Captain’s log, stardate 81463.3: The Enterprise is called on to transport first-contact specialist Tam Elbrun to Beta Strongrem to make initial contact with an alien life form. However, things go disastrously wrong when Romulan attackers show up and the Beta Strongrem sun goes supernova.
The adaptation, usually, is a way to experience a story you love through a different medium. Netflix’s A Series of Unfortunate Events TV series gave novelist Daniel Handler an opportunity to not only re-adapt his own work (because the 2004 film with Jim Carrey never amounted to much) but to revise aspects of it to make the series more cohesive, such as incorporating VFD into the events of the first four novels.
Another form of adaptation is to take a piece of fanfic and transform it into something wholly original. This happened to me a few years ago, when I chose to adapt one of my old New Endeavours stories into something set in the universe of Arcbeatle’s Starcatcher series.
It was one of the best experiences I’ve ever had as a writer, and I am proud to say that the end result became so popular that J. Wylder formally pitched me on doing a whole series in that mode, as a sequel series to Starcatcher. The end result was Starlight Endeavours, which you may have seen if you’ve read some of our recent seasonal anthologies.
“Tin Man,” essentially, is the process I took with moving from Star Trek to Starlight only in reverse order: the original thing instead becomes an episode of a franchise thing. (Only because it’s on TV, it isn’t fanfic.) According to Memory Alpha, “Writers Dennis Putman Bailey, David Bischoff, and Lisa Putman White based this episode on a short story titled “Tin Woodman” that Bailey and Bischoff wrote in 1976. It was first published in the December 1976 issue of Amazing Stories and served as the basis of a novel of the same name published by Doubleday in 1979.”
Just over a decade later, it became an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, entirely because the writers hated “Samaritan Snare” and thought they could do better, and went about doing exactly that, down to putting most of the story focus on a character of their own creation rather than any of the regulars.
Glimpsed in that light, as someone who’s done many an adaptation over the years, “Tin Man” becomes far more interesting than I first thought back in 2022, when I watched it for the first time. It centers around this guy, Tam, another Betazoid like Troi, but where she can only read emotions, he can read everyone’s minds at all times… except, as established, Data. Being an android, he’s a complete blank slate, so Tam gets on best with him for much of the story.
TV Tropes explains in greater detail what exactly his problem is: “Tam Elbrun was born with his abilities active and on a level beyond other Betazoids, and thus has been assaulted by the thoughts of others since he was born. Even with early diagnosis and training, he never learned to shut them out properly. The stress sent him to hospitals throughout his life, and he mentions to Troi that the thoughts of the few thousand people on the Enterprise alone feels like a tide that might swallow him up.”
Well, fuck, dude! No wonder you spend much of the episode acting so rude that you make Malcolm Tucker from The Thick of It look cuddly! He’s searching for “Tin Man,” seemingly a living ship that has been orbiting a collapsing star, but all subspace attempts at communications have failed.
Complicating matters is the presence of the Romulans, who are also interested in Tin Man, but only insofar as they can deny the Federation a chance at establishing first contact… mainly by destroying it. After spending much of the season seeing TNG try to put the Romulans in a new light, it’s kind of a drag to see them stuffed back into the role of aggressor again.
But then! Out comes Tam with a completely insane idea: merging his mind with that of Tin Man’s, so they can form a symbiotic relationship of the kind that you hear about all the time in high school biology. Unfortunately, the plan works too well – Tin Man is really big, after all, and Tam is only a mortal. Data volunteers to anchor him, and they go aboard Tin Man together.
Then this happens:
(Tam is in the chair, and a viewscreen opens in front of him. He looks blissful)
TAM: Explain to them. Make them understand.
DATA: But our mission
TAM: Is to save Tin Man. And I will. But he’s going to save me as well. All my life I have waited for this. A chance to find peace. Finally all the voices are silent. Only Tin Man speaks to me now. Don’t you see, Data? This is where I belong.
It’s an interesting thing, becoming one with something much larger than yourself. You really do have to work on finding a balance, as Tam does with Tin Man, so that you’re not overwhelmed by the immensity of everything. The question is, what drives such people to do this kind of thing?
There’s a trope for this called Mental Fusion: Two or more characters willingly create a Psychic Link in order to do amazing things. We all remember the 2008 Doctor Who episode “Journey’s End,” where Donna Noble essentially pulls exactly this maneuver by accident, becoming a human/Time Lord hybrid… which turns out to be really bad when she nearly risks dying because a Gallifreyan mind is too much for a human one to handle.
Fortunately, she gets better in the 2023 story The Star Beast, regaining all her memories of her travels with the Doctor
Fittingly, Data himself uses it in the third season of Picard: “It turns out that the Daystrom Station is holding a techo-organic version of the Soong Android. As this creation has multiple different versions over the years, they are loaded with the personalities of all of them: Data, Lore, B_4, and Lal, the daughter Data programmed.”
“The two strongest personalities, Data and Lore, vie for control. It looks like Lore wins, but Data actually surrenders his memories to Lore and turns Lore into Data. The end result is mostly Data, a good man, but with a bit of Lore’s dark and sarcastic sense of humour.”
As to why, perhaps it varies from person to person. One might wish to try and better understand a complicated being so different from themselves, while another (like Tam) simply realizes that he can give Tin Man a reason to live, and in return, he gets some much-needed peace and quiet.
One thing’s for sure: given the opportunity to look at the world through different eyes, who wouldn’t say yes?
Leave a Reply