Wolf Trek: Hollow Pursuits (feat. Freezing Inferno)

Captain’s log, stardate 81482.4: Reginald Barclay neglects his duties in favor of spending time on the holodeck, where he has constructed programs simulating members of the crew. When the senior crew of learns of Barclay’s holo-addiction, he must come to terms that he has a problem.


Hello readers! I got a special treat for you this week: longtime friend of the blog Freezing Inferno is here to discuss their least favorite episode of TNG, season 3’s “Hollow Pursuits!” It was the debut story for one Lieutenant Reginald Barclay, everyone’s favorite nebbish diagnostics engineer. He will go on to have supporting roles in various TNG episodes, appearing in every season bar the fifth, and a recurring role in the back half of VOY.

Much as I like the idea of Barclay, even I have to admit that this episode doesn’t really work very well as an intro story for him. It feels very much like he was introduced specifically to be bullied by the regulars, in particular William Riker and Geordi La Forge. Thank Danu for Captain Picard, ever the voice of reason as always. (True, there is the slip-up in the bridge scene, but that was plainly an accident.)

When I first saw this episode, I disliked it so much that I decided to rewrite it, with the Barclay stand-in as an ex-Borg drone who is trying to remember how to act like a human again. My chief engineer, rather than being distrustful of Violet, is instead supportive of her – the exact opposite of Geordi’s behavior in the original. If I could do it in the Year of the Goddess 2022, what excuse did the original TNG staff have in 1990? None at all, IMO.

But enough of my rambling! Here now is Frez to explain why, in detail, why they hate this episode so much. Take it away, Frez!


When I was about six years old, one holiday season my parents decided to tape a bunch of Christmas cartoon specials onto a VHS to appease me. I still have that tape and cherish it to this day, and it’s filled with all the usual content you’d expect: The Grinch, Charlie Brown, Frosty The Snowman, et cetera. One of the more curious inclusions was an obscure 80’s Canadian special called Bluetoes. It focuses on the elves of Santa Claus preparing for the holiday, the chief protagonist among them being a small child elf known only as Small One. Every other Christmas elf at the North Pole is annoyed by the poor performance of Small One, and his propensity to get into hijinks and mischief that set back the grand operations of giving toys to children all over the world at Christmas time. They express such in scenes where Small One is not around, constantly complaining and griping about what a hassle this little guy is, and often sending him off on time-wasting errands cooked up solely to get him out of their hair due to their dislike of him. 

I never much cared for Bluetoes as a child. It was my least favorite of the cartoons on this tape, and I would have much preferred to watch something like A Garfield Christmas. At that age, however, I wasn’t able to quantify exactly why I had a dislike for this cartoon. Years later, coming back to it on a nostalgic holiday binge of childhood gone by, it clicked for me. All the other elves put on this public facade of being nice to him and giving him Big Boy Errands, but in secret they harbor great contempt for him. It’s this exact element that stuck in my craw. Why? Because, dear reader, I am a tightly wound ball of anxiety molded in the shape of a functioning human being. The anxious comes in many forms, but this was one of the paranoid overexaggerations of my childhood: the idea that I was being talked about behind my back, that everyone who pretended to like me secretly held deep-rooted contempt for me, that if I were to die the next day there would be celebrations over no longer having to deal with me. (I’m doing much better now, so don’t worry, folks!) It’s irrational and overblown, but that’s just how anxiety is: a nebulous little brain goblin that takes root in your head and causes you to fuss and worry over every little thing to catastrophic detail.

What do you think happened a decade and a half later, then, when I was cruising along with Star Trek: The Next Generation for the very first time, and hit upon this episode? I hated it. I hated it precisely because it took those ridiculous overthinking fears and validated them. Here is a man not unlike me, this Lt. Reg Barclay. A tightly wound ball of anxiety molded in the shape of a functioning human being. A nervous and stammering introvert who retreats into a world of his own making due to his worries about how he is perceived, and how his coworkers treat him. What does the episode of television decide to do with the utopian and understanding crew of the starship Enterprise? It proves his worries right. Criticizing him behind his back, plotting to pawn him off to another starship and musing that perhaps they also did the same to get this burden, this waste of space out of their hair, and even calling him names. A name invented by that young upstart, Wesley Crusher. Broccoli. They call him Broccoli behind his goddamn back as they talk about how much they’re fed up with him, how much of a headache and a hassle this introverted loser is, and how much better they’ll sleep at night if they transfer him off the ship and make him somebody else’s problem.

This right here? This is my least favorite episode of TNG. I am fully aware that does not mean “the worst”: for goodness’ sakes, Code Of Honor exists and is an offensive pile of poor decisions. When I say it is my least favorite, I mean it offends me on a personal level. This is an episode of television that mirrors me, reflects the deepest and most sympathetic of my insecurities back at me upon the screen, and then points and laughs at it. Look at the misfit loser who can’t fit in. He sucks so much! I hate him! Get him off the ship! And just look at his stupid dumb Holodeck fantasy! He’s cringe! Cringe at the loser, gang! What an idiot!

That was my initial impression of Hollow Pursuits. It made a goddamn mockery of people like me, it could go rot, and I would never watch it again. Nine years is a long time, and I can’t resist a good exorcism. So I came back and watched the forbidden episode again today. The experience was… an interesting one. Over 45 minutes I felt as if I were in the middle of an emotional tug of war, pulled back and forth between two extremes. The first is the sentiment I expressed above, the metaphorical pointing and laughing at how cringe Reg Barclay is. The second, however, was only visible through hindsight. I mentioned that the one and only time I viewed Hollow Pursuits before today was on my first watchthrough of TNG. With the benefit of knowing what’s coming for Reg, I could see something different brewing: the typical utopian empathy and understanding that makes this show sing for me, usually.

It’s most present for Barclay in a later episode, season 6’s Realm Of Fear. That episode feels like the polar opposite to this, and is one of my favorites of the show because of how well it sympathizes with Barclay. His anxiousness over transporting is one that the crew helps him grapple and deal with in a mature and understanding way, his anxiety over having transporter psychosis is extremely relatable (at one point he basically uses the computer as a 24th century Web MD to determine if he’s terminal or not), and he ends up saving the day at the end. Very charming, very delightful. With that lens in mind, I can see the glimmers of this showing up in Hollow Pursuits. It’s most notable in the scene in Ten Forward where Guinan gives Geordi advice on how to sympathize and ease Barclay into working better with the crew, and kindly but firmly dismisses his assumptions about Barclay being a weirdo (“If I felt like nobody wanted to be around me, I’d be late and nervous too”). There is an empathy at play after the first few uncomfortable minutes, and people like Geordi and Troi begin to understand what makes Barclay so nervous and introverted, and try their very best to get him to come out of his shell and mesh better with everyone as part of the Enterprise family. Even the name calling gets addressed early on, with Picard immediately saying to cut it out, and Geordi doing the same after Data questions why they call him that if it’s not meant to be endearing. Moments like this made me realize I was being a little harsh on Hollow Pursuits, given how intensely relatable I found Barclay and how much deep hurting this gossip brought back up in me. They are trying to help him, just like they will in later episodes.

On the other hand, repeatedly over the runtime of the episode, every one of these moments gets undercut by pulling us back to the other side, by making Barclay our anxious little circus performer to be made the object of fun. It felt like I was in the middle of an emotional tug of war, pulled between sweet utopic moments of understanding Barclay and moments where the point is that he’s cringe. The whiplash has me disoriented, and I think the episode has its heart in the right place when it comes to Barclay, but it just indulges itself in these moments of secondhand embarrassment that bring all those awful feelings I have as an anxious mess back to the forefront.

We haven’t even touched on Barclay’s coping mechanism for dealing with his anxious introversion, and the fact that the right words never come to him while dealing with briefings and his day-to-day job as an Enterprise engineer. He retreats into a land of pure imagination, rendering his coworkers as Holodeck constructs so that he can truly express himself, be the brave boy he wishes he can be, and decompress from his stresses. As before with the emotional tug of war, the episode is divided on how ethically sound this is. Geordi of all people is sympathetic when he discovers Barclay’s secret, due to his own understanding of the feelings the Holodeck can draw out with the Leah Brahms avatar from Booby Trap. (Another episode of TNG I will never watch is Galaxy’s Child, because the last thing I need is an episode that tears down one of my other favorite episodes in order to point and laugh at the long-suffering Geordi LaForge and call him a weirdo too.) On the other hand, you have how Riker and Troi react to seeing their fantasy selves in the Holodeck, in a scene that causes me immense psychic damage. The joke where Troi expresses that this is all healthy and we shouldn’t be offended before getting steamed at seeing her own fantasy self wounds me greatly. You’re taking that wellspring of empathy and turning it into a punchline so we can laugh at Barclay again. Stop it.

And yet, I have to admit that the episode has a point, even if it’s making it accidentally. Barclay is ostensibly using this as a way to vent the feelings he can’t express due to being an introvert, to create avatars of the crew so he can say what he feels without hurting the feelings of the real people. Making up a holo-Wesley so he can say something like “Hey, I really didn’t appreciate being talked over in that briefing”. Instead, as the cold open shows, we get this disturbing fantasy where Barclay becomes the strong boy pushing around and bullying the senior officers with his confidence and swagger, and getting the girl while he’s at it. These fantasies are not healthy, especially when they involve real people like this. Sure, maybe in passing you’ve had an errant fantasy about a friend or coworker in your life. But you keep that to yourself, and in your imagination. Barclay is kind of doing this, but he’s also doing it on a public Holodeck where anyone can just walk in and see it. Your thoughts about the people in your life are your own business, but you can’t just go and AI render up anything you want about the real people in your life. There ought to be a regulation against that, both in Starfleet and the real world. It just makes Barclay look really bad, and only compounds to the mockery of him which spikes my blood pressure when I have to deal with it.

There’s an episode of Voyager, Author Author, which also deals with this in a way. The EMH makes a holodeck novel about a brave holographic doctor who has to deal with the crew of his starship treating him like garbage. Every other character is blatantly inspired by one of the other senior officers on Voyager, and the Doctor’s limp defense is “Oh that isn’t you, it’s just a fictional character inspired by you!”. Which, come the actual hell on. If I made up a story in which someone named Sheena MacJeer came across as a complete and utter jerk, I’d rightly be told off by the cool and talented person who is letting me write these words for what I was doing. No, kids. Don’t make holographic representations of real people you know and then exaggerate them for comedic effect. Thankfully, Barclay’s dependence on the holographic world to express himself is helped by the end of the episode as he says goodbye to his titular Hollow Pursuits.

That still doesn’t mean I like this episode. Far from it. I am emotionally drained after viewing it a second time, and still do not count it among my favorites. I could tell you to just go watch Realm Of Fear or some of the Voyager episodes in which Reg Barclay reappears to help communicate with the stranded ship, but since our dear webhost said I can do as much as I like… Let’s engage in a little alchemy over here. Let’s play the game of narrative substitution.

Let me tell you about Bocchi The Rock!, and how it is a better story than Hollow Pursuits in every way.

Bocchi The Rock! is a manga and anime in the popular “girl band” genre, in which the primary draw is watching cute anime girls form a band together and get into various comedic hijinks while hanging out. For our purposes, we are discussing this show because of its protagonist, Hitori Gotoh. Hitori is both a talented guitar player and a girl suffering from extreme social anxiety. She overthinks everything, is constantly in a panic about making the most of her youth before it all wastes away in an introverted slump of making no meaningful connections, and frequently engages in elaborate (and uniquely animated) doom fantasies in which she assumes the worst case scenario of people shunning her or her own ostracization from society for daring to not conform to extroverted norms. 

Here’s the kicker: this portrayal of an anxious pink blob freaking out is someone we are supposed to laugh with, not at. We see these ridiculous fantasy sequences, or Hitori turning into a bouncing animated smear of pink while screeching like a pterodactyl at the thought of Being Perceived On Social Media, and the joke is on how ridiculous anxiety is, not Hitori. Moreover, she has friends and mentors who love and support her. When she’s not around and they discuss her, it’s not to gossip behind her back about how much of a burden she and her crippling anxiety are. It’s a genuine concern for their friend, worrying and wondering if they’re burdening the poor pink blob with too much. It’s bass prodigies on drunken sake benders teaching Hitori not to be afraid of the crowd, that they’re not an enemy out to get her but a supportive force to cheer her on. It’s Hitori learning from all of this, coming out of her shell, and learning and growing not just as a musician, but as a tightly wound ball of anxiety molded in the shape of a functioning human being. I relate to her so much (along with her friend, the stoic blue-haired guitarist) like I do with Reg Barclay, but unlike this episode I never feel like I am being asked to laugh directly at her. That makes all the difference in the world for anxious blobs like her, Barclay, and I. Empathy and understanding, not mockery and cringe.

That’s why I love Bocchi The Rock!. That’s why, despite finding some unforeseen merits, Hollow Pursuits remains my least favorite episode of Star Trek. The moral of the story is, have grace and patience for the anxious blobs in your lives. We are trying our best out here, despite the brain goblins telling us otherwise.


On the other hand, repeatedly over the runtime of the episode, every one of these moments gets undercut by pulling us back to the other side, by making Barclay our anxious little circus performer to be made the object of fun. It felt like I was in the middle of an emotional tug of war, pulled between sweet utopic moments of understanding Barclay and moments where the point is that he’s cringe. The whiplash has me disoriented, and I think the episode has its heart in the right place when it comes to Barclay. At the very least, the late showrunner of this era of TNG, Michael Pillar, went on record as relating to Barclay both as a social wallflower and for the way he balanced fantasy and reality. Hell, Barclay’s original conception came from Gene Roddenberry himself, who wanted to show just an ordinary human guy on the starship Enterprise that fandom could identify with.

I can acknowledge that the intent of this episode from its creative staff wasn’t to make an anxiety-ridden laughingstock for well-adjusted people to laugh at, but that doesn’t change how viscerally I wince at this episode. These scenes feel as if they are indulging themselves in these moments of secondhand embarrassment that bring all those awful feelings I have as an anxious mess back to the forefront. It could be the case that these are creatives who know and understand this level of anxiety and are reflecting back how us anxious folks think we are being perceived on a bad day. Showing the worst and ugliest parts of anxiety and the human mind before showing how to learn and grow from it to become better, in that typical utopian Star Trek way. If the episode has done that for any anxious people, then it has done a good thing. All I can do is share my perspective, and my perspective is that this hits a nerve ending of insecurities lodged deep within my internal landscape.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑