It’s the only time this comes up, but that didn’t stop the fandom from doing a massive expansion on the idea – the very old JohnPerry series on FIMFiction, beginning with Mission Implausible, presents Con Mane as a real pony and a villain.
In the end though, it’s Twilight who gets to be the real great detective, though attentive viewers can probably figure it out long before she does. The solution to the initial mystery is revealed not to have been any of the chefs, but Rainbow, Fluttershy, and Rarity!
Per the trope page: “The MMMM is apparently so good that three members of the Mane Six went against their Elements of Harmony just to taste it. Rainbow Dash (Element of Loyalty) betrays a friend’s trust, Fluttershy (Element of Kindness) goes behind said friend’s back and takes something from her without asking and Rarity (Element of Generosity) steals something for selfish reasons.”
And without even being discorded first! Which is, now that I think of it, a fitting bookend to the season, since it started with the mane six having their respective elements get turned around on them. It just goes to show: just because you’re an Element of Harmony doesn’t mean that you’re immune to, as the Weird Al song “Amish Paradise” puts it, sin and vice.
While this isn’t the first time that we’ve discussed Agatha Christie shoutouts on the blog, (see: “The Unicorn and the Wasp” in The RTD Rewind) unlike that aforementioned story, this one really does work as a mystery story in both the Christie and Holmesian fashions: as in Christie’s work, the viewer is presented with various clues so they can solve the mystery along with Twilight and Pinkie, but the final summation (and the shorter mystery which follows) is pure Holmes.
The clues, for those of you who missed them:
When Pinkie runs down to the caboose, Rainbow Dash’s mane style is visible in silhouette.
Next, in the engine car, the “conductor” uses a female pony model and a yellow ear is seen. These put together mean Fluttershy.
Finally, much easier to spot is after the blinds are shut, the picture gains an eyelash and Rarity starts wearing her mane to cover one eye.
The shades were also closed simultaneously, with no visible figure, indicating magic and thus a unicorn.
This is what I love about this show – where else can you get a mystery story that not only works for the target audience, it’s a solid adventure for adults too, without condescending to anyone? It’s a hard nut to crack, but Amy Keating Rogers is more than up to the task.
Next week, the big finale! So big that for the first time ever, they aired both parts on the same day! It’s A Canterlot Wedding.
Leave a Reply