Wolf Trek: Allegiance

Captain’s log, stardate 81424.7: Picard is kidnapped and deposited in a laboratory maze with three other captives, while a replica of the Captain begins to wreak havoc with the crew of the Enterprise, leaving Riker no choice but mutiny.


This week, Captain Picard finds himself as an unwilling participant in a social deduction game put on by a couple of aliens who wish to study the importance of leadership among lower lifeforms. That’s right, folks, our intrepid captain ends up playing what amounts to Mafia, Among Us, or Werewolf, minus the whole “executing innocents during the day phase” thing.

As with “The Offspring” from a couple weeks ago, this episode was written as a ‘bottle show’ with only one new set – the prison cell that Picard and his fellow captives are kept in for the A-plot. It’s also a character-driven piece, allowing Stewart the opportunity to stretch his acting muscles both by playing Picard, and the alien doppelgänger impersonating him, who does things like put his feet up on his ready room desk and sing sea shanties in Ten Forward.

What I want to focus on, though, is the social deduction game that makes up the main plot of the storyline. There are four prisoners – Haro, a Bolian Academy cadet, Tholl, and Esoqq. They are in a rat’s maze designed to test their response to authority. Picard is a natural leader, Haro a natural follower, Tholl a natural opportunist, and Esoqq a natural anarchist.

What I really like about this episode, in particular, is the relationship between Haro and Picard. For much of the episode, she’s the closest thing Picard has to a true ally, since as a cadet she’s trained to follow the orders of a superior officer – in this case, Picard himself. His instinctive need to give orders to her, and the other two prisoners, ends up briefly working against him when Esoqq and Tholl start suspecting him as being the impostor.

But then Haro, who has otherwise been a picture perfect Academy cadet all this time, makes reference to a recent Enterprise mission (Mintaka III, back in “Who Watches the Watchers”) and this episode’s conflict, which surrounds the Enterprise’s top secret plague-curing mission. This has the effect of giving herself away, and Picard swiftly unmasks her as the real impostor, ending the experiment and freeing everyone else.

Per Michael Piller, having this be a Picard-centered episode was the intent from the word go: “We wanted to come up with some real fun for both Patrick the actor and Jean-Luc the character, so we came up with this idea. It might have been two ideas put into one. One was Picard gets stuck in a no-exit situation, and a false Picard takes his place on the Enterprise. I loved the stuff on the Enterprise, wonderful character stuff and Patrick was wonderful.”

If you know me very well, then you know that I love a good social deduction game, and they’ve taken off quite a bit in the last few years – there was the aforementioned Among Us craze in the 2010s, and the British series The Traitors has become a worldwide phenomenon, with international remakes in over 30 different countries. Even Trek itself has gotten in on the act, with most of the SNW episode “A Space Adventure Hour” centering on a holodeck murder mystery.

But for me, when I think of social deduction games, I always think of Werewolf. In fact, the very first time I watched this episode back in 2022, I was a few days out from an installment where, just as in the episode, a Starfleet officer was accused of being a villainous ghost, rather than the innocent noble she appeared to be.

The game was set in a haunted castle, and Gemini found herself marooned there by Q, as part of a test to see how she fared without a crew of trained officers to work with. Her first move was to quickly put together a ragtag crew of other nobles – Agatha, Aífe, and Artoria. 

Artoria possessed a secret power called Queen of the Underworld, defined as an unreliable seer role. If Artoria inspected a noble, she would be told that she found a Ghost, unless they inspect a Ghost, in which case there is a 50% chance that they will be told that they’ve found a Noble. On night two, she chose to check Gem, and when dawn broke the next morning, was informed that the seemingly gallant captain was, in fact, a ghost.

Of course, Gem was actually innocent the whole time. But even so, she was accused and executed on the third game day, with the truth coming out only after she died. Happily though, she was revived on night four, allowing me the chance to bring her back and rally the nobles to victory once and for all. It was a wonderful storyline, and to this day it remains among my favorites of all twelve games I’ve played or run.

I had so much fun with that game that a few months later, I started tossing around ideas for what became Mirror Broken, the fifth installment of my own series of Werewolf games, which finally got played in February 2026. I knew, with episodes like “Allegiance” as proof, that Star Trek could actually work quite well when applied to this kind of situation. After all, having seemingly good officers suddenly turn out to be villains is a franchise tradition at this point.

I think what makes Trek themed Werewolf games work (such as the ones I’ve run over the past couple years) is that you have an opportunity to play with and subvert the Roddenberry utopia that the Federation, and Starfleet, have historically been presented as. There’s just something incredibly thrilling about inverting that dynamic that I like, and outside of Werewolf, it’s even led to some great story arcs.

And that, for me, is the best thing about Werewolf for me: the games I’ve been involved with have always had great roleplay and storytelling, and when I started running my own games back in 2024, it was decided to put RP at the center of everything. Collaborative storytelling has always been one of my favorite things, and just as with TV shows, you can go to all sorts of places – the only limit is your imagination.

Next week: More Picard action as Starfleet’s resident total workaholic finally takes a vacation, only to find himself thrown into an archaeological mystery.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑